HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zemaj

735 karma · joined April 23, 2007

Email: hn@zemaj.com
submissionscomments
zemaj··on Show HN: My Weekend Project Nudity Detector API
Nudity detection is a hard problem, so hard that even the biggest companies tend to rely on crowd sourced systems, not computational ones. Is that what this is? Either way I definitely think you more information about how the system works, examples of what it can and can-not do and information about how long processing takes. I need a solution to this problem but have wasted so much time with other underperforming systems that I won't venture past the front page without some more details.
zemaj··on (debunked) PayPal vulnerability allows access to any account within 30 seconds
Updated. Doesn't looks like a huge issue, although obviously needs to be fixed;

"It seems that the 'victim' had opened an account using an email address of mine, with extra characters thrown in, which Gmail ignores and accepts as the same email address, so it was gmail which uncorrupted the email address and sent the emails to me, not Paypal. I had previously reported an account set-up with fraudulent email address to Paypal many times in the past, but only yesterday noticed that the email address was different to mine, in a way which on any other email system in the world would be a different email address."

From http://namesake.com/conversation/mattlangley/i-just-accident...

zemaj··on Duke Nukem Forever: barely playable, not funny, rampantly offensive
Clearly there is something wrong with me as I found the game throughly enjoyable. I did go in with low expectations after reading a few reviews.

However I also HATE God of War for its violence and misogyny. quite strange.

zemaj··on Y Combinator Numbers
Are there any numbers on how many YC companies are now defunct? Would be interesting to see how this compares to the anecdotal 9/10 startups fail in the first year.
zemaj··on The Revolutionary Birth Control Method for Men
This process may be a preferable alternative to condoms, but it does not stop the spread of STDs. From the WHOs perspective there's no obvious benefit.

I suspect this may be the real cause of their lack of interest.

zemaj··on California State Salaries
I'm guessing there is some background missing on those highest payed - for example a discussion on why coach salaries are so high http://www.azcentral.com/sports/asu/articles/2009/09/20/2009... They are not funded out of taxpayer money.
zemaj··on Broken Links
Despite all the FUD around hashbangs, the genuine problem I see with them is that they optimise for internal page loads, not the entry into a website. For example with hashbangs, requests to twitter when logged in go like;

1) HTTP GET http://twitter.com/some_account [~500ms for me]

2) 302 redirect -> HTTP GET http://twitter.com/ [~600ms for me]

3) HTML tells browser to download some JS -> HTTP GET bundle.js [~500ms for me] (concurrently here we start getting CSS)

4) JS reads hashbang & request actual data -> HTTP GET data.json [~500ms for me]

... only after about 2 seconds can we start(!) rendering data. Now there's about another 2 seconds for all json data & CSS calls to complete. It takes upwards of 4 seconds for a twitter page to render for me (the Load event lies as it fires well before actual data shows. Try it yourself with your favourite browser inspector).

When not using hashbangs, a single HTTP request can get all the data for the page and start rendering it. One blocking CSS call (possibly cached) is all that's needed for styling.

Hence when I see an external link with a hashbang it frustrates me (barely perceptively) because I know that when I load the page it's going to take a longer than a normal HTTP request. Significantly longer. While subsequent page loads are faster, it's not these you want to optimise for if you care about bounce rates. This issue affects every new link you click into a website, so it affects an even larger number of requests than normal bounces.

Hashbangs are a good solution to an important problem, but I don't see them as a tool to build entire websites upon. Fortunately I see the performance issue as one which will result in people voting with their browsers and choosing sites which only use hashbangs when they genuinely improve the user experience - especially since they're easily visible in the url.

zemaj··on Live ESP Experiment: Sexual Arousal Going Backwards in Time
I don't know. Some of those nonerotic photos are doing it for me :)
zemaj··on Google’s decreasingly useful, spam-filled web search
I still feel like it's not simple enough to be practical. I'd only really use a button that submitted the form behind the scenes. I think the extra step of filling out the fields is likely to drop my submission rate down to times I really get pissed off :)
zemaj··on Google’s decreasingly useful, spam-filled web search
If that strategy worked, spammers could use it in gmail to void spam filter utility. I'm sure the volume of legitimate requests would help drown that noise.
zemaj··on Google Spam Heresy: The AdSense Paradox
Don't really think that makes sense. Ad placement, site design, ad relevancy etc... all dominate the reasons of why people click ads. I don't think you're going to get much information about content relevancy out of the CTR as you can't hold those other features constant.

If Google is looking for how useful a page is, they're better off just looking at whether people go back to their search results and click on another site after a short delay.

zemaj··on Google’s decreasingly useful, spam-filled web search
It's seems to me like an explicit "Report Spam" button would help. The problem with SearchWiki & "Remove result" is that they have many other influencing factors as to why people would click those buttons.

People are pretty good at recognising "scams", but you need to tell them that's what they're looking for, not just how the content makes them feel. It seems like the report spam button was a large factor behind gmail's spam filtering success. Would love to see the same approach applied here. I know I'd be hitting my report spam button in chrome pretty often :)

zemaj··on WikiLeaks Archive — Cables Uncloak U.S. Diplomacy
It seems to me that Wikileaks is disruptive to Governments in the way that Napster was disruptive to the Music Industry.

While Wikileaks may not survive in the mid term, I believe what it represents may have far reaching, long term consequences. The internet has democratised information to the point that an unhappy individual with mid level trust in an organisation can expose the organisation's "sensitive" information globally with very little effort and thought.

Before the internet an individual could expose this information, but the barriers were much higher. To be a whistle blower you could only influence people immediately near you socially. To reach higher you had to filter your information through news organisations. While there are cases of this happening, the information was still continually at risk of being censored. Would this cable information have been released if a whistle blower took it directly to the NYT, or even a collection of newspapers?

With our current online structure of Twitter, Blogs and peer file sharing it makes sensitive information immediately accessible to millions with no chance of it being censored. To me Wikileaks represents the start of something hugely disruptive to our way of life. It's not possible to scale an organisation beyond several people while maintaining complete trust in each of them. When every piece of information is at risk of being exposed, what position does this place governments in? Is it possible for the current structure of the us government with its extensive lobby groups, international secrets and security through obscurity to continue?

I think its still too hard to see how the bits will fall here, but I do think we're in for an interesting decade :)

zemaj··on We're moving. Goodbye Rackspace.
The whole resize thing is fraught with problems. It was one of the main reason I moved to Rackspace Cloud, but it's just way too unreliable. I'm too scared to use it on any mission critical servers due to unpredictable downtime.

If you're under high traffic and you try to resize the server the operation time hugely blows out. There's no way to block this TCP traffic other than changing DNS settings which is obviously undesirable and you might as well just manually setup a new server if you're going to do this (which is what I now tend to do). This process should be automated. It's an obvious bottleneck and fixing would dramatically improve their offering.

I didn't really mind Rackspace having all these issues at the beginning, but after 2 years I see no progress anywhere. Unlike AWS there's very little apparent investment in the infrastructure tools. Other cloud services have matured, but Rackspace hasn't. While the support at Rackspace is awesome, there's only so often I can hear someone apologizing. I'd rather the issues just got fixed and all this friction was reduced. Incredibly disappointed.

zemaj··on We're moving. Goodbye Rackspace.
Huh, that's good to know, thanks. That makes my moving choice easier :)
zemaj··on We're moving. Goodbye Rackspace.
I moved all my services from EC2 to Rackspace Cloud about 2 years ago, but I'm regretting it.

Rackspace Cloud does one thing well - small instances have great value CPU & local IO performance. If your app is CPU or local IO bound, splitting it across multiple 256MB instances on Rackspace Cloud will get you huge performance relative to price. I've been worried that this would degrade as the service grew, but that hasn't been the case.

Unfortunately many other 'features' of Rackspace Cloud have been poor to awful recently. Some anecdotal stories;

1) We haven't been able to make images of our server or restore ANY backup of our servers for months. There is a bug in the backup service where if you have spaces in the names of your Cloud Files containers (completely unrelated to the backup service) then all images fail to be able to be restored. We can't remove the spaces in the containers because you can't rename containers (only delete) and there's too much data tied to different parts of our infrastructure in there.

2) In relation to the issue above, we have had a ticket open for over 2 months which we continually post updates with new information & asking for issue resolution. We never receive updates to the ticket itself and only receive information when contacting their live chat. The response is always "we're working on it". I could live with it if this was a short period, or not an absolutely vital part of their service, but come on - all backups broken for 2 months! No timelines on resolution. No ticket responses. No happy.

3) While CPU value is great on small instances you get the other end of the stick on large instances as other posters here have said. You don't get significantly improved performance above the 2GB servers. CPU capacity certainly does not double as their documents say.

4) Cloud Files latency is awful. Individual read/writes take 300-1000ms. Fine for a small number of large files. Impossible for a large number of small files. (Having said that, being able to upload files and publish to CDN in a click has saved me lots of time for static files I need to quickly publish).

5) Resizing mid to large instances is impossible. We recently tried to resize a 1GB (40GB disc) server to a 2GB (80GB disc) and it took OVER 3 DAYS. No really. It didn't complete. The resize process takes the server down towards the end. We had to get Rackspace to cancel the resize and manually spin up another server and transfer the files ourselves. To make it worse, we couldn't act on this issue initially because Rackspace insisted that the process was "almost complete" from 12 hours onwards. 2.5 days later we just gave up. We managed to do the manual transfer ourselves in a couple of hours. Even worse Rackspace seemed to not think that it was unusual for the process to take 3 days or express any desire to investigate further.

6) The web interface has awful performance at scale. Once you go above 20 cloud servers every single page load takes 10+ seconds. As the original poster says, the number of errors it spits out about not being able to complete operations is insane. It's rare I can go in there planning on doing something and not have to contact support to fix something broken on their end.

7) They're taking the entire web interface and API offline for 12 hours this week! You won't be able to spin up or take down any of your servers. Why? So they can fix a billing issue related to Cloud Sites (a service we don't use).

I've always been a champion of Rackspace Cloud and Rackspace in general, but sadly I would no longer recommend them to people. I'm starting to make contingency plans and looking for other providers again.

zemaj··on A Personal Perspective on Machine Learning
"In my opinion the hard problem in machine learning has moved from prediction to characterization."

Is this because prediction has been "solved" or because characterization is currently more commercially useful?

zemaj··on DumbledORM a novelty PHP ORM in < 200 lines
Ah, thanks! I actually spent a bit of time trying to find how to format code without any luck.
zemaj··on DumbledORM a novelty PHP ORM in < 200 lines
That's pretty cool. I like the method chaining.

There's definitely a need for a 'great' PHP ORM. I've been rolling my own for a couple of years since I've never been satisfied with what's out there. Here's the kind of syntax/style I use on mine (that class definition is the entire code I need to write to get working abstraction).

class Person extends Model {

const TABLE_NAME = 'people';

const TABLE_KEY = 'id';

}

$person = Model::find("Person", 1234);

$person->name = "James";

$person->save();

$persons_named_james = Model::find("Person", array("name" => "James"));

foreach($persons_named_james as $person) {

print $person->age;

}

$person = new Person();

$person->age = 26;

$person->save();

I should really upgrade to 5.3 so I could write Person::find(1234); instead.

zemaj··on Did Digg game its own system to benefit publisher partners?
On the surface, this follow up post is pretty damning http://ltgenpanda.tumblr.com/post/1404511358/second-confirma...

The pattern of diggs from the suspect accounts stopped not long after digg was notified of the blog post and before it was made public.

zemaj··on Firesheep: Easy HTTP session hijacking from within Firefox
FYI if you're still looking into this, this comment helped me http://codebutler.com/firesheep#comment_5843350

I have filevault turned on. Moving the binary out of my home folder (and adding a symbolic link) solved the problem.

zemaj··on Firesheep: Easy HTTP session hijacking from within Firefox
FYI if you're still looking into this, this comment helped me http://codebutler.com/firesheep#comment_5843350

I have filevault turned on. Moving the binary out of my home folder (and adding a symbolic link) solved the problem.

zemaj··on Firesheep: Easy HTTP session hijacking from within Firefox
Same setup. Sidebar shows for me after selecting it from the View -> Sidebar menu, however it pops up with a message that says "Run --fix-permissions first." Not sure where I'm supposed to run this flag.
zemaj··on "Twitter gave us no notice and no documentation which caused extended downtime"
Thought I'd post this here. Another day in our struggle of working on an increasingly hostile ecosystem for Twitter app developers. We were also IP blocked without notice twice in the 2 weeks beforehand. I had to send a support request to get us unblocked each time. We receive no notice and do nothing wrong, so are unblocked once our request is received. We have all kinds of protection on our end to stop agressive API activity being performed through our app, but that doesn't seem to help. Twitter provide us with no information about what we can do to stop being blocked.

It's frustrating.

zemaj··on Why God Did Not Create the Universe
All the article says is this; If I went into a casino picked a number on a roulette wheel and won straight away, you would be amazed. If I then did it a second & third time in succession, you would be incredulous. You might wonder if I was cheating the system or had some strange or divine powers.

However, if you then found out I had been going into a different casino only betting 3 times and walking away every hour of my life you would understand that it was just by chance that you happened to be there on the day that I won three times in a row. There is nothing to explain - no divine powers.

This is what Hawkings is arguing for the multiverse. Because there are many possible universes, the fact that ours has all the right qualities to sustain life is an inevitability. It's inevitable that one would be created and because we exist, we must inhabit one.

zemaj··on I'm Split Testing ... Why Haven't I Doubled My Revenue Yet?
If this holds for more situations, I guess the conclusion I would draw is that spilt testing should be done as far down the funnel as possible to generate the most return.
zemaj··on Too many laws, too many prisoners
I live in Australia and have been planning to migrate to the US in the near future. However this article has genuinely made me reconsider.

I knew there was an incarceration problem in the US, but I didn't realise it was this bad.

zemaj··on Where is the new Hacker News?
I've been here 1184 days, and consume the majority of my online news from links on HN.

It's always been like this.

Like any social news site, you can never get content that perfectly suits what you want. When you start looking for content you think doesn't suit your tastes, you will find always find it.

Nothing has changed.

Vote up posts you think suit HN and ignore ones you don't.

zemaj··on "Work for Hire" Contract Submitted as Evidence in Ceglia v. Facebook
Why would someone sit on something like this for 7 years? I can't think of any reasonable explanation. Facebook's lawyers also seem completely unprepared. How could Mark not have seen this coming? There's got to be an interesting story here.
zemaj··on My experiment with smart drugs (2008)
$400-$500 US at https://www.23andme.com/

They had a special deal for $99 when I got it, but that was very limited and they haven't done it since. Still I'd say if you hold out for a year that price will be halved. I generally recommend people to wait unless they're really interested in these things. The industry is still in its infancy. Cost is going down quickly and quality is going up just as fast.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →