HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ywvcbk

385 karma · joined September 3, 2024

submissionscomments
ywvcbk··on Christopher Columbus may have been Spanish and Jewish, documentary says
The Portuguese were doing the rational thing and taking the much rational and safer option.

Was anyone really going west before Columbus? Of course I assume the Portuguese might have discovered Brazil eventually anyway because of the ocean currents

ywvcbk··on Christopher Columbus may have been Spanish and Jewish, documentary says
> and the vikings (presumably Leif Erikson)

That’s closer to a piece of historical trivia though, the Viking discovery of North America had very limited impact and nobody in Europe was aware of it or understood the significance.

What Columbus did led to dozens of other expeditions almost immediately. Within a few decades the largest the New World states were subjugated by Europeans and some of the worst recorded epidemics in human history swept the continent decimating societies which hadn’t even had any direct contact with Europeans yet.

He also allowed Spain to become the preeminent European power for the next century or so.

How is that not extremely significant?

ywvcbk··on Christopher Columbus' remains found after 500 years as DNA analysis ends mystery
> using standards that should not be applied

There were plenty of people willing to apply those standards back in those days, even if they rarely had significant political influence outside of a handful of cases. e.g. Las Casas (almost a contemporary of Columbus) even managed to convince the Spanish state to pass legislation in 1542 that might be even considered progressive by the standards of the of the 1700s or even 1800s (of course it wasn’t necessarily very effective).

Why do you want to erase them from history?

> we are led to be miserable in everything.

Are we? How does saying that Columbus was greedy and cruel (even by contemporary standards) somehow makes us miserable? Seems entirely tangential..

ywvcbk··on Christopher Columbus may have been Spanish and Jewish, documentary says
> out occurred at exactly the same time that Columbus sailed for the East (by going west).

Which is notable why exactly? Surely both Columbus and his investors were hoping to return.

Who would give all that money to a descendant of Jewish converts let alone someone who might have been affected by the expulsion decree directly?

Columbus might have had Jewish ancestors a few generations back but I don’t think we can conclude anything else based on these findings. Especially not that he or his parents were actually practicing Jews.

ywvcbk··on Columbus' DNA suggests he was a Sephardic Jew from the western Mediterranean
> this is ostensibly a tech forum

There are plenty of non tech related posts on the front-page all the time?

> barely readable

Who even read anything besides the headline these days?

ywvcbk··on Columbus' DNA suggests he was a Sephardic Jew from the western Mediterranean
> He left Spain in August, the same week that Jews were kicked out. This explains why he left Spain

Extremely absurd statement that makes absolutely no sense at all. Surely his investors expected him to return?

If his (possible) Jewish origin would have been know surely that would have came out during one of the lawsuits between the Crown and his descendants: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pleitos_colombinos

> but it’s now clear this was due most likely due to forced conversion.

Or that his grandparents or even grand-grandparents were converts?

ywvcbk··on Christopher Columbus may have been Spanish and Jewish, documentary says
He and his son would have faced severe discrimination, wouldn’t even be allowed to hold public office and technically his descendants wouldn’t even emigrate to the Americans had it been publicly known that he was a descendant of Jewish converts (regardless of his religious views).

Surely that’s something the Spanish Crown would have used in the courtroom, considering that his descendants were engaged in a ~20 year lawsuit against the crown (which they won)?

ywvcbk··on Christopher Columbus may have been Spanish and Jewish, documentary says
> He was incredibly religious. In his Catholicism

Possibly as a way to conceal his background? Of course that’s pure speculation and it wasn’t as bad yet until later in the the 1500s but Spain became an extremely racist society, people who couldn’t prove that they weren’t descendants of Jewish or Muslim converts were often barred from holding political office or even testify in court etc.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limpieza_de_sangre#:~:text=O....

ywvcbk··on Christopher Columbus may have been Spanish and Jewish, documentary says
> r, is how the same year Columbus sailed the ocean blue, 1492,

How could that be related in any way? Presumably his investors did hope he would return and be allowed to enter the country?

> Columbus must not have been very religious

He was. As far as we can tell he was a very devout Catholic. Even if he had some Jewish origin (e.g. his grand/great grandparents were converts) that must have been a closely concealed secret and certainly not something that was publicly known.

ywvcbk··on Christopher Columbus may have been Spanish and Jewish, documentary says
Why would anyone ever think that it could have been anything but a coincidence?

Who would have sponsored his expedition knowing that Columbus would be legally banned from entering the country if he was successful? That just seems silly…

ywvcbk··on Christopher Columbus may have been Spanish and Jewish, documentary says
> His choice to set sail for the New World on August 2, 1492,

He could have just moved to Italy or the Low Countries?

> does suggest he may have not converted yet.

And he did while he was in the Americas? Why would the Castilian crown sponsor an expedition led by a known Jew and even make him governor of the newly discovered territories (note that in a few decades even converted descendants of Jews or Muslims were banned from emigrating to the new world after a few decades)

ywvcbk··on Christopher Columbus may have been Spanish and Jewish, documentary says
> AFAIK they welcomed converts with open arms (especially Muslim ones),

While that was seemingly true in the 1400s when ex-Jewish Conversos had sometimes significant economic and even political power. That had changed by the 1500s, antisemitism (same applying to Muslim converts) became much more focused on race and not just religion.

Conversos and Moriscos were persecuted and discriminated culminating in the expulsion of 1609 (which targeted hundreds of thousands of people who had technically been Christians for the past ~100 years).

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limpieza_de_sangre

In some cases it was pretty extreme and not that dissimilar to the one-drop rule in the US (and the decentralized pseudo-segregation wasn’t that dissimilar either).

Descendants of Jewish and Muslim converts were even banned from emigrating into the American Colonies a few decades after Columbus.

It likely wasn’t as bad yet in the 1490s but had Columbus Jewish origin (assume that’s actually true) been know he probably would have faced significant barriers in holding political office or even attracting investment for his expeditions.

ywvcbk··on DNA study confirms Christopher Columbus’s remains are entombed in Seville
Yes, I knew all that. "Found" is still the the wrong word to use.
ywvcbk··on Christopher Columbus' remains found after 500 years as DNA analysis ends mystery
> deranged?

Can you elaborate what do you mean by that?

ywvcbk··on DNA study confirms Christopher Columbus’s remains are entombed in Seville
> was one of the most evil men

> If anyone's corpse deserves a pissing on, it would be his.

That's a strong statement. I mean he was obviously very cruel and greedy but I don't see how he was particularly exceptional in that way compared to thousands of other historical figures (we can call all of them one of the most evil men in history but that just makes the term meaningless..).

Even in the same ~50 year timeframe his direct "achievements" pale to compared to those of Cortés, Pizzaro.

ywvcbk··on DNA study confirms Christopher Columbus’s remains are entombed in Seville
Seems like a nonsensical click-bait title.

They found his remains by confirming that they are indeed buried in the tomb with his name on it?

ywvcbk··on Valve says Steam users don't own a thing, GOG says its games can't be taken away
I’m sure most could if they really wanted to. They just don’t.
ywvcbk··on A modest critique of Htmx
I’m not saying that part is hard or particularly relevant. It takes a lot more time than 5 minutes to figure out how the new framework and/or build system works and all the implications of that, though.
ywvcbk··on A modest critique of Htmx
Django is quite stable and monolithic. If you used it 10-15 years ago and wanted to build something new it wouldn’t take too much time for you to readjust. With JS you’d be entering a new world and chances are that almost everything you can remember is now an “anti-pattern” and starting on a clean slate might be easier..

Frontend is a mishmash of random components and packages, unless you are 100% sure in advance what are you going to use and and do chances are that you’ll run into with issues with the latest version of package X not working with build system Y due to cryptic incomprehensible reasons unless you make sure to stick with the latest “mainstream” trends (which seem to change ever 1-2 years).

ywvcbk··on A modest critique of Htmx
Every few years I end up wanting to build some random/hobby webapp and each time the official docs have changed drastically.

Use CRA + webpack, now use Vite instead, you know what? Screw CRA you should just immediately jump to Next.js instead (which seemed like a huge overkill initially, but actually seems kind of nice).

Unless you’re working on a single project or continuously following what’s new it just seems confusing and overwhelming. If I got comfortable with CRA and came back after a year or two should I still use it for a new project even if it’s bo longer the default? Will new packages/etc. still work with it? Maybe… who knows. I just know that I now have to waste time figuring that out.

ywvcbk··on A modest critique of Htmx
Now store all of those states in an URL or some other place that would allow you to recreate the full view after the website is reloaded or in a new session.
ywvcbk··on A modest critique of Htmx
It’s an app with a bunch of random components, though not really a website.

If you want an actual website with proper routing and possibly SSR and want to use “plain” React with no additional libraries you’ll have to waste a lot of time reinventing the wheel.

ywvcbk··on The profit-obsessed monster destroying American emergency rooms
It’s kind of like Obamacare without a huge number of compromises

> non-profit private insurance

Only base/minimum coverage, the same companies still offer extended/supplemental plans with no such limitations.

Also is the for profit part really that important? Profit margins are capped and even if all insurance companies became non profit and costs went down went down by another 5-10% or so at most, would that fundamentally change anything? The extreme inefficiency seems like a mich bigger issue.

ywvcbk··on What Excessive Screen Time Does to the Adult Brain
No, only actually candlelight is fine. Ideally an open fire. However reading itself is unnatural so it can only lead to negative outcomes..
ywvcbk··on What excessive screen time does to the adult brain
> smartphone use" in most of the population but here

Presumably you don’t think that all the white collar workers who aren’t in tech spend all of their work-hours scrolling tiktok/etc.?

ywvcbk··on OpenAI completes deal that values company at $157B
> Their economics are structurally better than googles assuming

Are they? I would guess that the cost per query for Google, even back then was insignificant compared to how must OpenAI is spending on GPU compute for every prompt. Are they even breaking even on the $20 subscriptions?

During their growth phase Google could make nothing from most of their users and still have very high gross margins.

OpenAI not only has to attract enough new users but to also ensure that they are bringing more revenue than they cost. Which isn’t really a problem Google or FB ever faced.

Of course presumably more optimized models and faster hardware might solve that longterm. However consumers expectations will likely keep increasing as well and OpenAI has a bunch of competitors willing to undercut them (e.g. they have to keep continuously spending enough money to stay ahead of “open/free” models and then there is Google who would probably prefer to cannibalize their search business themselves than let someone else do it).

> in fact as bezos demonstrated with Amazon for many years, profit is an indication you’ve run out of uses for capital to grow.

Was Amazon primarily funding that growth using their own revenue or cash from external investors? Because that makes a massive difference which makes both cases hardly comparable (Uber might be a better example).

ywvcbk··on OpenAI completes deal that values company at $157B
To cost per user for Google and FB was/is almost insignificant(relative to LLMs). So all the ad revenue was almost free cash.

It’s not even clear if OpenAI is breaking even with the $20 subscription just on GPU/compute costs alone (the newer models seem to be a lot faster so maybe they are). So incrementally growing their revenue might be very painful if they keep making the UX worse with extra ads while still simultaneously losing money on every user.

Presumably the idea is that costs will go down as HW became faster and models themselves more optimized/efficient. But LLMs themselves already seem to almost be a commodity so it might become tricky for OpenAI to compete with a bunch of random services using open models that are offering the same thing (while spending a fraction on R&D)

ywvcbk··on OpenAI completes deal that values company at $157B
I guess the difference (at least at comparable development stages) is that a single user query cost almost nothing for Google compared to how much money running ChatGPT costs.

I wouldn’t be surprised if OpenAI were still losing money even with the same CPM that Google search has.

ywvcbk··on OpenAI completes deal that values company at $157B
> the stuff to be shoveled

They are spending a lot on shovels but it’s not clear that there is that much “stuff” (consumer demand) to be shoveled.

VC money can only take you so far, you still need to have an actual way of making money.

LLMs might effectively replace Google but they are already a commodity. It’s really not clear what moat OpenAI can build when there are already a bunch of proprietary/open models that are more or less on the same level.

That basically means that they can’t charge much above datacenter cost + small premium longterm and won’t be able achieve margins that are high enough to justify current valuation.

ywvcbk··on OpenAI completes deal that values company at $157B
> 5-10 years from now

> models of Gpt4 capabilities or similar

I took Apple how many years to change their bass config memory from 8 GB to 16? Somewhere between 8 and 10..

Regardless, I’m not sure running reasonably advanced models locally will necessarily become that common anytime soon on mainstream devices. $20 per month isn’t that much compared to the much higher HW costs, of course it’s not obvious that OpenAI/etc. can make any money longterm by charging that.

← PreviousPage 7 of 11Next →