Also, the Arizmendi cooperative is named after the founder of Mondragon, Jose Maria Arizmendiarrieta.
328 karma · joined July 1, 2015
Also, the Arizmendi cooperative is named after the founder of Mondragon, Jose Maria Arizmendiarrieta.
The only type of "well run, ethical companies" where unions are redundant are worker-owned cooperatives. Otherwise, an employer, regardless of how ethical they are, can never replicate the most critical aspect of unions: collective bargaining rights. Sure, an employer can essentially just implement the kind of benefits that would be negotiated by a union, but it does not replace the fact that until a union exists employees have essentially no means to collectively demand changes to compensation and working conditions unless they unionize.
But you shouldn't be so sure that it has had zero influence, either.
There are plenty of gigantic corporations who are probably looking forward to eventually acquiring parts of Google. I wouldn't put it past Verizon, who has not only partnered with Google but also fought for telecom control against them. Don't we also need to break these companies up as well? Or do they have too much influence in the government? Ajit Pai, for example, famously worked for Verizon before government.
I'm not trying to protect Google. But I just think that the government needs to find a way to enforce these breakups more evenly or else it just leads to further consolidation, as you pointed out.
If anything, CEQA and other environmental regulations have contributed more to improving the quality of life for working class people and the poor than it has contributed to their detriment. California is the median for poverty in the US and also happens to be in the top 15 for quality of life while also being in the top 10 most environmentally friendly states. Because of that, I don't see a correlation between environmentalism and poverty.
> This is the part which made me feel you disagreed with it.
I am aware, and as I already explained, this is a rhetorical device which you mistook for my own personal belief. Obviously I don't believe OSS is bad. It's friggen great.
And that's a fair question. I am absolutely not saying that open source means you must maintain it. I am simply saying if you call yourself a maintainer then you are responsible for maintaining. If you don't want to maintain OSS, then don't. Just don't pretend you're a maintainer and that you have no responsibility to maintain. At best, pass it on to someone willing to maintain it. At worst, pretend you're working on it. As I said in my original comment, others should fork as needed.
And to add, I don't believe the original subject of the article, the now former maintainer of actix-web, did the wrong thing. I am in agreement with their decision to drop out. No one should be held to an unrealistic standard by entitled users and expected to put up with that BS. The part of my original comment that everyone has a problem with is seriously the least consequential phrase. Blows my mind that everyone is hyper focused on taking it out of context as well.
What you are responding to is a rhetorical response I gave as an argument against the dismissive idea that an open source maintainer should have no responsibility unless they are getting paid. I don't agree. I find that it's a maintainer's responsibility not to extend, but to maintain. That's all I'm arguing.
If someone wants to throw OSS at the wall to see if it sticks with no obligation to maintain, then that's fine. But as soon as someone puts on the maintainer hat, I think it's reasonable to say they are accepting responsibility for that role.
And if you're intentionally doing any of the things you listed above, then you're not a maintainer. That simply is not what maintaining means.
It's moments like this that I reflect on the past and the public and virtual forums I have participated in... and how my own attitude shifts in favor of cooperation when I must couple my face with my words. And I wonder if others feel the same.
The article states pretty clearly from the interview with Senator Mark Warner:
> “To my knowledge, Health and Human Services has done nothing about it,” Warner told TechCrunch. “As Health and Human Services aggressively pushes to permit a wider range of parties to have access to the sensitive health information of American patients without traditional privacy protections attached to that information, HHS’s inattention to this particular incident becomes even more troubling,” he added.
It's not that they're doing nothing, they're supposedly making it worse.
They're also underfunded. OCR budget dropped to 10% of its previous budget between 2017 and 2018:
https://www.hhs.gov/about/budget/fy2018/budget-in-brief/ocr/...
So, when you ask "why would these companies care?", I think the current federal government is trying to say "these companies _should not_ care."
Alternatively, the primary difference between the USA and PRC is not that the US necessarily has more global influence, but that the PRC does not pretend to value the autonomy of its citizens.