HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

yourapostasy

3,287 karma · joined October 3, 2011

submissionscomments
yourapostasy··on AutoCodeRover: Autonomous Program Improvement
In short, no.

The ArXiv paper mentions the human developer must supply a unit test (which can conceivably be coded with at least the assistance of an AI agent if not autonomously coded, but their experiment relies upon the former kind of unit test) that issues a pass-fail signal. So the 78% of failures are clearly identified, at the cost of implementing TDD for the Issue. The side effects story is punted upon, but I’d still take this over the nothing we have today.

Of course, over a relatively short amount of time using this, I’d expect to experience the 22% (or whatever the real rate is) success rate to drop asymptotically towards zero as the low hanging fruit of the approach are mined out and it becomes kind of like another linter in our CICD pipelines.

The impact of this tooling upon staff skills development will be interesting to say the least.

yourapostasy··on Diffoscope – In-depth comparison of files, archives, and directories
For those not familiar with meld:

https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/meld/

There is a GitHub repo of it that is now deprecated, this is apparently the official repo. I’m curious how these stack up to other, similar tooling, but for now I’m starting to wonder how much work it would take to modify GNOME Sushi [1] to call one of these utilities when two items are selected in the GNOME Nautilus file manager, and go one step beyond macOS Quick Look (though we would still be missing the Quick Look powerful editing capabilities).

[1] https://www.omgubuntu.co.uk/gnome-sushi-mac-quick-for-ubuntu

yourapostasy··on Infrastructure as code is not the answer (2022)
The network effects benefits of a large population using a common domain specific language and abstraction are easily overlooked when one on the inside of that echo chamber dealing with the warts of that context frame. I’m also not overly fond of the current state of IaC but we have a good enough foundation upon which I have a rough line of sight on a future where we develop better representations going forward, and that alone is enough for me to avoid wholesale tossing it out or halting/slowing its use.
yourapostasy··on AI used well can restore middle class jobs [pdf]
I’d like to see the strong case for autonomous driving being the harbinger of generalized AI laid out. Specialized AI, with varying hardware support, has yet to solve the last-mile of 5-10% of autonomous driving in favorable conditions. In snow, sleet, hail, dusty, smoky, foggy or some rainy conditions, progress has not been commensurate. Yet somehow this is the success template for generalized AI applications. I’m missing the chain of logic here.

A lot of this breathless talk surrounding this turn of AI is so uncomfortably reminiscent of what I’ve seen before in the mainstream the last turns around the 1970’s and 1980’s, and the potential failure mode might not be so different: solving the last 5-10% is tantalizingly close but remains stubbornly out of reach of calls for the “more cowbell” of each era or call to action by the sales legions (currently cowbells look like NVIDIA boards and various counts of AI models be it tokens or what have you), and the last 5-10% is the necessary advance to cross the chasm.

I love and use the tech myself every hour, but it has deep gaps I don’t see being resolved even incrementally between versions or competitors.

yourapostasy··on Baltimore's Key Bridge struck by cargo ship, collapses
This news report [1] confirms there were two pilots at the time of the accident. Baltimore Port runs a dock pilot from the Key Bridge to the port itself, and after the Key Bridge, a harbor pilot who takes the ship (I believe the rule is any vessel > 100 tons, and all non-domestic ships of any tonnage must by Maryland state law be piloted in this manner) out to the mouth of the bay.

The after-accident report and insurer and re-insurer wranglings will be a fascinating read, I'm sure. It will be a miracle if the taxpayers escape unscathed for the rebuilding of the transit spanning the harbor, and it falls entirely upon the insurers and re-insurers.

As dramatic as this accident was though, and the many parallels I can draw from its lessons to software engineering, IT operations, cybersecurity and so on, I'm not as sanguine believing it will really drive home to organization leaderships the evergreen advice to pay down your tech debt, maintenance matters, organizational culture/esprit de corps counts, the operational teams are just as important as the engineering teams, etc.

[1] https://fox59.com/news/national-world/cargo-ship-hits-baltim...

yourapostasy··on A Spark Extinguished
I've learned over the years of traveling and speaking with ethnic Chinese and Chinese nationals that I make my acquaintance with, that there are numerous tragic stories like this in China and throughout the diaspora. Many are only preserved through family oral traditions and many of those will die out with the population decline. I've heard it expressed that modern day China has a lot of spirit (energetic vigor), but is still seeking its soul (embodied contemplative wonderment and compassion for all around ourselves, as opposed to dogmatic spirituality per se), and was struck by how apt that was to political leadership in all nations, and to an equal or lesser extent their peoples, depending upon the nation.
yourapostasy··on They Praised AI at SXSW–and the Audience Started Booing
Can someone please elaborate upon this:

> If the current tech leaders can’t figure this out, they will be wiped away by history—that’s happened before, and will happen again.

When has this happened in history, to who, and what was the context? The examples I can think of were mostly related to technological advancements (mainframe to minicomputer, for example), and not related to general public anger.

yourapostasy··on What does Alan Kay think about LLMs?
I wonder if all of that was in an operating system as described but backed by Nix so we accomplish the NixOS-style reproducibility and configuration time travel, what the developer experience and user experience would be like. Instead of binary blob images, we'd have Nix declaratives and flakes we dissect at will, without fear of wedging the system with the live modifications we make.

Our hardware is sufficiently capable enough these days that I'm curious if we can do this to conventional Smalltalk and Common Lisp system/machine designs to re-imagine them, and bring back a level of tight feedback looped developer experience that has gone underground in the mainstream.

yourapostasy··on What does Alan Kay think about LLMs?
I wonder if all of that was in an operating system as described but backed by Nix so we accomplish the NixOS-style reproducibility and configuration time travel, what the developer experience and user experience would be like. Instead of binary blob images, we'd have Nix declaratives and flakes we dissect at will, without fear of wedging the system with the live modifications we make.
yourapostasy··on Sweden Is a NATO Member
Strategic reaction doesn’t necessarily mean a capital atomic strike. It can be a range of responses that have been off the table during the Ukraine war so far. Switching the entire economic output to a wartime posture for example, is just as strategic.

I think it is in Russian elites’ and Putin’s self interest to continue the status quo and grind down the West in Ukraine, plunder it, and leave the long-term consequences to Russia in someone else’s hands. I’m doubtful they’ll actually use atomics unless the walls are violently closing in. Even China backed way off when Putin loosely waved around nuclear rhetoric in the opening months of the war, and asked in nervous diplomatic speak, “chill, broseph”.

yourapostasy··on Someone stole a Jasper radio station’s 200-foot tower, owner says
Container ship dock line snaps on the other hand...
yourapostasy··on Vesuvius Challenge 2023 Grand Prize awarded: we can read the first scroll
I’m now wavering a bit on my earlier dismissal of people freezing their bodies for an indeterminate future revival. I could probably get into a science fiction story with this premise:

Instead of relying upon machinery, some zillionaire has their body dry frozen and stashed in a lunar south pole crater, with a foundation funding interstellar propulsion research to move the body to the coldest stable points discovered along the way towards the Boomerang Nebula (1° Kelvin) and research to revive back from burnt-crisp state.

The foundation incites all sorts of advancements along the way like working out practical fusion and ever more exotic energy generation, AGI, gravity manipulation, Drexlerian nanotech, Dyson swarm, star wisps, self-modifying bodies and so on, in its quixotic quest to fulfill its mandate.

yourapostasy··on Why Certificate Lifecycle Automation Matters
Can anyone with good experiences with a commercially-supported ACME stack recommend a vendor they’re happy with, where the stack was integrated into their own in-house certificate authority? I’m especially looking for vendors that have very good documentation and tracing introspection to let our own engineers who read the documentation rapidly troubleshoot the stack, and our own developers build robust integrations to the client to rotate the certificates.
yourapostasy··on Shoplifting and frustrated customers plague self-checkout
To be fair, sometimes simply some of us live in low-trust areas and/or micro-cultures and the machines have to be set to correspondingly annoying compensatory configurations. While I suspect Japan doesn’t have widespread scan-as-you-shop or Amazon Go/Fresh for cultural acceptance reasons, I’ve noticed the areas I’ve seen these in my travels have generally been what I would characterize as high trust. High agency, high trust cultures are quite a breath of fresh air to immerse oneself within, though I’m curious to see the flip side of that “grass is greener” sentiment.
yourapostasy··on Henry Kissinger Has Died
> ...was an almost superhuman ass-kisser.

This piques my curiosity. Does anyone have the mechanical specifics of how this worked, as in actual conversations when Kissinger was in his element that demonstrated this quality in action?

Teens today who have never experienced Steve Jobs' Reality Distortion Field normally don't believe my shorthand description of the RDF like the above encapsulated description of "superhuman ass-kisser". Fortunately, I can show them the historical records, giving them not just the video of his meticulously-rehearsed MacWorld presentations, but the context of the enormous stakes he was playing with, to change their minds. And to teach them that what seems extraordinary can be accomplished with extraordinary effort, if one is willing to relentlessly study and practice.

So whenever I hear about extraordinary abilities, I'm always curious to see how they worked up close, mechanically, in dissect-able action.

yourapostasy··on Fat OCI images are a cultural problem
This rant is all well and good, but the folks who really need to hear this are the sales and marketing folks at the third-party software vendors who happily burble that “we’re containerizing/containerized!”. Then you peer into their implementation only to find out they popped a VM into that sucker and called it a day. When you get on a call with them, you find out really containerizing their product (of which “distroless” is only one of many, many re-architecting and re-designing their product should go through) is nowhere on their roadmaps, because too few customers are demanding it.

We might need a “X Factors” list to popularize what checkboxes properly “containerized” products should tick, to help move the needle.

yourapostasy··on Interactive Common Lisp Development
> But we can do everything in between too (inspect the running app, change it a bit, change it a whole lot (while staying in sync with local source code), use images to speed-up development etc).

Is anyone aware of SBCL or LispWorks-based tooling that integrates with ServiceNow CHG records to record and perform these kinds of changes to automatically create an audit trail of such changes in a CHG record as the Lisp image is manipulated for emergency changes?

yourapostasy··on A failed AI girlfriend product, and my lessons
A communications/semantic Kessler Syndrome. This likely boosts the signal gain of memes without pushing any more data down the pipe.
yourapostasy··on Migrating to OpenTelemetry
Have you checked out Jaeger [1]? It is lightweight enough for a personal project, open source, and featureful enough to really help "turn on the lightbulb" with other engineers to show them the difference between logging/monitoring and tracing.

[1] https://www.jaegertracing.io/

yourapostasy··on Migrating to OpenTelemetry
> ...with AWS all roads lead to Cloudwatch, and everything is so much better.

Most of my clients are not in the product-market fit for AWS CloudWatch, because most of their developers don't have the development, testing and operational maturity/discipline to use CloudWatch cost-effectively (this is at root an organization problem, but let's not go off onto that giant tangent). So the only realistic tracing strategy we converged upon to recommend for them is "grab everything, and retain it up to the point in time we won't be blamed for not knowing root cause" (which in some specific cases can be up to years!), while we undertake the long journey with them to upskill their teams.

This would make using CloudWatch everywhere rapidly climb up into the top three largest line item in the AWS bill, easily justifying spinning that tracing functionality in-house. So we wind up opting into self-managed tooling like Elastic Observability or Honeycomb where the pricing is friendlier to teams in unfortunate situations that need to start with everything for CYA, much as I would like to stay within CloudWatch.

Has anyone found a better solution to these use cases where the development maturity level is more prosaic, or is this really the best local maxima at the industry's current SOTA?

yourapostasy··on Making Hard Things Easy
>My dream is to make everything visualizable at runtime.

Check out demos of the old Lisp Machines, [1] is a brief overview demo, [2] links to a timestamp with a view of some simple diagramming, but I’ve seen TI-Symbolics beasts routinely display complex relationships in Lisp code on their massive (for the time) bitmapped screens. The limitation was the end user managing the visualization complexity.

With open source llvm, clang and similar making available abstract syntax trees and even semantic analysis and type checking results, LLM’s assisting with decompiling binary blobs, and modern hardware (goggles, graphics cards, and so on), I sometimes wonder how close we can come to reproducing that aspect of the Lisp Machine experience on open source operating systems.

[1] https://youtu.be/o4-YnLpLgtk

[2] https://youtu.be/jACcgLfyiyM?t=43m52s

yourapostasy··on 90% of companies say they’ll return to the office by the end of 2024
I think this is a promising approach. My version of it would be to switch to the Bell Labs / Xerox PARC layout style of individual engineer offices surrounding a central conference room area. Couple that with a genuine leadership backing and incentives promoting mentorship for senior individual contributors to come in and mentor juniors in the physical offices. When those juniors are promoted to a sufficient level of demonstrated consistent self-sufficiency and outcome-driven behavior over a number of years, the new more senior position includes the right to go full remote.

In any case, in my personal experience with clients' engineering organizations, those where you have to micromanage to the point going to the office is necessary to manage well don't accomplish much in any case, and tend to produce technical debt at a much faster pace, than those with much tighter company culture cohesion around self-motivated engineers. I've concluded over the decades it is due to a highly useful information compression dynamic leading to an even more useful abstraction interface only possible in a high trust environment.

yourapostasy··on Blacksmithing is alive and well in Kentucky
> ...the only thing I am afraid of is the chainsaw. That thing can do significant damage even slightest mistake when being used...

After you carefully read the instructions, wear 9-layer wraparound chaps, cut-retardant shirt, forestry helmet, and chainsaw gloves, and you pay attention like as if you are on a gun range, you will have reasonably mitigated the risks. Most accidents happen when people grow complacent and don't take what they are doing seriously; even with all the PPE you can still screw up in a serious way if you aren't careful, deliberate and paying attention. I encourage anyone who is scared of chainsaws to read the literature. Even occasional users can make it a safe activity with some diligence.

yourapostasy··on RadioShack’s new owner plots old comeback strategy
> I don't see this as a winning strategy.

I wonder if most of their storefronts are leased or outright carried on their books (shades of McDonald’s strategy). If they own the dirt most of their storefronts sit upon (they have someone in corporate who manages real estate, but I can’t tell if that is just overseeing corporate property like distribution centers and offices or they pulled a McDonald’s), in some circles the real estate play is the asset and anything else is cash flow to keep the lights on.

yourapostasy··on The worst programmer I know
This is why software craftsmanship is rarely recognized. When you build with craftsmanship so features are easy and fast to add on top of what you built because you thoughtfully the most likely ramifications of the current requirements within reason, operational excellence is easy to accomplish because you sat down with front line operators and took the time to understand their incentives and daily operations pain points from a first-person perspective, and so on, you aren’t the one who is recognized with the commensurate credit, those who benefit from your work in the future are the ones who grab the limelight as if they did your work, unless the leadership are themselves highly technical (and many times, not even then). Incentives currently in most of my clients are mostly aligned to the fulfillment of keywords and not an outcome.

“Produce a procedure documentation” gets keyword fulfilled into “here is a document with some steps”, instead of “here is a procedure we wrote, used spelling and grammar checker upon [I’m still shocked so few take the few seconds to correct as they go], run through an automated editor, then iterated through random people from the user population until someone who never saw it before accomplishes the procedure without assistance”.

Some startups succeed because they’re forced into conscientiously thinking through these ramifications in just the right contexts because they’re so close to the coal face. It is also possible to overdo this in the wrong context and end up bikeshedding.

yourapostasy··on OpenTelemetry in 2023
If you’re using Honeycomb, how did you find their solution’s developer/DevOps engineer ergonomics, their support, and their overall experience?
yourapostasy··on 80% of bosses say they regret earlier return-to-office plans
> Earning median wage most of that goes towards rent. There's nothing left to save. Move further away and you lose big on earnings.

If you are in your teens or 20's in a median wage income, then I advise considering vanlife grinding towards FIRE. I spent so much time in libraries or labs at that stage of my life that in hindsight, I should have dismissed the stigma of "homelessness" and adopted vanlife, scraped enough together for a duplex down payment, rent both sides out initially until one side is paid off, and then settle in that side should I want out of vanlife at that point.

yourapostasy··on My $0->$100M->$0 in 5 years story
> Quorum decision making in those circumstances keeps those things in check.

Depends upon the composition of the quorum. If the quorum is mostly "eh it works, just ship it", jugaad, chabuduo, corner cutting engineers, then I've witnessed adverse results.

Conscientious engineering that delicately balances trade-offs is difficult to teach, and poorly discerned by most casual observers (even other conscientious engineers casually observing) in the short term.

yourapostasy··on Binance lays off over 1k Employees
In larger companies, for some values of “talented” that comprises non-technical factors like political acumen, yes. If the “talented” label is meant as a shorthand for some kind of meritocratic scale, then I have my doubts about that.

I’ve long since lost my astonishment at the revealed preferences in layoff selection criteria. It isn’t a complete Machiavellian free-for-all, but merit and fine-grained logic usually don’t prevail at the top of the criteria list in the trenches.

yourapostasy··on How to listen to database changes using Postgres triggers in elixir
One of my clients uses a tool operating within the same space as Debezium called Qlik Replicate to listen for log-based CDC to replicate the data to a different database. The challenge we found was that not everything was recorded into the redo log, like DELETE's wrapped inside functions in one vendor's database. There was a long list of caveats we eventually uncovered beyond even the documented ones. This challenge arises even if performing CDC between two databases from the same vendor on the same version, somewhat narrowing the use cases we could apply CDC upon.

If you must care about bit-level accurate replication, catching gaps after the replication completes is we concluded after a year of chasing that chimera a deep rabbit hole with an event horizon that constantly recedes into the future. If you can tolerate some replication errors and can tolerate not knowing where they happen without a lot of investigation, then CDC works great.

CDC gets us close, but I'm still looking for someone who is working upon covering the edge cases that redo logs alone do not address.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →