HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zoltz

188 karma · joined September 24, 2007

submissionscomments
zoltz··on Noble or savage? Hunter-gatherers
The current Economist issue contains a letter on this story by Stephen Corry, Director, Survival International, London. From the letter:

"The Sentinelese are not the only tribe of hunter-gatherers who still resist contact with the outside world ("Noble or savage?", December 22nd). There are over 100 uncontacted tribes worldwide, many of them hunter-gatherers. Nor are the Sentinelese warlike. They defend their tiny island with good reason--intruders have shot and killed Sentinelese, and neighbouring tribes have been wiped out after contact with outsiders."

http://www.economist.com/opinion/displaystory.cfm?story_id=1...

zoltz··on The Raven Paradox (logic)
"The green apple does indeed offer the same infinitesimal evidence that all ravens are pink, but by going through the set of non-pink objects in the universe and eventually finding a raven, the proposition will be disproven."

I had residual doubts about these pink ravens, but that's a great way to put it. Now I really feel "on top" of the paradox.

zoltz··on The Raven Paradox (logic)
I'd go with Dave Cole. From the Wikipedia article: "when one finds a black raven, it is a much more important discovery than finding a non-black object simply because there are fewer black ravens than everything else"

Finding a black raven yields evidence that all ravens are black.

Finding a green apple also yields evidence that all ravens are black, but very weak, much weaker than finding a black raven. It offers the same weak (and in this case misleading) evidence that all ravens are pink.

zoltz··on The Raven Paradox (logic)
The part of the Wikipedia article you quote has nothing to do with what you quote it for.
zoltz··on From 10 Hours a Week, $10 Million a Year - Plenty of Fish
There may be an underlying reason for the difference in tastes here: if you are generally inclined to reflect on the things you encounter you don't want to be presented irrelevant clutter because it wastes your reflection resources. The "masses" are not inclined that way, for them it's just: the more they get presented with the better.
zoltz··on The Late Victorian Holocaust
In addition to this, nobody ever seems to talk about British responsibility for the creation of some of today's major conflicts, such as:

- Kashmir, where nuclear powers India and Pakistan have been close to war;

- Israel/Palestine, which poisons the whole world.

The only one I ever heard pointing this out in Britain was a comedian, and the audience was laughing heartily. (Sorry don't remember who it was.)

But it is really a newspaper conspiracy, as the story claims? My impression is that World War II outshines the whole rest of British history. The British are incredibly proud that they stood up to the Nazis, and who can deny they were on the good side in a huge and unusually clear case of "good against evil".

zoltz··on Never. Ever. Cargo-cult.
"understanding the advantages of something is far superior to accepting it solely based on the recommendation of an authority"

This is not as obvious as it sounds because it costs time to get to your own understanding. It depends.

zoltz··on Radical constraints can lead to breakthroughs in simplicity and entirely new things
I agree that this is the potentially "hottest" statement from the story. Yet only two examples are given: Google and Twitter. Taking away the clutter around the search box was a good idea, but wasn't Google's real innovation something like counting links to pages to judge their significance? The Twitter example is better, but one example is not enough to make the case. Are there others?
zoltz··on Coral reefs operate free-market economy: fish cleaning stations
You're right, the article is not new. I was just looking for something free on the web, and in English. A new article on this has just appeared in: Frankfurter Allgemeine Sonntagszeitung, 30 December 2007, economy section. There it says also that fish whose territory is so small that they can't choose between stations have been shown to get worse service and longer queues.
zoltz··on When non-technologists write about technology: about The Economist's "Technology in 2008"
The Economist is never wrong. But who is "pmarca".
zoltz··on Spreading the load: volunteer computing
"Thanks to the exquisite pattern-recognition capabilities of the human brain, amateurs with just a little training can distinguish between different types of galaxy far more efficiently than computers can."

It used to be considered noteworthy when computers were better at something than people, not the other way round. The tables may be turning ...

zoltz··on Matt Maroon: Why I Quit Playing Poker For A Living
> You can't really compare the two

I'll still try. Both games have a philosophical and a computational side. The chess philosopher could ask questions such as

"everyone knows that dominating the centre is an advantage, but WHY EXACTLY is that the case"

But even if he understands this better than others, it won't help him that much because chess games are decided on the computational side. This is why you have to start at an early age in order to become a great chess player. And it suits computers.

Poker's computational side includes, for example, odds (trivial) and ICM. In most forms of poker, though, it is far outweighed by the philosophical side, at least as of today. The poker philosopher could ask questions such as

"everyone knows that being in position is an advantage, but WHY EXACTLY is that the case"

If he's willing to work hard on his understanding of the game, he might, in theory, learn the rules at any age and become the world's best poker player in just a few years. Getting direct monetary value from one's philosophical insights is an attractive proposition. Unfortunately there are big psychological drawbacks, which Matt Maroon describes so well.

zoltz··on How to Do Philosophy
Really that's what I thought when reading this essay. And I agree that some of your essays are exactly what philosophy should be. But most are advice about startups rather than philosophy (although you can still see they were written by a philosopher), and some state specific observations. Maybe the philosophy essays deserve their own directory?
← PreviousPage 2 of 2