HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zapzupnz

2,667 karma · joined August 2, 2018

submissionscomments
zapzupnz··on The New Collabora Office for Desktop
A study from 16 years ago is hardly relevant anymore. Back in 2003, people were still familiar with Office 2003's layout; most people have long since forgotten that layout or never learnt it in the first place.

The author doesn't discuss users' existing familiarity with Office 2003 and they only mention the word 'training' once, that "software design to interact with technology should require the least amount of training as possible" whilst never acknowledging that training in, and even qualifications in, the use of the Office suite was very much a thing in the 1990s and early 2000s.

Even then, the most problems were had in Excel. Advanced usage of Excel is done by technical people who would have had some training. Word and PowerPoint weren't shown to have significant difference in usability; arguably, Word is the program most people forced to use the Office suite spend their time in.

Never mind the ways by which the Ribbon and computers have changed since Office 2007. Options moved around, the Ribbon height reduced, screens having gotten wider to compress fewer options into submenus…

The author states at the end of their conclusion:

> In order to determine if the result of the study with respect to the Excel 2007 application persists and are not due to the learning curve the experiment can be repeated with users having at least three years using this version.

Do you know if the author or anybody else followed up?

It would be more interesting to see a comparison between Office 365 now that the interface has effectively become the de facto standard (same as Windows, macOS, mobile, tablet, and the web version) and Google Sheets (which retains the menus, toolbar, etc.).

I'm no lover of the Ribbon myself but I feel like there's better evidence for it not being the ideal interface than this which wouldn't have convinced me even at the time.

This isn't the proof that'll bring down the titan.

zapzupnz··on The New Collabora Office for Desktop
> The new one looks all Microsoft-Ribbony

LibreOffice has a Ribbon interface option, too.

zapzupnz··on [dead]
Why not post directly to the article rather than through a twitter post?

Also, this article only applies to the US.

zapzupnz··on Show HN: Bonsplit – Tabs and splits for native macOS apps
The website already has a demonstration of what this does that native tabs don’t do and how they look.
zapzupnz··on Bugs Apple loves
And I'm calling out the unearned arrogance of somebody who doesn't understand what hyperbole is, a fairly basic rhetorical device.
zapzupnz··on Bugs Apple loves
Great, "Works on My Machine" award for you. Well done.
zapzupnz··on Bugs Apple loves
All of the things on this website have affected my experience of macOS and iOS for a long, long time.

I definitely go straight to the Gmail website when I need to search for anything on my work account. Yes, I've got it set up to cache all the emails locally indefinitely. Have done for years. Even did so when my workplace used Office 365 instead of Google.

On Hacker News, of all websites, giving yourself the "Works on My Machine" badge is not a worthy contribution. It's dismissive of any experience other than your own.

zapzupnz··on Bugs Apple loves
The terrible UI of a straight-forward document separated into distinct blocks, paragraphs and charts that are easily read, that scrolls from from top-to-bottom? Yeah, awful.
zapzupnz··on Bugs Apple loves
I suspect the point was never to win awards for web design, just to put some content on a page.
zapzupnz··on Can you slim macOS down?
Aside from all the hardware that doesn't work.
zapzupnz··on Can you slim macOS down?
That "which makes it worth sacrificing the ability to run your machine the way you want" is utterly superfluous.

The way I want to run my machine is by running macOS and using its features, app ecosystem, and so on.

Not once have I ever felt I've had to make a sacrifice to do so.

zapzupnz··on Can you slim macOS down?
I have a life and plan to live it, not spend all day configuring my computer to do basic things that macOS does perfectly.

"I've never personally understood" seems to be a lack of imagination.

zapzupnz··on LG UltraFine Evo 6K 32-inch Monitor Review
You did see that they mentioned the Studio Display as well, yes?
zapzupnz··on Gaussian Splatting – A$AP Rocky "Helicopter" music video
Anybody sufficiently interested would press further, not back away.
zapzupnz··on Gaussian Splatting – A$AP Rocky "Helicopter" music video
If one actually tried to explain to a five year old, they can use things like analogy, simile, metaphor, and other forms of rhetoric. This was just a straight-up technical explanation.
zapzupnz··on Gaussian Splatting – A$AP Rocky "Helicopter" music video
Not everything has to be. Sometimes, an artist's style or a particular track just hits a particular vibe one may be after or need in a particular moment.

I'm not a fan of this music either but I could imagine hearing it while I'm studying or coding.

Don't trash something just because it's not your vibe. Not everything has to be Mozart.

zapzupnz··on If you put Apple icons in reverse it looks like someone getting good at design
> There was never a period of time when you could just look at any logo and know what it is

None of your examples are for built-in applications. You have to go out of your way to download those programs. You'd know what the traffic cone means because you downloaded the program with the traffic cone. You went out of your way to get it.

Let's go back to that era and look at some other built-in apps, like Pages is (these days).

Notepad: a blue-covered notepad with some lined pages visible.

Wordpad: a fountain pen writing on some lined paper. Eventually the pen disappeared but the paper remained.

Paint: a paint palette, then a bucket of art supplies, then a glass cup with paintbrushes, then back to a palette but with a brush.

Solitaire: a deck of cards.

Outlook Express: an envelope.

MSN Messenger: two people next to each other because they're communicating with each other.

Windows Movie Maker: a film reel/strip.

Internet Explorer: a big 'e' (for Explorer) with a planet-like ring around it, suggesting a planet that you could traverse. (Okay, a bit abstract)

Over the Mac, there was:

SimpleText: a pencil writing on a sheet of paper. Later re-used for TextEdit.

Sherlock: a detective's cap and magnifying glass, indicating searching. The magnifying glass was later re-used for Spotlight.

Disk First Aid: A floppy disk on the back of an ambulance.

Disk Utility: a doctor's stethoscope pressed against a hard disk.

etc.

> it was not how comprehensible logos became, but how cynical we ended up

Because, on macOS, none of the icons became any more comprehensible than before. If anything, they got less comprehensive even when the visual metaphor remained the same because the representation is so poor. That's what made everybody cynical.

zapzupnz··on Can You Disable Spotlight and Siri in macOS Tahoe?
There isn't any such service; it's on demand.
zapzupnz··on Can You Disable Spotlight and Siri in macOS Tahoe?
The first message in the thread isn't the definition of the actual feature.
zapzupnz··on Can You Disable Spotlight and Siri in macOS Tahoe?
Faster and better, but in all its time, it's never gotten better than Alfred which, ironically, depends on the Spotlight index.
zapzupnz··on Can You Disable Spotlight and Siri in macOS Tahoe?
> I put files in sensible places

Good for you. Do you want a medal?

Finding files often means more than just looking in folders for adequately named files. Sometimes, it's looking for the contents of files, for things that aren't files (because some kinds of files on macOS aren't actually files, they're folders that are treated specially by the system), and for things like contacts, calendar events, reminders, mail, etc.

zapzupnz··on Can You Disable Spotlight and Siri in macOS Tahoe?
Does grep work on anything other than plain text?

And then you'll have to wait for grep to trawl every folder to find the right file rather than consult an optimised index.

zapzupnz··on Can You Disable Spotlight and Siri in macOS Tahoe?
And then you didn't. What's the purpose of saying this?

All consumer-operating systems also used to be single user with administrative access by default. Shall we return to that, too?

zapzupnz··on Command K Bars
And nothing screams "has never had the pleasure" like a Windows or Linux user who says "who cares if there's no menu bar?" ;-)
zapzupnz··on Command K Bars
Those who undervalue this don’t realise that the Mac menu bar is also the standard mechanism for defining keyboard shortcuts; as long as it has an entry in the menu bar, it can have keyboard shortcuts assigned and even reassigned from System Settings.

There’s incentive for the menu bar to be properly populated with all the functions that a program offers. Mac users expect it.

Compare with non-standard Mac apps (mainly Electron apps or ports from other OS), modern Windows apps, and many Linux apps where the menu bar is often a second class citizen or completely absent, leaving you to the whims of the developer rather than enjoying conformance to a system-wide standard.

zapzupnz··on macOS 26's Cut Corners
These are not reasons. These are placatings.
zapzupnz··on The struggle of resizing windows on macOS Tahoe
Oh, interesting! Which features?
zapzupnz··on The struggle of resizing windows on macOS Tahoe
It's a mountain of little things that add up rather than a few killer features.

It's the way drag and drop is a fundamental interaction in text boxes, the proxy icons in title bars, how dragging a file to an open/save panel changes that panel's current folder rather than actually move a file.

It's how applications are just special folders that are treated like files, how they can update themselves independently of each other or any system packages, how you conventionally put them in the /Applications folder so you can put that folder on the Dock to use directly as a launcher.

It's how all text fields consistently support emacs-style keyboard shortcuts, respond appropriately to the system-provided text editing features such as the built-in Edit menu, text substitutions, and writing features.

It's how you can automate most Mac-assed apps; how you can extend the operating system through app-provided and user-created services to every other application that handles text, files, images, PDFs, through the built-in APIs using AppleScript, Automator, and Shortcuts.

It's how the whole program rather than its last window is the fundamental unit of an application such that document-based applications can exist without a window without also polluting some system tray with an unnecessary icon, how that means workflows expect more than one window open.

It's how there's a universal menu that works for every app, not just conforming ones (i.e. KDE's global menu only shows KDE apps' menus; other apps need a plugin or just don't show at all), how the help menu has a search field to look for menu items, how keyboard shortcuts are bound to the menu items are bound arbitrarily within the program's settings window and can thus be assigned globally in System Settings, how this means all of an application's main features are therefore accessible via the menu bar, how that creates consistency in the menus.

Those are just some things off the top of my head but there are plenty of others, some a bit more user facing, some less. Just examples, a non-exhaustive list.

I'm sure those who don't care about these things will dismiss it but if you've been using a Mac since before macOS, before OS X, or even before Mac OS X, these are things you won't drop for Linux just because the design is a bit uglier.

Of course, if none of these things matter, then the swap is easier. It doesn't mean any DE is a drop-in replacement by any means. Many of the things that make some DEs "Mac-like" are skin deep.

zapzupnz··on The struggle of resizing windows on macOS Tahoe
Maybe they didn't want people seeing their awful new icons at large enough sizes that the seams would be showing...
zapzupnz··on The struggle of resizing windows on macOS Tahoe
Going back to Lion would almost feel like bliss compared to Tahoe. Hell, bliss compared to Big Sur.
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →