3,123 karma · joined December 15, 2013
Like, are you seriously asking whether scientists have looked into whether high temperatures and low rainfall cause dry forests and whether dry forests burn more easily? Do you really think it is a big unsolved question in science whether hot air dries stuff and whether dry stuff burns more easily than wet stuff, and maybe it's actually dry stuff that makes air hot and the fire causes the things to have been less wet before they burned?
Ah, I see, you have the highest possible qualifications in the medical field!
> instead of giving them a strong motivation to resolve the underlying cause.
OK, so, please explain, then, how you treat, for example, various thyroid problems that are the underlying cause for increased body weight and that no real treatment is known for? Given that you are so highly qualified as to call bullshit on a medical professional, you sure will be able to offer more than telling everyone who has superficially similar symptoms to yours that they are too stupid to cure themselves because they don't do what you have done?
No, the number of failures is completely meaningless, just as the number of successes is. The only thing that is relevant is the ratio of success vs. failure, somehow weighted appropriately based on the certainty claimed for the prediction and to correct for duplicated predictions.
Given how much fraud is happening with customer data (that is: it being acquired under a pretense and then used for a different purpose), I very much doubt it.
> require more physical product be printed, and are less convenient for users than online solutions.
Except that's kinda orthogonal. The paper solution is easier to demonstrate to be free of back doors, but there is no reason why you couldn't build an "online solution" that doesn't do any tracking. You could just hand out random tokens without ever associating them with a transaction, and then accept sets of ten of those to redeem for a rebate, say.
Like, it would be perfectly possible for a merchant to encrypt the transaction description with a public key of the customer, and their bank only submitting the encrypted record with the amount and the account to debit to the card issuer, who would debit the account and pass on the encrypted record to their customer.
That's just a random idea, but the point is that you could achieve much the same result with a lot less data collection if you actually cared to.
Also, I don't hate them (the ones that collect data, that is) because they push inefficiency onto the customer, but because I have to pay more so other people get paid for helping corporations manipulate me more effectively.
By preventing greater harm to others that would result if you didn't. Seriously, that wasn't obvious?
Also, making a language X parser accept anything that is not in fact language X is nothing but a terrible idea. If there is one thing that standards are good for, it's interoperability. And if there is one thing that hurts interoperability, it's having different implementations of supposedly the same standard accept and reject different inputs. That's how you get websites that work in one browser, but not another, because one browser was so helpful to make up some meaning for your creative markup instead of rejecting it with an error message, which obviously helps you absolutely nothing with the next browser that is of a different opinion. If you think the spec is stupid, you have to change the spec, if you don't manage to do that, you still should implement the spec, because interoperability is more important than whether your program can read some input that isn't JSON and that therefore no other JSON parser is guaranteed to understand anyway.
1. Well, one thing that IT security professionals surely don't use is "cyber", that's a term from the snake oil corner of the industry.
2. People in IT security most definitely do not distinguish between security problems that the manufacturer intended as a feature and security problems that were caused any other way. You create a model of things you want to protect, and if a property of a product violates that, then that is the definition of a security problem in your overall system, obviously. The only difference would be whether you report it as a vulnerability or not, as that would obviously be pointless for intentional, publicly announced features.
> It's not a good analogy for a whole host of other reasons, but that's one of them.
Really, even that would not be a good reason, as it smells of essentialism.
> You're using a nonstandard definition of computer security. That's your prerogative, but don't be surprised if it continues to cause confusion for those you interact with.
No, I am using the exact standard definition, and the only sensible one at that. It obviously makes no sense to have a definition of "security" that says nothing about whether your system is secure. If you consider Google having access to your data a threat in your threat model, then whatever properties of your system that give Google access to your data is a security problem in your system, it's as simple as that.
The only thing that matters is whether your overall system reaches its protection goals or not, not whether some component by itself would be considered vulnerable in some abstract sense. And that obviously applies in the opposite direction as well: If you run some old software with known vulnerabilities that you can not patch, but you somehow isolate it sufficiently that those vulnerabilities can not be used by an attacker to violate your protection goals, then that system is considered secure despite the presence of vulnerabilities.
Well, but do they actually have your permission?
> If it was done secretly then it would be a security problem, but without secrecy or lying, it's simply Google not living up to your privacy preferences.
Well, for one, are they not doing their things secretly? Is the mere fact that you can find out about it enough to call it "not secret"? Is the mere fact that you didn't refuse where you didn't even really have an option to refuse permission?
Let's suppose a food manufacturer put a new pudding on the market. Included with the package is a 500-page explanation of everything that you need to know about it. Somewhere on those 500 pages, all ingredients are listed. Most are mentioned using the most unusual names. Among the ingredients is a strong carcinogen. A carcinogen that doesn't contribute anything to the taste, the look, or anything else you would value. All it does is make producing the pudding cheaper to produce.
Now, a biochemist could obviously know what is going on if they were to read the 500 pages, so it's not secret that the carcinogen is in the pudding. Also, the packaging says that you agree to the conditions of use in the 500 pages if you open the package, so you gave them permission to feed you that carcinogen.
Would you agree, then, that this pudding is not a health safety risk, it's simply the manufacturer not living up to your health preferences?
Also, I don't really understand how permission can make something not a security problem. It seems like that's all backwards?! I generally would first check a product for security problems, and then give permission based on the presence or absence of security problems. And one of the security risks to check for would be software leaking information to whereever I don't want information to leak to. Why should the fact that the manufacturer of some piece of software announces or doesn't announce that they leak certain information have any relevance to whether I condier the leak a security problem? If I don't want my information in the hands of Google, then how am I any more secure against that leak just because Google told me about it?
In other words: They do not understand that they are losing all liberties?
> It's been too many years of revelations and media campaigns. I think at this point we just have to admit that most people don't mind, not that they don't know.
I very much disagree. Do you have an idea what media people consume? What absolute bullshit they are being fed? Do you really think that people on that basis have an accurate understanding of where all of this will lead?
> Right, but where do you draw the line.
You don't, there is no need to, it's not a binary matter. You might for pragmatic reasons in order to have terms to use for effective communication, but there is no actual line between "dictatorship" and "democracy", between "libertarianism" and "totalitarianism", it's a scale with many steps in between the two extremes. The point is that just because something might be considered a democracy under some pragmatic definition, doesn't mean it's therefore equivalent to everything else that you might label a democracy.
> Did the germans in 1933 think they have a democracy? Do Turks or Russians today think they have a democracy?
I think that's somewhat the wrong question to ask, in that it assumes "the Germans", "the Turks", or "the Russians" to be homogeneous groups. There most definitely were and are lots of people in all of those societies who would not consider their political system a functional democracy.
> It's easy to tell post-facto, or from the outside, not so easy when it's happening in real time.
Well, but is that actually true? If you understand power structures somewhat, it's not really that hard to see, is it? It seems to me this is much more a matter of competence than of your location in time or space. While it may be hard to get the full picture of what is going on, it's not really that hard to see whether you are free to say whatever you want, to inform yourself about whatever you want, to vote securely, i.e., whether the structural prerequesites for a democracy are there. It's just that a lot of people are not competent at recognizing what authoritarianism looks like and are more than willing to accept any authoritarian apologetics they are presented with.
> Do the UK or US think they have a liberal democracy ? absolutely. Is that 100% true? less clear
But do they? As above: I am pretty sure a significant proportion of people don't think that, at least not without reservations. And a large section of the public wouldn't even know what you mean by "liberal democracy" as opposed to just "democracy", so you can not really meaningfully say that they think they live in a liberal democracy. They would understand your question to mean "can you vote?", which they would, correctly so based on their understanding of the question, answer with "yes".
I think it might be helpful to draw an analogy with religion: Many religious people have a very warped understanding of reality and in particular of how to understand reality. They simply lack the competence to understand the failures in their reasoning. They think they do understand the world in terms of their preferred fictional story, but they don't realize it's all fictional. So, based on their rather confused understanding of the world, they then demand that slavery should be upheld, or that gay people should be oppressed, or that women must not be allowed to control their own bodies, or whatever the case may be, because they think that those are the right things to do. But then, there is a not insignificant group of people who overcome their religion, who come to understand how reality actually works and how it can actually be understood. And with that understanding usually comes a rejection of their previous political stance, because they now understand the actual consequences of their former ideas. These are not people who are actually fundamentally OK with the damage they were doing before, they simply were lacking an understanding of how their actions were damaging, because based on their previous fictional world view, they were doing the right thing to prevent bad things from happening.
You have to consider that people might just be incompetent at this democracy thing, rather than that they all have an understanding that reflects all the things that they could know if they were paying attention to the right sources that you might be paying attention to.
Yes, precisely there.
> Generally, we only enter the realm of security of the information leak is secret or unintentional, neither of which is the case here.
So, you are telling me the user is intending the information leak? I'm not sure I understand: You say it's not a security matter if the "leak" is intentional. But then, if a user is transmitting information intentionally ... why would you call that a leak?
Or do you mean the leak is intended by Google or whoever and that is why it's not a security problem?! But then, what if a hacker intentionally installs a back door on your system and uses that to leak your information ... then that wouldn't be a security problem either, would it? Or is that where the "secret" part comes in, and it would only be a security problem if the hacker didn't tell you that they stole all your data?
So, you think that the general public understands what it is like to live in a police state, how corruption wastes resources that they otherwise could benefit from, what negative consequences they themselves can expect further down the road?
If you ask me, most people are not even really aware of the things you list. Most people believe those things are a small necessary evil that you need to ensure safety, or individual mistakes that happen, and and it's not something they would ever experience themselves, because they believe that the state is fair and friendly and would only ever do such things to people who really did bad things, which they themselves obviously aren't, as any officer would immediately recognize. People have no fucking clue how power structures work, how their data is actually being used, how bad corruption can get, how inhuman governments can act against them. They have no fucking clue right up to the moment where they are the victim and they are totally surprised what is happening to them.
> Authoritarianism has gradations and is not incompatible with democracy. Democracy may protect from extreme authoritarianism but it doesn't guarantee liberalism.
How isn't that the exact same "but structurally sound buildings have burned down!" response as before? Nobody is claiming that democracy guarantees liberalism, rather this is all about the fact that you can not have democracy without liberalism. Democracies are perfectly capable of ending liberalism, and have done so many times, but with it they necessarily end democracy. Either people can make free decision in their own best interest, or they have to follow what the authority dictates. A democracy in which authoritarianism rules is only a democracy in name, but not in function, just as the GDR was. If the dictator tells you who you have to vote for, that is not a democracy, no matter how much you get to vote.
How is that a response to my suspicion that people don't understand the risks of authoritarianism? You are just repeating that people do not object to living under surveillance, which is exactly what I said, while you are not responding at all to me pointing out that that may well be because they don't understand what is happening, rather than because they understand what is coming and are fine with it.
> Ostensibly, democracies help to avoid fascism and complete concentration of power , but democracy itself is not enough to guarantee freedom. Democracies have voted in the world's worst fascists.
How is that a response to authoritarianism not being compatible with democracy? It's like if I said that fire is not compatible with structural integritry, and you are countering that many a structurally sound building has burned down. Yeah, they have, and I very much doubt many of them were structurally sound afterwards.
Well, is it really, though? I mean, no doubt there is a thing that people call "surveillance democracy", and I would agree that it's actually a distinguishable thing.
But for one, just because something is called "democracy", doesn't make it a democracy, so the question would be: What makes a democracy a democracy, and would a "surveillance democracy" fit those criteria?
But also: Is a "surveillance democracy" even a place where authoritarian control has gotten out of hand yet? Maybe as long as you could still vote the authoritarians out of office, it's not out of hand yet? But then, what if there is actually no real way to achieve this, for whatever reason, and those places are destined for a situation where it is generally accepted that the authoritarians can not be voted out of office, even when people might ultimately change their mind about that whole authoritarianism thing? Maybe then it is out of hand after all? But then, is democracy actually fine if it is unavoidably destined for a place where it is impossible for a majority to elect a new government?
Your analysis so far seems not too far from a line of thought that would conclude that the GDR was a democracy (they had elections, and they even called themselves democratic!)--not sure whether you would agree with that, but the GDR sure was and is not considered a democracy by many.
> most people are on board with UK level surveillance
But are they really? My impression is rather that people simply have no fucking clue what surveillance does or what the risks are. So, while it might well be true that most people don't think of surveillance as a problem right now, that doesn't answer the question of whether people are actually OK with it, as in what their opinion would be once they might be directly confronted with the consequences.
And that was my point: There sure are and have been plenty of places where people are not happy with authoritarianism anymore, and those do not tend to be the places where people just vote the authoritarianism out. Authoritarianism is not compatible with democracy, by its definition: It is kindof fine just as long as there is still enough democracy left to potentially remove the authoritarians, so people don't realize the danger they are in, but it becomes unbearable exatly at the point where that power does not exist anymore, because that is also the point at which the authoritarians don't have to care about public opinion much anymore.
In other words: Nothing is dangerous, because there is always another way to achieve the same thing if your resources are unlimited. Seriously?
> There are apps on phone with full encryption, there are mesh app that require no setup. There are custom roms for android with 100% focus security and privacy.
In other words: There are ways for individuals who understand the situation to limit their participation, therefore what is actually happening is of no concern, no matter where it actually leads. Seriously?
> Also is tracking bad? If we ignore the privacy fanatics, all the good that location tracking has given us far outways all the bad stuff.
Could you substantiate that, maybe?
> Also everyone seems to love the idea giving people a voice but does a 360 when they realize other people can have completely opposite radical ideas too.
In other words: People who want people to have a voice should be happy when people who want to shut up everyone who isn't like them are promoting their ideas? Seriously?
And how is democracy doing in places where authoritation control has gotten out of hand? After all, you are claiming that democracy is not in danger. So, have people who noticed that they weren't that keen on authoritarianism after all regularly voted the authoritarians out of office successfully, then?
Well, great?!
> (security)
Erm ... no?
> than to know what I'm doing (privacy)
Privacy is not about what your software knows, it's about who else gets access to that information. Software allowing access to your information to parties other than the ones that you intended is a vulnerability class commonly called "information leak".
> This doesn't mean im unconcerned about the latter.
And thus it is, as per the common understanding of the word, a security concern.
> If secure software compromises privacy in ways that concern you
That's just logical nonsense. You might as well be saying "If secure software kills you in ways that concern you, [...]".
> it may not be the right software for you to use, but it is still secure
So, let's assume your browser had a bug where for some reason, every website could read all the data in the browser. Like, could access the storage, cookies, cache, history, page contents, everything. But no write access. This is obviously purely a privacy violation ... but, according to your definition, not a security problem, right?
No, it's not. Security is not a goal in itself, it can not be, security is only about guaranteeing other goals, there is no security absent all other goals. What it means for software to be insecure is that it doesn't ensure your goals are met. For many, privacy is an important goal. If the software that you are using compromises your privacy that you value, then that software is not secure.
But also, actually, it would be a problem, because the law would still be broken, because the law still systematically protects the abusers. What is needed is a change to the unjust law, not some exception for someone who highlighted that that is what it is.
So, why is it then that these laws do apply here? Is that just incompetence on the part of those who wrote those laws? Because, you know, if it wasn't, then your claim that this was not a goal of these laws is a bit unfounded.
Plus, the fact that these laws still haven't been changed to protect whistleblowers really completely invalidates even the possibility that this is just incompetence. All those people who would be in the position to change that law know about Snowden, and nothing has happened. That is not what an honest mistake looks like.
> However you try to spin things, this is exactly what happened.
So?
> Snowden was in a position of trust, leaked all kinds of state secrets, and then tried to profit from that leak.
So?
Why is it that you feel the need to defend these abuses? To grasp for these straws of plausible deniability? Why is it so hard to see this for what it is: Systematic human rights abuses and violation of the law with other laws that protect the abusers and punish those who reveal the abuse. Why is this law that protects the abusers so much more important than the laws these abusers broke and break? How can it possibly be just to uphold the law against the whistleblower while at the same time letting the abusers continue to break the laws they don't like?
Why do you think that the only two alternatives is to allow people to sell secrets to foreign governments and sell revelations about illegal actions of the state or to punish both in the same way? Why do you think it is impossible to distinguish those two cases?
From what kind of twisted security standpoint is it counterproductive to allow someone to reveal mass security violations?
I don't think it is useful to participate in the newspeak that authoritarians use to pretend that you are somehow more secure when your human rights are constantly being violated.
Or do they? I mean, it's not that there can not be advantages to doing so, but then the same can be said about torture, about killing "dangerous" people without a trial, about censorship, ..., or in short: There can be advantages to any of the things that authoritarians like (as long as they themselves aren't the target, obviously).
But still, we have recognized that we are better off as a society if we make all those things illegal, because the good that comes from them is outweighed by far by the bad. Maybe we should come to that same conclusion about "state secrets"? Maybe we should realize that they are inherently incompatible with democracy, and that having them damages democracy so much that we would be better off accepting the risks of not having "state secrets"? Or, to at least reconsider how far they can go/how they can be used? Like, I dunno, maybe you can have state secrets, but not for longer than three years, and you can not convict someone based on secrets? I don't claim to know what the right balance would be, just throwing out random ideas, but my point is that it seems to me that the damage done by the concept of state secrets warrants reconsidering whether they are actually worth it.
That is not a reason to make repairs illegal. Authoritarianism does not solve problems. If property means anything, then it certainly should include the right to use it "incorrectly", though obviously with liability for any damages you cause others.
No, that is a fundamental misunderstanding of what odds are. Odds are not a property of a system, odds are a description of your knowledge about that system. There is no such thing as "odds of the system", the odds for the same system can be vastly different for different observers.
If you know how to control the coin, then the odds for you are almost 1:0 for your intended face. For the person next to you who doesn't know you, it's probably 0.5:0.5. For the person that has watched you for a while, it might be 0.6:0.4, if that's the ratio of the faces that you flip (intentionally). All for the exact same system at the exact same moment.
Also, a binary distinction between "having no clue" and "perfect predictions" is not useful. While perfect predictions are the limit of an ever refined model, there are many steps in between a useless model that gives random predictions and a model that makes no mistakes whatsoever.