HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zeroname

189 karma · joined September 7, 2018

submissionscomments
zeroname··on Ask HN: What kind of information do you look for before learning/using new tech?
Popularity is a quality in its own right. If something is popular, there are experts who know how to deal with the issues. There are clients who need issues solved. There is a market.

Just take SAP, probably a pile of garbage in terms of quality, but it's paying its consultants handsomely and customers keep rolling in.

zeroname··on Ask HN: What kind of information do you look for before learning/using new tech?
> Microsoft is backing C# so that probably has a bright future

Not too long ago, that statement would've been seen as satirical. Microsoft has left a huge graveyard of technologies behind. They seem to be on a better track now, but I'd still be wary.

zeroname··on Ask HN: What kind of information do you look for before learning/using new tech?
1. Who uses it and what have they done with it?

2. Is it actively maintained? (How) are issues dealt with?

3. How popular is it and what is the trajectory?

I don't want to be the first person to run into all the issues. I'll let the kids do that, they love shiny new technology.

I don't want to invest into a stopgap technology (like Coffeescript). My gut feeling is that Elixir is one of these technologies, it has some good ideas that will probably show up elsewhere in due time.

I do value "XYZ sucks" posts to some degree, but unless I already know the technology reasonably well I probably won't be able estimate the impact of the issues.

zeroname··on Germany lays out a path to quit coal by 2038
> Maybe in a simple model of capitalism.

You may call it capitalism, but even the birds and the bees "understand" the concept of investing now for future gains.

> Example: no one invests in a nuclear power plant - unless the state insures the thing, finances (incl. all the costs that come from technological and construction problems) the thing all through...

That's just not true, lots of private capital has financed reactors before. Note that I never claimed that nuclear reactors are economically sensible (especially counting in disasters), but that if they were they would finance themselves. Indeed, there's a lot of hard-to-calculate risk in a nuclear reactor, which is bad from an investment standpoint.

> But it hasn't. France has built nuclear for many reasons - for example France is a country with nuclear weapons and thus has an interest in nuclear technology.

So what? The U.S. has the one of the largest nuclear arsenals in the world, yet they barely do nuclear at all.

> There is also an ideological trend to large state-driven/owned technologies.

So why don't they build giant state owned wind turbines?

> That's not how it works in the energy landscape. Check out TEPCO. The Japanese state does not let it die.

Whatever they do, the company isn't going to (be able to) pay the bill, unless they're not in fact bankrupt.

> You are shifting the goal post all the time. If enough countries do it (for example in the EU), then it matters.

Not really. Which countries are you talking about? The EU makes up maybe 10% of CO2 emissions and a big part of that isn't related to electricity. Think of all the research you could fund with the money spent on that forced premature rollout of renewable energy in Germany. Think of all the money that still needs to be spent to make it work. Think of what you actually achieved in terms of CO2 goals, so far. It's an absolute embarrassment.

zeroname··on Germany lays out a path to quit coal by 2038
> That's an illusion, especially in the energy sector. It has been for decades.

It's not an illusion, it's the basis of the economy. If something is known to be both useful and necessary, there is a profit to be made and capital will be allocated to it. That's the financial side. Of course for the energy sector there are lots of ideological, environmental and political concerns that need to be dealt with for things to actually happen.

> Because the costs are hidden and paid by the tax payer. The energy industry is mostly state owned and the price is political. That makes it not possible to charge the consumer with the real costs (like finding billions for the aging and expensive nuclear reactor fleet or for replacing them with newer reactors) - any president trying to do so would and does face mass protests.

Hard to ascertain. If it was really that unprofitable to produce nuclear energy compared to the (clean) alternatives, France could just build the alternatives. After all, the state foots the bill either way, unlike a private company that can just go bankrupt and not clean up their mess.

> One can see how this works in the UK with EDF's reactor:

> "If Hinkley really comes on stream by 2025 as planned, it will sell electricity at a guaranteed price that is double the current market level, with the excess cost passed to every UK consumer"

Yes, but the "current market level" is lower because of fossils, not because of renewables, which also need heavy subsidy. You can't have your cake and eat it too. If we're just arguing about market price, then clearly coal is the winner.

> Actually quite a lot of countries are.

None of the countries that really matter (have a significant share in CO2 emmissions) are.

zeroname··on Germany lays out a path to quit coal by 2038
> There are no neutral organizations.

That's only fair to say, therefore you must not mind me quoting some facts highlighted by "the other side":

"From the viewpoint of security of supply, so far wind power in Germany has replaced conventional power plant output of no more than 150MW. For comparison: In terms of the stability of the electricity grid in Germany, a power plant capacity of about 77,000 to 82,000 MW is required at the time of the annual peak load, which can occur usually on a late afternoon on a day in the period from November to February and is not known in advance"

https://docs.wind-watch.org/VGB-Windstudie-2017-Teil-1-EN.pd...

Your source just doesn't really deal with base load at all, even though that's the giant pink cigar-smoking elephant in the room. It can't be taken serious. It's starting with a premise ("Energiewende" is necessary) and works its way backwards, carefully avoiding to deal with the real issues. It's implying significant technological breakthroughs coming out of left field. It's all supposed to happen with taxpayer/consumer money, thrown around like candy. There's profiteering everywhere, lots of PR and lobbying, lots of moral grandstanding. In that environment, I can almost guarantee you, the money will be in the wrong hands. It won't be there when the real opportunities appear.

zeroname··on Germany lays out a path to quit coal by 2038
> Solar is not very volatile

Only if you disregard the fact that that the sun doesn't shine at night.

zeroname··on Germany lays out a path to quit coal by 2038
> That's your claim.

That's common sense. If something is both economically useful and necessary, it finances itself. You don't need subsidies at all, at most you need loans.

> Enough people here have been thinking the opposite.

So what? If "enough people" believe in Santa Claus, does that mean he'll all bring us presents on Christmas?

> Actually Germany a) does not have generally the most expensive electricity in Europe - check out industry prices for electricity in Europe.

Yes, industry is exempt because of lobbying. If industry had to pay those horrendous prices, it would damage Germany's competitiveness. Therefore, more to pay for the average citizen.

> If you followed recent protests in France, then you have seen that is also about higher energy prices for the public - which has been kept artificially low so far.

First of all, France has the cheapest electricity in all of Europe. Those protests were sparked by a "green tax" on fuel. I don't know what your point is, but it sounds like "green policy causes civil unrest in France". It's not helping your argument.

> That's a very shallow study about a non-goal (100%).

Fine, you may rely on 20% fossil fuels and maybe you'll be able to reduce the required storage cost from "absolutely infeasible" to "monumentally expensive". All to the end of removing a smidgen (less than 1%) from global CO2 emissions. The rest of the (developing) world isn't going to follow suit with that kind of pretentious nonsense.

> A more detailed study from 2013

That's all projections on what should happen, based on lots of ifs and maybes. It's utterly useless.

zeroname··on Germany lays out a path to quit coal by 2038
Flexibility is not the crucial issue. It's just what that large Tesla battery is good at, which is why everyone highlights it. In terms of capacity, it's next to nothing. No proponent wants to talk about that.

If you just look at the graph you'll see that dispatchable makes up almost 100% of base load during significant periods of time. Do the math on how many batteries and how much pumped storage you would need. It's simply not happening without fossils.

Australia uses natural gas so it can pull down CO2, but the coal is still exported and burned by someone else. It's a wash. Germany only has coal. If storage was feasible they wouldn't be standing there with their pants down on their CO2 goals. They would've built the best batteries and storage pumps the world knows.

zeroname··on Germany lays out a path to quit coal by 2038
> It's not 'unsolved' - it's just that it was economically not useful nor necessary nor wanted to store wind electricity in larger scales and this might be the case for another decade. Then we will see more storage coming online.

The whole thing wasn't economically useful or necessary from the very beginning, otherwise it wouldn't have needed massive subsidies that made Germany have the most expensive electricity in Europe.

> It's not 'unsolved' in the sense that we don't know what to do. It's just that storage needs are just starting to increase.

You don't know what to do. The storage requirements are massive:

https://www.oulu.fi/blogs/how-much-storage-does-the-energiew...

Think about it, if you did know what to do, why aren't all the politicians pointing to some clear-cut roadmap on how to achieve the goal, using all the great engineering prowess that Germany is famous for?

zeroname··on Germany lays out a path to quit coal by 2038
> Germany does not have a single wind turbine in a single location. It has vast numbers of them across many locations, many of which are situated in areas with near near constant wind. Across the whole portfolio of this production resource there is a certain minimum level of production which is consistently maintained.

Yes, but it's a fraction of total output and it's nowhere near enough to supply the actual base load.

> Yes, the meaning has spread to demand but the idea that base-load demand must be supplied by 'base-load' power plants such as coal or nuclear is a piece of sophistry that quickly dissolves when it is examined closely. Just one reason being that their supply is not guaranteed (as I have described above).

What quickly dissolves into sophistry is the idea that wind energy is remotely comparable to coal or nuclear in terms of supplying base load. Yes, an individual coal plant doesn't have 100% reliability, but it's still massively less volatile than wind.

> [1] https://medium.com/@TheAustraliaInstitute/gas-coal-power-has....

Okay, let's look at Australia: https://reneweconomy.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/Disap...

What's that big grey part that is "dispatchable"? It's mostly natural gas, which Australia has plenty of (7% of exports), but Germany would need to import. Australians can pat themselves on the back for not using any more coal in the grid, but they still ship it off (16% of exports) for someone else to burn it.

zeroname··on Germany lays out a path to quit coal by 2038
> Base-load power is the power that continues to be generated even when there is low demand for it.

That is wrong. Base load is the minimum demand of electricity at any given moment over a time span. The base load that a wind turbine without buffer storage can supply is zero. The same goes for solar, obviously. The vast majority of renewable energy in Germany happens to be wind, its storage and transport remains the biggest (and unsolved) challenge.

zeroname··on Germany lays out a path to quit coal by 2038
This is highly misleading information from the usual suspects. The total output in kWh of heavily subsidized solar/wind energy is not the issue.

The problem of the "Energiewende" is that the highly volatile wind/solar output can not supply the base load without massive buffer storage. The technology for that storage does not exist. Only nuclear, coal or the more expensive natural gas can supply the base load.

What actually makes the whole charade work is that Germany dumps surplus electricity (at a loss) during peak times and then imports what's missing during down times from other countries (for example the highly nuclearized France). If all the neighboring countries did what Germany does, it couldn't work.

zeroname··on How to Be Successful
Doesn't matter, once you're past a certain age, almost nobody will hire you as a programmer. Don't build your entire career on it.
zeroname··on Oregon Bottle Deposit System Hits 90 Percent Redemption Rate
Has somebody bothered to estimate the cost of this whole process in terms of overall energy expenditure and waste of irreplacable human lifetime?

Achieving a 90% redemption rate could still be 100% nonsense.

zeroname··on Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize
> General software development gets moved overseas and comes back all the time.

General software development also isn't unionized. As soon is it is, moving overseas becomes vastly more attractive.

> Software development is hard. Pushing it to a cheaper third party usually increases costs a lot in the long term due to the increase is development complexity and generally a decrease in worker skill.

What's actually harder about outsourcing is management and quality control. The developers in cheaper countries aren't somehow inherently worse.

Many publishers have studios around the world, working on entire games by themselves. Why keep funding an expensive studio in the US that's getting unionized? That better be high caliber, which most studios aren't.

> A strong union can also prevent companies from moving some jobs overseas.

Maybe in a big monolithic company, but that's not how game publishers operate.

zeroname··on Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize
They are doing it. Outsourcing has a cost unto itself though, just like unionizing has a cost.
zeroname··on Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize
You didn't address the more important point: Managers can get away with it by moving production to cheaper places. It's already happening anyway.

What a lot of people don't realize is that unions can also cause wage suppression when they decide that more members working is better than fewer members working at higher pay.

zeroname··on Nearly Half of Game Developers Want to Unionize
The production value behind those "bare bones" titles is still magnitudes larger than what you had back then, while the "play time" is at least comparable.

Statistics show that most people never finish the games anyway (I certainly don't) so it's only fair that those people who must really play everything pay extra.

zeroname··on Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore
Virtually anybody who runs a successful business believes that a good business environment is also good for the country.
zeroname··on Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore
If he didn't care about the UK then why would he vocally support a Brexit? That's a clear contradiction.

To put it another way, I can argue for a better business environment in my home country while simultaneously having all my business in a country that actually has such an environment.

zeroname··on Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore
In the short run, Brexit will be bad for business, especially if it happens as uncoordinated as it looks now. In the long run, nobody knows, but at least there's potential to negotiate favorable deals without dealing with the EU.
zeroname··on Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore
Where exactly is the hypocrisy? Singapore has been touted as a model on how to organize trade after Brexit.

Of course you want a trade deal with the EU after Brexit. One major problem with being in the EU is that it forces the UK to uphold tariffs and tariff-like restrictions on imports from non-EU countries. Singapore itself has little to no tariffs.

With a hard Brexit, those deals simply won't exist yet, so it's wise to move to place where they do exist.

zeroname··on Backblaze Hard Drive Stats for 2018
Ten people give their opinions, as requested. One person thinks you're arrogant and tells you so.

You can't argue with results.

zeroname··on Valve Breaks the Shackles of Proton
> I worry that developers will see this as an alternative to native Linux ports

You should worry that developers will not see this as an alternative to native Linux ports. Ongoing support for Linux just isn't worth it, it has been proven time and time again. If developers instead focused on Proton/WINE as a platform they might get some real value with only minor effort.

The problem with Linux users is that they're the armchair developers in every comments section, complaining that some port is bad because it's "not native" or not 100% as good as the Windows version. You just have to ignore that.

zeroname··on Most “ugly” produce gets turned into soups, sauces, salsa, jam
The post originally linked to a youtube video of that same guy sitting in front of a laptop, researching specs. I did watch that one.

Again, even if those bananas see no other use than being dumped, that doesn’t mean they would’ve been consumed by actual humans if it hadn’t been for those standards. Some other organism will consume them instead.

zeroname··on Most “ugly” produce gets turned into soups, sauces, salsa, jam
I guess "spite" might be an underappreciated factor of real-world (un-)economics.
zeroname··on Most “ugly” produce gets turned into soups, sauces, salsa, jam
> Many times the farmers are given such a low ball offer, that is basically expecting them to sell for loss. The farmer does the obvious. Takes their produce, dump in a lake near by as garbage, because it often doesn't economic make sense to take it back.

That doesn't make any economic sense either. How is "selling at a loss" (i.e. taking in less money than it costs to produce) worse than dumping the produce (taking in no money whatsoever)?

There has to be some other factor at play here.

zeroname··on Most “ugly” produce gets turned into soups, sauces, salsa, jam
Actually it isn't. It's the same kind of poor research that the rant is about. Those are cosmetic specifications for supermarket stock, nowhere does it say what happens with the produce that doesn't meet them. It's simply insinuated that it goes to waste, but that isn't true.

The supermarkets know very well what kind of produce doesn't sell, so these specs actually prevent waste, because unsold produce that is about to spoil really does go to waste.

zeroname··on A high-carb diet may explain why Okinawans live so long
> a healthy diet really can just be summed up as "eat food, not too much, mostly plants"

Absolutely not. We do know enough about malnutrition to say that this statement is false.

It has also been demonstrated that "zero carb" diets have all sorts of short-term desirable outcomes, such as weight loss or controlling diabetes. Your "don't eat too much, mostly plants" diet fails here.

What we don't know is the long-term outcomes of that (or any other) diet. Frankly, I'd rather risk a shorter life than continue a life of obesity, which is also associated with higher mortality.

← PreviousPage 5 of 16Next →