HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zajio1am

2,646 karma · joined June 15, 2019

submissionscomments
zajio1am··on Anthropic takes legal action against OpenCode
Is this relevant for people that use regular (per-token credit-based) API key?
zajio1am··on Starlink Mini as a failover
When here is local power outage and everyone switches to 4g/5g, it is overwhelmed and unusable.
zajio1am··on Asian governments roll out 4-day weeks, WFH to solve fuel crisis caused by war
No. EU laws are of two kinds: directives and regulations. Directives work roughly as you describe, while regulations have direct effect like regular laws.
zajio1am··on Don't post generated/AI-edited comments. HN is for conversation between humans.
> Wouldn't it work better to just write the thing in whatever language they can actually write in and then do a straightforward translation in a single pass?

Nontrivial translation tools are AI(neural net)-based tools (although not necessary LLM). Whole transformer neural net architecture was originally designed for translation.

zajio1am··on “Car Wash” test with 53 models
Maybe that is because i am non-native speaker, but 'garage' i understand primarily as a place where car is parked, not a car repair shop. So it makes perfect sense to walk there in order to repair the car (that is already there).
zajio1am··on Running My Own XMPP Server
XMPP had rather bad name. Well-known design issues causing message losses, fractioned ecosystem due to varying implementation of extensions, unsuitability for mobile clients, absence of synchronization between clients, absence of end-to-end encryption. Most of these issues were (much) later fixed by extensions, but Matrix (or Signal for those who do not require federated one) was already there, offering E2EE by default.

Even today, E2EE in XMPP is rather inconvenient compared to Matrix due to absence of chain-of-trust in key management.

zajio1am··on I want to wash my car. The car wash is 50 meters away. Should I walk or drive?
One could argue that answers given by LLMs make sense. By assuming reasonability of the asking side, the answering side could assume that both options are possible and use abductive reasoning to conclude that the car to wash is already at the car wash station (and the question is about using another car to drive there).
zajio1am··on The EU moves to kill infinite scrolling
No, it just ensures that humans acting through such legal fiction have the same rights as humans acting directly.
zajio1am··on End of an era for me: no more self-hosted git
600K request per day is ~ 400/minute. That is very low number. But seems to me that many webapps are so bad that even that small number causes significant load for them.
zajio1am··on Communities are not fungible
Most of NIMBY legislature and processes that block private construction also block public construction. So most YIMBY arguments to improve the situation apply to both public and private constructions. (Not to mention that public construction has a plenty of problems specific to it.)
zajio1am··on Running Your Own AS: BGP on FreeBSD with FRR, GRE Tunnels, and Policy Routing
Note that it is not a real C-class IP prefix unless it is from the 192.0.0.0/3 range, otherwise it is just a sparkling /24 IP prefix.
zajio1am··on We mourn our craft
I do not talk about UBs, compiler can be non-deterministic even for completely valid and well-specified source code.

Seems to me that people just confuse determinism with soundness.

Determinism is just whether the output of the tool (machine code) is determined by the input (source code), i.e., for one input always returns the same output.

Soundness means that output is always consistent with the semantics of the input. i.e. returned machine code always does what is specified by the source code.

Compilers can be non-deterministic (although usually are deterministic), but they are always sound (ignoring compiler bugs).

LLMs can be deterministic (although usually aren't), but they are not sound in general.

zajio1am··on We mourn our craft
There is no requirement for compilers to be deterministic. The requirement is that a compiler produces something that is valid interpretation of the program according to the language specification, but unspecified details (like specific ordering of instructions in the resulting code) could in principle be chosen nondeterministically and be different in separate executions of the compiler.
zajio1am··on Data centers in space makes no sense
You do not need orbital capability to hit an orbital target. Just suborbital missile that reaches target's orbital altitude.
zajio1am··on English professors double down on requiring printed copies of readings
There is a specific condition called dysgraphia that pretty much fits descripion "can't write well".
zajio1am··on 'Askers' vs. 'Guessers' (2010)
It seems to me that it is much more symmetric. In both situations one side guess, due to fundamental uncertainties of human interactions -- each side knows their subjective costs/benefits, but not costs/benefits of the other side.

For 'guesser protocol', the initiatior guess whether the ask is appropriate (say initiator_known _benefit > responder_guessed_cost), while in 'asker protocol', the task of guessing is shifted to responder, as the responder has to guess whether the reject is appropriate (say responder_known_cost > initiator_guessed_benefit).

zajio1am··on IPv6 is not insecure because it lacks a NAT
You do not need compromised ISP for spoofed LAN IP traffic, the attack could came from other clients on the same WAN segment.
zajio1am··on EU–INC – A new pan-European legal entity
Common language works for employment and business, but then you go to government bureau (or want to fill government form) and they will insist on official language.

That is why english as secondary official language would be beneficial.

zajio1am··on IPv6 is not insecure because it lacks a NAT
RFC 4787 does not really describe how real world implementations behave. As almost all SOHO routers are Linux-based, i prefer to discuss Linux netfilter-based NAT behavior than some hypothetical RFC 4787 NAT. There are clear differences. For example, RFC 4787 says:

> REQ-1: A NAT MUST have an "Endpoint-Independent Mapping" behavior

While Linux netfilter behavior is "Address and Port-Dependent Mapping".

As Linux netfilter implements both NAT and firewall behavior, it is relevant for the discussion which parts of overall netfilter behavior falls into 'NAT part' and which into 'firewall part'. There is clear distinction - DNAT/SNAT rules in nat table represent NAT behavior, while REJECT/DROP rules in filter table represent firewall behavior.

As Linux-based SOHO routers are usually configured with both NAT and firewall netfilter rules to implement both NAT and firewall behavior, one cannot answer question 'Does NAT filter traffic?' based on external behavior of such SOHO routers, but has to analyze which part of the network stack is responsible for such behavior, or how the same network stack configured with just NAT rules and no firewall rules would behave. And here the answer is no, it would pass traffic (that do not match existing connections) unmodified.

zajio1am··on IPv6 is not insecure because it lacks a NAT
Consumer IPv4 router has both firewall and NAT enabled by default, and such packet is blocked by its firewall functionality.
zajio1am··on 60% of Legal Searches Now End Without a Click
I have an opposite experience. I use predominantly DDG (mainly for UI reasons), but often the search results are much less relevant than from Google, or i got exact zero results, where Google finds plenty of instances of searched phrase.
zajio1am··on Grok Sexual Images Draw Rebuke, France Flags Content as Illegal
> Photoshop is fine, running a business where you produce CSAM for people with photoshop is not. And this has been very clear for a while now.

What if Photoshop is provided as a web service? This is analogous to running image generation as a service. In both cases provider takes input from the user (in one case textual description, on the other case sequence of mouse events) and generates and image with an automated process, without specific human intentional input from the provider.

Note that in this case using them for producing CSAM was against terms of service, so the business was tricked to produce CSAM.

And there are other automated services that could be used for CSAM generation, for example automated photo booths. Should their operator be held liable if someone use them to produce CSAM?

zajio1am··on Grok Sexual Images Draw Rebuke, France Flags Content as Illegal
When these models are fine tuned to allow any kind of nudity, i would guess they also can be used to generate nude images of children. There is a level of generalization in these models. So it seems to me that arguing for restrictions that could be effectively implemented via prompt validation only is just indirect argumentation against open-weight models.
zajio1am··on Grok Sexual Images Draw Rebuke, France Flags Content as Illegal
This is already possible, just download open-weight model and run it locally. It seems absurd to me to enforce content rules on AI services and even more that people on Hacker News advocate for that.
zajio1am··on Non-Zero-Sum Games
Well, i would say that there are two common fallacies w.r.t. meritocracy:

1) Mixing up merit (ability to provide achievement) with effort.

2) Assuming it has anything to do with moral weight. While it primarily targets just decision making and distribution of deserts (rewards).

Why distribution of deserts should be meritocratic? Because that ensure that collaboration is positive-sum for everybody involved. Considering this, fair reward for participation in some group effort has to satisfy a condition that reward is at least as large as a missed opportunity (of collaborating in some other group, individually, or not collaborating at all).

zajio1am··on Non-Zero-Sum Games
Yes, also effort is something a person can influence directly, while ability cannot or only indirectly (education ...) so it makes sense to focus on things people can influence, but but achievement is the ultimate target.
zajio1am··on How did DOGE disrupt so much while saving so little?
> Six months later you begin to understand why they were done “wrong”.

It is hard to say whether it is really understanding, or just stockholm syndrome of local optimum.

zajio1am··on I'm returning my Framework 16
In my experience, when there is a time to replace the CPU/board by a newer one, the case if a notebook also accumulated enough wear and tear damage that make sense to replace it.

And when not, replacing whole notebook means i still have the old one, which i could use as a backup or sell or give to someone.

zajio1am··on Clair Obscur having its Indie Game Game Of The Year award stripped due to AI use
It is silly, considering there is obviously much higher chance that code-generating LLM generates copy of existing copyrighted code than image-generating diffusion model generates copy of existing copyrighted image.
zajio1am··on I spent a week without IPv4 (2023)
Ideally, 464XLAT should have been there from the beginning and its host part (CLAT) should have been a mandatory part of IP stack.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →