HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zarzavat

11,153 karma · joined April 24, 2021

submissionscomments
zarzavat··on Giving a domain a hill to climb: benchmarking as data activation
What's with the lack of capitalization?
zarzavat··on Odin, Wikipedia and engagement farming
The article was for a public company. There are not many viagra companies that go public, except for Pfizer.

Deletion should be reserved for cases where the entire edit history is worthless or must be deleted for legal reasons etc. Articles on notable subjects where editors have put genuine work into editing them at some point should not be deleted.

zarzavat··on Agentic coding notes from Galapagos Island
Every metric becomes a target (Goodhart's law). Also, the plural of anecdote is not data.

The subjective anecdotes from HN users matter because they are not data and are much harder to game. Not impossible to game, always be aware of users with low karma, but more difficult than gaming a benchmark.

zarzavat··on Agentic coding notes from Galapagos Island
Apple claims their price increases are temporary too. I'll believe it when I see it. The capacity limitations are not going away any time soon.
zarzavat··on Odin, Wikipedia and engagement farming
They can just strip out any problematic content and protect it. At least leave the lede and the infobox and whatever else can be salvaged.

Deleting the article means you can't even see the edit history to see why it was deleted. Whatever good work was done by other editors is gone cannot be built on. It's extreme.

zarzavat··on Agentic coding notes from Galapagos Island
API prices are the new normal. I doubt that prices will drop to the level of the subsidized subscriptions any time soon. Usage is growing exponentially but capacity cannot. There is no reason for them to waste their capacity on subscription users if they can sell that same capacity to API users.

Like with Uber and Lyft, the low prices were a fight for market share, but now they have successfully captured that market share the focus changes to balancing their books.

zarzavat··on Agentic coding notes from Galapagos Island
Fable changes the game yet again, because it's API-only.

You're not likely to want to run Fable in a loop any more than you want to take a bunch of dollar bills and light them on fire. Every invocation of Fable has to be intentional, its context carefully managed. I feel like a babysitter.

zarzavat··on Odin, Wikipedia and engagement farming
I was researching a public company the other day and I open their Wikipedia page: deleted.

I get it, probably it had been massaged by their PR department. But deleting the article punishes the readers by removing the very space for critical discussion of a topic with good SEO. Now if you want information on this company you will likely end up on their website, it seems like a reward to me.

zarzavat··on Is the iPhone birth control? Causal evidence from AT&T's 2007-2011 monopoly [pdf]
Even if you control for age and wealth, the people who used iPhones in 2008, i.e. tech hipsters, are obviously different in tangible ways from the people who didn't use iPhones in 2008. It's not possible to prove causality from that.
zarzavat··on Have you restarted your computer this week?
I think you have Stockholm syndrome. It's not worth having any loyalty to such an organization. Since they don't want you to work, just spend your working hours looking for a new job.
zarzavat··on Redeploying Fable 5
Don't worry, now that Fable is freely available, a Chinese distill will be out a few months from now. To riff on Musk, the US AI industry is the bootloader for the Chinese AI industry.
zarzavat··on The CEO of Mullvad is the main financer of the Swedish Örebro party
You have to consider the context which is that Sweden does have an awful lot of fake refugees mixed in with the real refugees. "Parasite" is harsh but unfortunately all too accurate for some of the migrants who are essentially gaming a system intended for people in real distress.
zarzavat··on Is sunscreen the new margarine? (2019)
There are other ways to lower blood pressure than sun exposure. Article is insane and confuses necessary and sufficient conditions.
zarzavat··on Samsung, SK Hynix, Micron Sued in US over Memory Price Fixing
They're running a business not a charity. Their job is to manufacture what the market as a whole demands. If they can make more money making HBM than DDR4 then they have to make HBM. Why would a business go out of its way to make less money?
zarzavat··on Some Simple Economics of AGI
This article is about current level AI, not future AGI. The common definition of AGI is intelligence that matches a human's, so there would be no need for a human to supervise every action of the AGI any more than a CEO supervises every action of their employees since by definition the human supervisor would do no better than an AGI performing the same role.
zarzavat··on Age verification is just a precursor to automated attribution of speech
It seems unlikely that running a website without age verification will be illegal across the entire planet.
zarzavat··on Age verification is just a precursor to automated attribution of speech
I don't like age verification. However I'm not concerned about it.

The internet needs new spaces that are more decentralized and less in bed with governments.

We already lost our freedom when we agreed to move from IRC to Discord, from phpBB to Reddit, etc.

The teenagers who are blocked from mainstream social media will deliver us new free online spaces that are better than what they're blocked from.

zarzavat··on Austria Lobbies EU to Host Anthropic After US Access Curbs
While I love your eye for malicious compliance I believe that Putin also forced European countries to increase their defence budgets.
zarzavat··on U.S. allows Anthropic to release Mythos AI to ‘trusted’ US organizations
Fable = Mythos + guardrails

Fable + jailbreak = Mythos

zarzavat··on International investment and local rules push prices up faster than supply
The US is special insofar as the US stock market is extraordinarily safe with many options for value investing. In much of the rest of the world it's the reverse: domestic stocks are risky and it's real estate, land and gold that are the safe, prestige assets.

When you add in an unstable environment at home, this mentality leads to foreign real estate being perceived as the ultimate asset. It's perception rather than reality because foreign real estate is not exactly a good investment, especially if non-resident: it's illiquid, highly taxed, requires insurance, is easy to confiscate, etc.

zarzavat··on PlayStation Is Deleting 551 Movies from Customers' Accounts
If you're the ethical type you can "buy" it on one of these services and then pirate it in order to keep it in perpetuity. If you're the less ethical type you can skip the "buying" step.
zarzavat··on U.S. allows Anthropic to release Mythos AI to ‘trusted’ US organizations
The Government's position is that Anthropic/OpenAI are forbidden from allowing non-US citizens use the models. This is impossible in reality because how can Anthropic know that the person sitting behind a Claude code session or API key is at any given moment a US citizen? You can check their ID on signup but how can they know that they didn't give their credentials to someone else to use? They can't.

Given the impossibility of compliance, what Anthropic and OpenAI are doing is working with the government to release it to certain organizations with the government's blessing.

If this were about missiles and not AI models, nobody would question this turn of events. If the government said that nobody can export this missile or allow non-citizens access to the missile, and then they started giving permission for certain organizations to handle the missile, that would be normal, not picking winners.

The only reason people are questioning it in this case is because they believe that these models are not dangerous enough to deserve these kinds of export controls. Personally I'd agree that in my 3 days of using Fable I didn't observe any superpowers. Unfortunately however, Anthropic undermined that argument by claiming that Mythos is highly dangerous, which set them up for any jailbreak of Fable to be considered a national security risk. Who is a court going to believe? Someone who used a model for 3 days? Or the government and the people who made that model?

zarzavat··on U.S. allows Anthropic to release Mythos AI to ‘trusted’ US organizations
That was in reference to whether anyone outside of Anthropic might be able to have standing to sue at all, not the merits of the case.
zarzavat··on U.S. allows Anthropic to release Mythos AI to ‘trusted’ US organizations
Technically the US government is allowing Anthropic to serve the models to any US citizen, and it's Anthropic who decided that's impossible to comply with and so they pulled the model for everyone. I guess a US business with non-citizen employees could work.

A lawsuit would be a hard sell though, because Anthropic themselves argued that the technology is dangerous. Even if many people on HN might think that Anthropic was scaremongering about Mythos, a court is probably going to take their assessment at face value, and courts are loathe to find against governments in cases of national security.

There's also the issue that these models are getting better through an iterative process, so even if the line between GPT 5.5 and Fable/GPT 5.6 is somewhat arbitrary, it doesn't mean that the government shouldn't be able to draw a line at all. So you're left arguing that they drew the line too early, which is subjective.

zarzavat··on U.S. government will decide who gets to use GPT-5.6
> If the US government says only US citizens can access a model, how do they enforce that.

It's easy if only enterprise users have access. It just becomes yet another compliance issue.

They won't let the public use it, even if citizens, because that would undermine the goal of controlling its use.

> I'm hoping this is a call to action for local AI.

If US frontier models stop being publicly available then they stop mattering, it also becomes hard to justify further investment in US AI companies if distribution is so locked down. The Chinese models will be the frontier.

zarzavat··on Ask HN: Is "no source code was copied" still a sufficient copyright defense?
Copyrights on UIs are nebulous. You can't copyright the functional aspects of a UI, that's the domain of patents, yet the functional aspects are likely the parts you are most keen on protecting. Also you need to prove that they copied you and didn't come up with it independently.
zarzavat··on Micron locks in historically high memory prices for five years
What are they going to do about it? Start their own DRAM fab?
zarzavat··on Apple to skip high-end M6 Mac chips in favor of AI-focused M7 line
Just buy now. DRAM prices are not coming down any time soon, and Apple may be forced to raise prices again.
zarzavat··on LastPass notifies users of yet another data breach
"Password manager" used to mean a program that runs locally on your computer. At some point people started making it into a SaaS, because that's more profitable.

I do think there are some cases where an online password manager makes sense, e.g. for businesses, but for individuals it's better to just stick with an offline password manager, at least for the high value accounts.

zarzavat··on Aisle Discovers 6 New CVEs in Curl, Including the Oldest Issue Ever Reported
Another way to read it is that the public now have access to resources on a scale that was formerly the domain of three letter government agencies throwing millions of dollars to hire humans to do this work. While in the short-term it's painful for maintainers, in the long-term we all end up safer.
← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →