HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zer00eyz

6,029 karma · joined June 24, 2014

submissionscomments
zer00eyz··on Trump administration is suspending Microsoft from a green card program
The CEO's of Alphabet and MS would like a word.
zer00eyz··on Trump administration is suspending Microsoft from a green card program
> If this was the case we wouldn’t also outsource positions.

Invert your argument: If outsourcing was so great, we wouldn't have any software jobs in the US.

The reason to outsource, to offshore are far more nuanced than "cost".

zer00eyz··on Trump administration is suspending Microsoft from a green card program
I have worked with a lot of H1B's in tech.

I have not met a single one who was not over qualified for the job they were doing.

I have only met a couple who were (to some extent) getting screwed because of an agency in the middle. However I would not have found the wage unreasonable and the markup was well within the industry standard.

H1B is a path to import talent that mostly wants to stay here... We need to fix the portion of the process where it is onerous to go from H1B to green card and citizenship.

zer00eyz··on “Math 2.0” will need to value mathematical progress more holistically
Before mobile phones you never called someone and asked "where are you" because a phone was tied to a location...
zer00eyz··on The first fully implanted cochlear implant reaches patients
> They think the lithium ion battery inside will need to be replaced in 15 years.

Pacemaker batteries have a 10 year replacement cycle and are lithium based, but don't get recharged (Just replaced). The concept of having to do this on a schedule is not that far fetched.

zer00eyz··on We're going to need default hard budget caps on pretty much everything
You mean you want to curb business Gacha?

AWS, is a loot box... Tokens are just in game currency, and that sales person is just metrics that have identified your spending as making you a whale.

Your average CTO from the last decade turned a fixed cost into variable spending that looks like a mobile game.

zer00eyz··on Big Tech ruined the cloud, so we're renaming ours
The thing is there are tons of "passive" automations that you still might want.

For instance, I left my garage freezer door open, in summer, once. The loss of food almost made me cry (just from the pure waste of it all). I have temp monitors now (external, with probes into fridges and freezers) as well as door sensors. If I am dumb and leave them open, or if they break I'm going to get a notification.

Windows/doors open, and it starts raining, alert... I have a whole set of alerts on when to open the windows too based on season and inside vs outside temp. I have seen a savings on my bills for heating and cooling.

Reminders of all kinds when it's not optimal to run the oven, or appliances because of power costs.

zer00eyz··on Big Tech ruined the cloud, so we're renaming ours
> I think the number of users who would use a full set of groups and permissions controls in their home is very small.

In the age of agents everywhere this is no longer true or viable.

It's going to be hard for them to do it, for historic and legacy code reasons. But it's long past being a choice and now becoming a need.

zer00eyz··on Don't be fooled–LLMs don't reason
This is the double edged sword of calling it AI, of using terms like Temperature and Hallucinate and Thought.

Stop trying to compare either system to a human and look at it for what it is -

A prediction engine that runs fast enough to brute force problems.

In the case of alpha go its "innovation" was millions of games played against itself. It had bound parameters and strict win conditions.

In the case of LLM's you can deploy 1000's of agents to smash themselves against an idea. The whole hugging face attack is an example of this (1200 agents out of an unknown number chose that path).

There is the old saying about monkeys, typewriters and Shakespeare. Well we have better monkeys who basically follow a derivative of zipfs law (not actually), who use tokens not letters and their goal in many cases is testable (compile, unit, E2E).

zer00eyz··on GPT 6.1 Sol: Near-Astra intelligence for a fifth of the price
It's all Gacha for business.
zer00eyz··on Sonnet 5.5
> With software, it’s a monthly fee that will continue to increase over time.

The fact that you think this is the way software is priced is telling.

The model being destroyed here is that every piece of software is something that needs to generate recurring revenue.

zer00eyz··on AI companies in race to demonstrate their model most threatening to humanity
Provider (party A) rents me an agent. I (party B) give it a task thats impossible. It goes and hacks someone else (Party C) in response - and causes actual damage.

Who is liable for that agents actions? The attack came from my network (curl commands from a local harness) but it was the agent running on the providers servers who did it. Who should have been keeping an eye on things? Who pulled the "trigger" here.

Go back to the hugging face attack and how they had to use an open weights model to figure out what was going on. This is a problem of asymmetry - You cant even use the tools attacking you to help resolve the attack because of "guardrails".

A lot of what we have seen so far is "poor security posture" and "poor engineering" - it been a lot of "go fast and break things" style growth in these companies and they are hitting the point where they need adults in the room. I suspect your take on "they need time" is spot on, and they haven't been willing to take that (to date).

zer00eyz··on Revealing the details of how OpenAI agents hacked Hugging Face
> It looks like a primitive chess engine, trying every move, no matter how stupid, until it works. Relying on its ability to do millions of operations rather than having a plan.

There is that old saying about monkeys and typewriters and Shakespeare - These are just better monkeys with bigger typewriters and ability to aim them at a goal.

I am by no means a doomer but for gods sake we need to have a grounded conversation. Because what happens when the DOD or NSA rolls up at OAI's front door and says "install that in our data center over here please" and uses it to go after someone with it?

Are banks (as some of the more security minded institutions) safe against 10000 concurrent, well coordinated attackers who do not ever rest?

Because there's a lot of potential for unintended 2nd order impacts from anything an agent can do, when done at scale.

I have to wonder if this is already going on, and every one is living under a gag order (it would not be the first time) and the calls for "regulation" are more about "not weaponizing it".

zer00eyz··on Two-tier encryption in the UK
No.

But processes that exist to preserve democracy that arent governed by that democracy are problematic. Saying the "king would never do..." when a king has makes the argument silly.

The UK is not alone in this - a great example is the filibuster in the us (a senate rule).

zer00eyz··on Two-tier encryption in the UK
> "but what if King kills someone"

Anne Boleyn, Catherine Howard would like a word.

zer00eyz··on Two-tier encryption in the UK
> What is the actual purpose of freedom of expression in a democracy? Is it being able to call people N-word online with no repercussions, or is it being able to organise, form political parties, and change the country?

What is the difference between the two? Because you're going to make a cultural argument and NOT a legal one. The C-word is one you throw around (and the Aussies to) but would cause an American woman be pretty upset. You seem perfectly fine with its use, but we frown on both terms socially but they are strictly legal.

Defamation VS political speech would be a better comparison, and I could make the argument that Americans being more lenient are better off with our freedoms.

zer00eyz··on Jev in 25 Lines of Python
> nothing about its...

Non deterministic systems have furthered the "brain rot" in our industry.

Lots of people were happy to ignore the code in their "supply chain" before LLM's - but suddenly not reading the LLM's output is a problem. I get they are different but we're in the same realm.

The lack of real data on performance of what ever application that one is trying to pitch is getting appalling. It's a lot of "trust me bro" this works better hand waving. And it's getting gross.

And how do we even measure nondeterministic systems? Because if I told you that Anthropic was spending millions of dollars having 1000's of agents "pre solve" benchmarks to build into their next version of the system you would scream they were cheating. Every one is focused on the "hacking" in the hugging face incident and no one is looking why they were even playing with those benchmarks in the first place.

"Trust me Bro"...

zer00eyz··on OpenAI is well positioned to fast-follow Jev
> Agreed. This isn't new. ...

It doesn't have to be new, it just has to be consumable by devs.

You could send text before Twilio. You could process credit cards before Stripe.

Jev, at the end of the day is an easy to use API.

Everyone seems to forget that usability is a thing.

zer00eyz··on AI Has No Wisdom and Neither Will You
> and aims to drive time to market metrics down aggressively with AI.

Go fast and break things has been a mantra for how long?

I think a lot of the laments about "good" code are really about "ownership" - and as someone who spent most of my working career in OTHER peoples code bases I have seen some things. There are a lot of you who think that your code bases are "great" when they are NOT. Personal understanding is not a good measure of quality.

The increased cadence from AI is just speed running to the legacy code base.

The answer: express the concern, and reiterate it after every issue that arises because of increased complexity. Start building a plan on how to "unravel" the mess, how to migrate things in place, how to start drawing boundaries in your systems. The system is designed to reward heroes who fix problems - you want to be super man who stops the bridge from falling apart, not the engineer who pushes the costly fixes it before it does.

zer00eyz··on I said no and Apple said yes
I have spent the last 28 years in the SF Bay Area, working in tech.

I have spent the last two months in Florida.

I was always aware of the disconnect between the insular world I lived in and what went on "outside" - but little did I know how big that gulf was.

If this was a car guy thread the complaint would be about a missing 3 horse power on his new Toyota when he put it on the dyno. And every one else is talking about their custom tunes, and scratch built systems, and how much better they are. Most people would not care and just want to drive to work.

How many of you are gonna have your Mom install linux and do support for it? How about your crazy uncle, or the slow cousin? Being done with Apple wont change Apple - make linux easy to use and usable. Or convince people that Apple > MS to force them to compete again. Or better yet both.

There is a business here.

zer00eyz··on I don't want to read what you didn't write
> e.g. python to English.

You're making a big assumption that the code is what is being executed, and not a compiled binary.

Where is the code: My repo? the clients? If it's in mine, the client does not have access and the CLI is a first stop to debugging. They arent in the context of written docs, more likely a production error from a log (thats now spitting out a message to check the CLI).

Less steps, less tools, more context in line and available in an interface your already using.

> they can ask an LLM to analyze it, within the context of their specific use case and your personal thoughts if any.

Or I can skim the man page it generated and make sure it looks good. The "work" (the tokens) dont have get spent over and over again.

zer00eyz··on I don't want to read what you didn't write
I will give you a use case where this is absolutely not the case.

I have a bunch of CLI utils I run for various clients and their peculiar setups. They now have man pages with descriptions and examples in them because the LLM went and read my code and did the needful.

I no longer have to re read my own code, rather I can just use the manual page.

Format and description came from semantics and context that (barely) existed elsewhere and I was not going to retain or transmit, but I have now.

zer00eyz··on Teen Social Media Bans Miss the Point
Im barely in the back half of Gen X. My oldest kids are grown now, but grew up with iPhones in their hands.

I am reminded of all the ridiculousness of the 1980s/1990s - "Its 10pm do you know where your kids are?" "I learned it by watching you dad!" Lawsuits around backwards message in music (Later PMRC), that Bevis and Butthead caused the child to burn down the trailer (fire! fire!)...

My kids hate social media for the most part - and are much more free range than their peers. Why? Because we did the hard work of parenting them! We were involved in their lives, from their grades to their social lives, to talking about the tech in their hand and the problems it can create.

We need to have a conversation about kids - about them being able to be outside, roaming, unattended without parents being arrested. About them having third spaces, about severe restrictions on their "freedom" in the world if we want to get to the heart of the issue. They are breaking this law because social media has become their "third space" that is parent free where they can explore and figure out the world.

zer00eyz··on Weeping whales: Stillborn humpback whale grieving documented
Orcas have also been seen to carry their dead calf's around.

https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/feature-story/southern-reside...

zer00eyz··on For AI leaders Doom is a form of hype
> Like if its true it can't be hype

https://www.npr.org/2016/07/26/487522807/why-the-public-perc...

Could AI kill us all. YES!!! Are the people who are building "AI" right now on that path? I would be hard pressed to say even "maybe".

Ultimately continuing to scale the way they have is getting increasingly expensive. Thats the quiet part that none of them are saying out loud...

AI could kill us all but we cant afford to get there, were maxed out and it doesn't look like even with 10x as much money we will is NOT good for sales.

Could a break through happen for recursive self improvement, or continuous learning or continuous training - sure. But that isnt as likely and right now NO ON can afford to run experiments because there isnt the capacity out there even if you have capital.

zer00eyz··on How to write an effective software design document
> It is often faster to just build the damn thing and see where it lands.

Part of documentation is figuring out if you're building the RIGHT thing. It give the opportunity to get feedback from more than one party.

The usability of most modern (complex) application is deplorable. I see things that a paper prototype with 5 people on the street should have stop dead in its tracks being rolled out with banners and trumpets.

And then no one ever wants to remove an unused or unprofitable feature. There is no bonus for it, no one puts that on their resume. But the feature you launched that really did enshitify the product gets put on there with 3 gold stars.

zer00eyz··on Nvidia is the central bank of AI
If you reshuffle your argument, and apply the same facts you get to a similar conclusion but with a drastically different spin.

> it's more specialization

China, constrained by hardware, and talent (not to slight the Chinese, but they are limited to domestic resources - and much of the US effort is very international). They did, what the Chinese do, and optimized the process of production, and drastically lowered the cost of development of their models. Cheeper to build, cheaper to run is just good economics.

Meanwhile in the us, we have open AI doing "experiments" - it looks like the costs around the hugging face hack are going to be about the same as China would spend on building out one of their smaller efforts (several million dollars). (Depending on whos numbers you trust, the fact that I can even make this claim should make you raise an eyebrow).

Go back to the 80s' and "expert systems" - most people will tell you that for their time, they were amazing, and useful. People would have loved to have more of them but they were so cost prohibitive that we all but abandoned them for serious use. The US frontier labs seem to have forgotten this lesson and their calls to "slow down" look like an excuse to "cut the waste so we can move to making money".

zer00eyz··on Fuck it, make it anyway
The language of the law attempts to be consistent, legal English isnt entirely the same as ours, it remains somewhat inured to modernization. It is, if nothing a domain specific way of writing. (There is a great bit by Lenny Bruce on this very topic)

If a basic filing with some citations is needed, letting one AI generate it, and then another validate it (to catch soft ball hallucinations) leaves it to be read and reviewed.

Lawyers, good ones, are by trade, critical readers and reviewers of documents. The contempt exists for those who fail to do this part of the job. Letting AI write your submission without reviewing it, validating it, is telling.

zer00eyz··on We must pace the frontier
Fusion Reactors, Flying Cars, Self Driving Cars...

We're really bad about predicting the future.

Look at the whole robot vacuum market. These aren't exactly great devices. They have low suction small bins and dont do a great job. People love them and think that they work so well. Why? Because they keep their house clean and avoid making the sorts of messes that would be easy to address with a larger vacuums.

zer00eyz··on We must pace the frontier
> Hypereautomation will kill jobs and destroy the economy.

What do you think that were going to hyper automate?

Did my gardener get faster? How about the plumber I need? Are you going to speed up the coroner? Are nurses going to be able to handle 2x the patients because of your work?

All AI has done, so far, is devalue software. It did that by democratizing its creation. We're delivering on the promise of VB script, and Apple Script and IFTT, and every drag and drop coding tool ever.

> companies are delivering products at vibe coding speeds

Who? Make me a list of companies saying that "We moved the needle with AI" who arent AI companies? I can name a couple - Grindr being the biggest name. Thats the really interesting use case here - because it's a niche product with a small team who is generating outsized value. AI tooling enables more of that - it's going to chip away at SAAS companies - their one sized fits all solutions are going to get eaten by smaller more efficient companies that are far more vertical focused.

You need to step outside the bubble of tech and look at the real world, on the ground, because it doesn't look anything like the SF Bay Area.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →