2,817 karma · joined August 15, 2007
meet.hn/city/pl-Warsaw
Socials:
- github.com/zby
- linkedin.com/in/zbigniewlukasiak
- x.com/zby ---
I am surprised that apparently I am in a minority here.
Personally I would just like to read the best comments.
I think co-recursion between prompts and code is crucial, but I also think that the ephemeral nature of code in Recursive Language Models is impending deployment time learning (https://github.com/zby/llm-do/blob/main/kb/notes/deploy-time...).
I wish they arranged it around READMEs. I have a directory with my tasks and I have a README.md there - before codex had skills it already understood that it needs to read the readme when it was dealing with tasks. The skills system is less directory dependent so is a bit more universal - but I am not sure if this is really needed.
I only wish the author changed his stance on vendor extensions: https://github.com/badlogic/pi-mono/discussions/254
I have a feeling that codex still does not do it reliably - so I still have normal README files which it loads quite intelligently and it works better than the discovery via skills.
By they way you don' need to use library to have output schemas: https://platform.openai.com/docs/guides/structured-outputs , https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/build-with-claude/struct...
I haven't yet tried this very extensively - but another profound change in programming that this showed me is that it is now very easy to borrow parts of Open Source libraries. It used to be that you could only base your work on a library - borrowing parts of projects that were not designed to be shared (used as libraries) was prohibitive - but with llms it is entirely possible to say: "now please borrow the UI ideas from project X" and it does that. Maybe you need to add some planning.
The project is about 27kloc now.
I find the second paragraphs contradictory - either you fear that I would agree with random stuff that the AI writes or you believe that the sycophant AI is writing what I believe. I like to think that I can recognise good arguments, but if I am wrong here - then why would you prefer my writing from an LLM generated one?