HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zardeh

342 karma · joined December 29, 2013

submissionscomments
zardeh··on Why I close pull requests
To clarify here, what kinds of changes do you think require a design document?
zardeh··on Why I close pull requests
>You shouldn't hire people who don't give enough of a shit to take the big picture into account.

At a certain point you can't. I was recently asked to implement a feature for a usecase for another engineer. It required a design doc and review by a few representatives from related teams. He and I wrote the doc, and the initial review was that any solution that would fix his usecase would break the testing infrastructure for practically every other developer in the building. He could write a few fewer loc when testing, at the cost of tests failing due to unrelated changes.

Neither he nor I had the awareness of the impact, and realistically couldn't have, it was neither of our responsibilities. And because I spent an hour filling out a template document, I didn't need to waste my time doing that.

zardeh··on Why I close pull requests
Which leads to problems: see systemd.

Also, to be clear, Linux is relatively small compared to Google or Microsoft, or indeed many corporations codebases. Someone could conceivably read the entire Linux kernel codebase. That's not true for BigCorp.

zardeh··on Why I close pull requests
>Requiring permission to do work is the enemy of progress and engineering dignity. It creates a presumption of incompetence and an atmosphere of low trust that punishes people who want to push the envelope of what's possible.

Its not a permission to do work, its permission to merge the results of the work to master. Those are different.

>Google's design document culture is bad.

Then why do we have JEPs, PEPs, and rfcs in perhaps every other major project out there?

zardeh··on I'm becoming scared of Facebook
>Nope, if you choose to turn this feature on, it will only use your microphone (for 15 seconds) when you’re actually writing a status update to try and match music and TV.

It doesn't do ambient recording. Its basically shazaam.

zardeh··on Show HN: Code.hackmit.org – Software for Hackathons
Hey anish, using these (and giving back) were great. I'm glad to see that Gavel has progressed significantly since I contributed.
zardeh··on Stroustrup's Rule and Layering Over Time in Rust
Its important to read that line in context:

>There should be one-- and preferably only one --obvious way to do it.

The zen of python isn't saying "only have one way to do anything" it says "have at least one obvious way, and preferably only one obvious way to do this".

There can be lots of ways to iterate over a list:

    [x for x in l]

    for x in l:
        x

    while (x for x in [1,2,3]).next():
        ...
Only one is obvious for a given situation.
zardeh··on Yahoo discloses hack of 1B accounts
Google also allows you to use google authenticator, but I don't believe they allow third party services.
zardeh··on A Basic Introduction to Neural Networks (2007)
While I don't share his total disdain for the article, he got the date spot on, and I'd say that

- no mention of non-sigmoid activation functions - calling overfitting 'grandmothering' and - diving comparatively deep into gradient descent (which while absolutely the most common, is not the only way to train a neural network), while being an inch deep on practically every other aspect.

Its a bit of a confused intro that simultaneously tries to teach you the basics while throwing jargon at you ('delta-rule', 'beta-coefficient', 'hyperparaboloid', etc.).

zardeh··on Ask HN: Where is AI/ML actually adding value at your company?
I'm curious, because this is something that I was interested in doing for brick and mortar universities, what aspects do you use to do your recommendations. That is, is it just a x/5 rating per user that is thrown into a latent factor model, or do you do anything else (like dividing course 'grade' vs. opinion along two axes manually?)
zardeh··on Imzy wants to be a kinder, gentler version of Reddit
Did slaves in the 17th century have the right to free themselves from slavery? No. That right was limited by law. They had the ability to do so, in some cases, but certainly not the right (as is legally recognized).
zardeh··on The Silent Anniversary: Fifteen Years Since Our Last Major Crash
7
zardeh··on The Silent Anniversary: Fifteen Years Since Our Last Major Crash
Of those 5, 4 occurred in propeller craft. I think that it is relevant to include that kind of difference. Regional airlines and major airlines do work differently.
zardeh··on Google Makes So Much Money, It Never Had to Worry About Financial Discipline
But it does matter to a lot of people, which I think is the thing.

There will absolutely be people who are willing to sacrifice some ease-of-use in the name of additional privacy, but it seems that those people are in the minority, and that means that Google (or whomever) needs to provide 99/99 when everyone else is only 90/90, if they want to continue being market leaders.

zardeh··on Google Makes So Much Money, It Never Had to Worry About Financial Discipline
Why not Safari or Opera?

Competition is good. You can make a standards based browser and then add additional features that others can't or won't provide. Building it in house gives them more control. Do you think Mozilla would have developed V8 if google just threw money at them?

zardeh··on [dead]
>Why does language have to welcoming and inclusive? Can't it merely meet a minimum standard of mutual respect?

What's the difference? I consider inclusivity a minimum standard of mutual respect, do you not?

>Shouldn't it be what's best for the project? I understand that's nitpicking but the focus is wrong.

The CC is (to my knowledge) an opt-in thing, meaning that by opting in, you are consenting to put the greater community before your project (in some contexts). Is that a problem?

zardeh··on More Than 1M Google Accounts Breached by Gooligan
Now I really want to post this to /r/politics or one of the jill stein subs, with a title like "PENN VOTING MACHINES COULD HAVE EASILY BEEN HACKED, THE VOTES ARE INVALID".

It would get upvoted, perhaps to the front page, and then news outlets would likely pick up the story.

zardeh··on VLC 360° Technical Preview
You should increase the opacity on the header bar on that page when you scroll down, you get weird interactions otherwise.
zardeh··on Deleting the golang subreddit
What illegal behavior is that?
zardeh··on What Test Engineers Do at Google: Building Test Infrastructure
(also, speaking as a SETI at Google, I've never written a test for someone else's code. I build tools that make testing easier. I write tests for my own code, because I'm building applications that are complex enough to require tests.)
zardeh··on Visual Studio for Mac
I'm not sure how you got that out of his post.
zardeh··on Peter Thiel To Join Trump Transition Team
Very little, Obama didn't have the advantage of a friendly congress.
zardeh··on Barcelona Supercomputing Center
Having been there, its a really interesting location, quite beautiful.
zardeh··on Exposing high-end poker cheating devices
The video links to a defcon talk.
zardeh··on Verifying Wikileaks DKIM-Signatures
IDK, as a bernie voter in the primary, I don't see this as surprising or problematic, at least not if I'm reading these correctly.
zardeh··on Sam Altman: “YC not going to fire someone over support of a candidate”
I'm confused, is this not a perfect example of the free market in action? Is this not exactly what conservatives suggest will (should) happen when we allow discrimination based on religious or personal views. They suggest that private individuals and organizations will refuse to work with those companies whose views they disagree with, and that in turn will force the companies to adapt or perish.

Is that not exactly what happened here? OkCupid refused to do work with Mozilla based on Mozilla's (CEO's) beliefs, and this led to action on the part of Mozilla.

I'm not sure how you can call this a liberal action when it is essentially what the right espouses as 'the way things should be'.

zardeh··on Static types in Python
Well, my joke was that numbers.Number exists, and I think supports those operations, but even someone complaining about this topic is unaware that it exists.
zardeh··on Static types in Python
Well yes, but

    # optionally: Number = Union[int, float, complex]
    def sum_and_stringify(nums: Iterable[Number]) -> str:
        return str(sum(nums))
also works. Except no one knows what the Number abstract base class is (or even the Iterable abstract base class for that matter)
zardeh··on Static types in Python
>It feels like Von Rossum is making life hard for the PyPy compiler project again.

Or perhaps, he realizes that to require these typechecks at runtime would either

- require a massive rewrite of the CPython interpreter

- cause a performance penalty in code that is statically typed (there are pure python libraries that allow this, and yes your code runs slower)

Further, it offers a relatively narrow amount of help to pypy, which has already come out and said that they have no interest in using annotations for efficiency gains, because they're a jit and they don't need them.

zardeh··on Not OK, Google
>This strikes me as a matter of semantics; does it really matter if I'm targeted whether they hacked my account or hacked Google?

I think is incredibly important. If your information is put at risk due to bad practices by Google/Yahoo/Apple/Facebook/whomever that's a problem to be taken up with the company. If you use insecure passwords and someone is able to access your information that way, then the problem is with your passwords, not with the platform.

>Think harder. Who has the root access to the servers holding the data?

As far as I'm aware, no one. Like I said, from my experience, accessing personal data and user information as an engineer required a lot of red tape and approval from 'the powers that be', and violating those rules would get you fired faster than anything else.

>Could the existing infrastructure and data segregation ever change? How many external checks and balances are in play that can't be manipulated by internal forces (i.e. is there anything stopping Google, or holding Google accountable if their data protection policies change)?

Here I agree with you, probably not (or very little). They obviously have public privacy policies, but you have no proof that they abide by those, and I don't know (and doubt that) they get audited or whatnot to make sure that those policies are followed. Which is why being an employee made me more comfortable. If nothing else, it meant I'd know ;)

← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →