HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zeroname

189 karma · joined September 7, 2018

submissionscomments
zeroname··on The CRISPR Baby Scandal Gets Worse by the Day
> The absence of a legal prohibition doesn't mean something is ethical

Nobody claimed otherwise. Legality is not the point.

> ... it can mean that the perceived incidental costs of policing it outweighs the benefits.

That's an ethical defense. We can disagree about the costs and benefits of abortion or genetic engineering, but purely based on principles I don't see how you can defend non-medically indicated abortion but not genetic engineering.

zeroname··on The CRISPR Baby Scandal Gets Worse by the Day
> It does not follow. Similar: even in "employment-at-will" jurisdictions, where you can fire anyone at any time without giving justifications, you are not allowed to fire someone for a slew of protected reasons, such as becoming a whistleblower, their sex/age/sexual orientation/race, or joining a union.

...which is a contradiction! Legislation like that arises through conflicting requirements coming from different directions. So, if you want to fire someone based on their race, you must not disclose it, but you can still do it. It obviously doesn't make sense, it just happens to be the law.

I'm not talking about the law anyway, I'm talking about ethics. Really the argument I am making is that maybe abortion for any reason isn't ethically defensible, but if it is, then all kinds of other things become defensible on that platform.

zeroname··on The CRISPR Baby Scandal Gets Worse by the Day
Poor comparison. Let's not forget that it's legal for people with hereditary diseases to procreate, would you compare that with "poisoning the water supply"?

Furthermore, here are some legal ways to crudely "engineer" the DNA of your future offspring:

- smoking

- drinking

- legal prescription drugs

- exposing yourself to ionizing radiation

That counts for both males and females, of course with pregnant females the effects are vastly amplified.

zeroname··on The CRISPR Baby Scandal Gets Worse by the Day
> - it is not actually defensible to abort fetuses based on sex.

If it's ethically defensible to abort fetuses for no particular reason (i.e. general legalized abortion) then it follows that abortion for any particular reason is ethically defensible.

> - genetic engineering might make populations more susceptible to epidemics

genetic engineering also might make populations less susceptible to epidemics

> - it would increase pressure on others, or other nations, to follow suit so as not to fall behind in the “race race” of eugenics

That's indeed a possibility.

> - it would seem to devalue non-engineered life, directly threatening the universal dignity of all human beings

First of all, there's no such thing as "universal dignity of all human beings", different societies have different conceptualizations of "dignity" and its consequences. Even then, why should being genetically engineered threaten your dignity or that of others? Engineered humans are still humans. Their DNA isn't necessarily any different than what some natural mutation could've come up with.

> - your tired meme is tired

I'm actually dead serious.

zeroname··on The CRISPR Baby Scandal Gets Worse by the Day
If it's ethically defensible to abort a child based on its sex (or for any other non-medical reason), it should be ethically defensible to mess with its genome.

I, for one, welcome our new Chinese designer baby overlords.

zeroname··on Market Moves Suggest a Recession Is Unavoidable
It would still be stupid to buy in at the top of the market if you assume it's going to tank - which is far more likely now.
zeroname··on Market Moves Suggest a Recession Is Unavoidable
That would assume everybody can interpret the information correctly and make an unemotional decision regarding their investments. In reality, everyone wants the party to go on indefinitely.
zeroname··on US military to tech protestors: “We’re at war; pick a side”
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window
zeroname··on Uber Is Headed for a Crash
> I don't think that's right but that's how the system works these days.

That's not how "the system" works, that's what the investment climate is like at this point in the business cycle. Money is cheap and investments are equally unwise.

zeroname··on Uber Is Headed for a Crash
> The author doesn’t cite growth rates, customer acquisition costs of lifetime value of the customer and without that it’s not clear they know what they’re talking about. If CAC << LTV and you have a high growth rate and your cost per ride is coming down then they should be doing exactly what they’re doing.

If, if and if. There's no reason to believe that costs come down with significantly with (even larger) scale, or that people will prefer Uber over competitors or ordinary taxis, once they raise prices. The main reason why Uber has so little competition is that it's simply a bad business model, but massive growth in todays environment attracts enough investors to keep the ship above water for a long time.

> The investor around the table are not dumb.

That's not implied, the idea is that enough greater fools will be found once the stock goes public.

> There’s a reason I don’t even go to Lyft anymore—Uber is way better than it was a few years ago.

Uber simply has more money to burn. Enjoy your rides while it lasts.

zeroname··on Valve creates new revenue sharing tiers to give big sellers a break
> You only need to read their blogs to see how it’s hurting the “good” indie developers.

I don't think so. The odds are that if they failed with sales on their indie game, instead of admitting that there a thousand developers just as good as them who are fighting for a slice of the pie, they'd rather blame the platform.

Again, I have never been presented any of these asset flips on Steam. I do see hundreds of games that appear to be well-made every week and I don't even have the time to take a closer look at even a fraction of them, much less buy and play them.

zeroname··on Valve creates new revenue sharing tiers to give big sellers a break
I don't get your historic analogy. Yes, you could make a game that rivaled the games of the big guys, all on your own. However, there's no way you could've gotten your game into the major sales outlets without a publisher. That publisher would've never given you a 70% cut. In that regard, you're far better off now.
zeroname··on Valve creates new revenue sharing tiers to give big sellers a break
> See for yourself: > https://insights.stackoverflow.com/survey/2018/#salary

Like I said, you need to factor out those unsuccessful developers that don't make any money. This is self-reported data is of questionable merit, but if you switch to US, game developers aren't at the bottom anymore and none of the salaries listed are bad in any way.

Again, if you do what you love, you should be able to stomach a pay hit. If you don't love it after all, don't wait for the industry to change, change industries yourself.

> Itch.io yields about 1% of the revenue of Steam.

That doesn't generalize across different titles. Maybe some title has zero visibility on Steam, but some visibility on itch.io. Then you're better off with itch.io.

Either way, it's just a guess.

> No, only once a game reaches $10 million of total sales revenue.

I misread that, my bad.

zeroname··on Valve creates new revenue sharing tiers to give big sellers a break
I have never seen any of these on "my" Steam. It's not part of my shopping experience in any way.

I know they exist because Jim Sterling sometimes makes funny videos about them, but I can't fathom how they make a significant impact on "genuine" developers.

zeroname··on Valve creates new revenue sharing tiers to give big sellers a break
It's not just lack of marketing, it's the fact that there are now far more games, but gamers have neither more money nor time to compensate.

There are too many game developers, it's as simple as that. Too many millennials don't want the regular old "grown up" jobs anymore, they want to be creatives or artists and the market just can't soak them all up.

If you think it's hard as a game developer, try living off painting or sculpture or music or literature. The vast majority never get there. Meanwhile, a game programmer at least has ordinary programming jobs to fall back on - if they can stomach it.

zeroname··on Valve creates new revenue sharing tiers to give big sellers a break
If you look into it you will find that you can buy many indie games directly from the developer and still get a Steam key.

If you don't want that Valve charges "too much" from indies, then you should be proactive and join other marketplaces. It's a hen-egg situation.

zeroname··on Valve creates new revenue sharing tiers to give big sellers a break
> Already game developers are the lowest paid workers in the IT industry

That is not true if you factor out all the people developing games independently on their own dime, against better financial advice. To counteract that, there just aren't enough developers working on enterprise Java architecture for no money, out of passion.

It's also only fair that people who get to work on "fun" things like games are paid less. If they don't think it's fun, they can switch industries and earn more. Nobody is doomed to be a game developer.

> I'm not arguing against any change, it just seems spiteful that Valve are sticking it to the little guys who can't go anywhere else.

The little guys can go to itch.io, which charges as low as 0% commission. They may even have more visibility on there than on Steam, given that it's a smaller pond. There's also the Humble Store, which leaves commission up to the buyer.

> This could have been a great chance to improve Steam overall, by reducing the commissions for all developers...

They did reduce commissions for everyone by 5%. The extra 5% is for those who are at risk of moving off the platform because they can create their own visibility.

zeroname··on Retail Arbitrage at Walmart [video]
> No, it was PS3s. Here is an article about it from the time: https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2006/12/6406/

It doesn't say they had to sell at a loss, just that they didn't get the ridiculous markup they hoped for.

The PS3 really was in short supply and prices did remain elevated. The article mentions that.

zeroname··on Retail Arbitrage at Walmart [video]
Exactly. The existence of arbitrage doesn't "defy" the law of one price, it is its entire foundation. What a bold display of economic illiteracy.

Next up: English major at NPR discovers the economic secret to free lunch.

zeroname··on FOSS is free as in toilet
> In the USA they used to have paid toilets but got rid of them because it was called discrimination against the poor.

Meanwhile, in "socialist" Europe, paid toilets are the norm. Then again, wild urination isn't a sex offense either.

zeroname··on Is Neuroscience a Bigger Threat than Artificial Intelligence?
"Besides its economic threat, the advance of AI seems to pose a cultural threat: if physical systems can do what we do without thought to give meaning to their achievements, the conscious human mind will be displaced from its unique role in the universe as a creative, responsible, rational agent."

That's a bit of an aggrandizing characterization for the gang of monkeys that climbed down the trees a couple of ice ages ago, that almost nuked itself over a disagreement on the best way of distributing bananas, roughly speaking.

"We are agents in the world, whose decisions, choices, actions are made meaningful by the content of the belief/desire pairings that bring them about. But what if the theory of mind that underwrites our distinctiveness is build on sand, is just another useful illusion foisted upon us by the Darwinian processes that got us here? Then it will turn out that neuroscience is a far greater threat to human distinctiveness than AI will ever be."

Oh my, a threat to our distinctiveness! Next thing those scientists will tell us that the earth is not the center of the universe, that the stars in the sky aren't fixed and that indeed Santa Claus himself is not a real person running a sweatshop at the north pole.

zeroname··on Hiroshima (1946)
> Not for a while, I think. We only had two bombs at the time. IIRC it would have taken months (weeks?) to build another.

It wasn't that far off:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bombings_of_Hiroshima_a...

zeroname··on Hiroshima (1946)
> This point in particular comes up a lot , but there is scant actual evidence for it.

There is scant evidence for this (honest question)?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Downfall#Operation_K...

> Contemporary US military estimates of a ground invasion get nowhere near those casualty numbers

That's pretty irrelevant, because hindsight is 20/20. Given the conduct of Japanese in the war, it wouldn't have seemed implausible at the time. The soviets sacrificed millions of their people to repel the Nazis.

zeroname··on Backdoor in event-stream library dependency
> Dozens of emails / notifications, people pinging / bothering you on multiple platforms, multiple emails, etc.

Two options:

1. Stop supporting the package, mark it as deprecated, ignore/delete the spam

2. Hand over project to a stranger, endangering all of your users

One of these options is irresponsible, the other one isn't. I'm not asking anyone to do something for me, I'm asking them to not do something for the sake of sanity.

> It's stupid to blindly trust someone's code, regardless of who they are of if they are the current maintainer, that is not how you build secure software.

I agree, but both of us know that pretty much the entire Javascript ecosystem is exactly that stupid. Let me ask you: What have you personally done to vet your dependencies? Have you used Babel or any of the other popular Javascript packages that have a huge dependency tree? If you have, chances are you are effectively blindly trusting all the developers in that tree. You're not checking every single commit that goes into it.

> If you want to start some organization which vets people for maintainers go for it, but don't expect maintainers to do it, I can guarantee you that thousands of maintainers do not.

I don't expect that they do, I expect that if they fuck up that their reputation takes a hit. That would some incentive for not fucking up. Instead, there isn't even any consensus that this guy fucked up. He's taking no responsibility whatsoever.

zeroname··on Hiroshima (1946)
It's obviously not true that the US can do as it pleases, it can't afford to go to war whenever it wants, its army is really expensive. Also, virtually of the foreign interventions done by the US in the last decades have been failures.

Just ask yourself, why are there all these crooked foreign leaders that make a living of antagonizing the US? If the US is really so powerful because of its nukes, why don't they just surrender?

zeroname··on Hiroshima (1946)
The real reason is that no other major country has a white vest either. Look at this list, the USA barely ever shows up:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_and_anthropogenic...

zeroname··on Hiroshima (1946)
> What surprised me most how many citizens didn't feel that its use was inhuman.

It's all about context. At that point in history, the Japanese forces had already murdered millions of non-Japanese. Furthermore, firebombing campaigns on Japan caused way more civilian casualties than the atomic bombs. The Japanese leadership was ready to sacrifice millions in a possible ground invasion. Fortunately, the war stopped at "only" two atomic bombs, there were more to come...

zeroname··on First gene-edited babies claimed in China
> Again, you are effectively arguing that it would be ethical for a doctor to try to experimentally create a glow-in-the-dark baby if asked to by the mother.

No, I am not arguing that. That's an embarrassingly absurd conclusion to draw.

These babies have a risk of life-long HIV impairment. This intervention may prevent this. With any medical intervention, you need to trade off risk and reward. Obviously, for an unborn child, there can not be any consent here.

It would be unethical to not give the babies the treatment if there wasn't any risk associated. What makes it unethical is that the risk profile isn't even known. The scientific foundation is poor.

> Anyway, this discussion doesn't seem to be going anywhere productive, so I will bid you good day.

I agree and let me say this: You're by far the worst discussion partner I have ever had on HN.

zeroname··on Backdoor in event-stream library dependency
> Easy for people who have zero packages and no pressure to say.

If you have this "no warranty, no responsibility" attitude then how can you have pressure to maintain anything? How does that translate into pressure to hand off the project to strangers? Nobody asked for that.

> Don't contribute to OSS and you have no problems.

Yes, please don't contribute if you have this kind of attitude. It's harmful. If you can't maintain the package, deprecate it. Don't hand it over to an unvetted entity. If we can just agree on that M.O. we'll have a much better situation.

> If these huge companies profiting off OSS work actually contributed financially and with time, maybe maintainers would happily remain maintaining.

Ifs and buts and sugar and nuts. They don't contribute, they never have and they probably never will, you are responsible for your packages even if you are doing it voluntarily.

zeroname··on Backdoor in event-stream library dependency
> Meritocracy is an outdated discriminatory practice.

Of course merit is judged subjectively (like anything else), but what exactly is the alternative?

In particular, I don't find anything actionable in that manifesto in regards to decision making.

← PreviousPage 8 of 16Next →