HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zug_zug

12,715 karma · joined April 18, 2014

Tech dude
submissionscomments
zug_zug··on Show HN: Factorio but with unreliable components
I'll try to make the UI better for mobile browsers. I hadn't intended for it to be on mobile, but let me brainstorm on that.
zug_zug··on Show HN: Factorio but with unreliable components
I appreciate those two points of feedback. I'll work on those today.
zug_zug··on ADHD, autism or complex trauma? [pdf]
Yeah so I think when most people these days say trauma, they simply mean "An ongoing emotional overreaction due to a past negative experience." I think that's a super useful concept.

In your case I'd just ask myself "Do I still feel like I'm a bother in situations where I know I'm not because of X?" And if so, it can be productive to see if you can change that directly or indirectly.

zug_zug··on On social reality in China
I don't live in a major city.

Looking at the research it shows that subjects who self-identify as loving America can be preducted by best by being older, and political party, though not wealth at all.

So I don't really have any hard-data to justify my impression that it's uneducated blue-collar white men without much going for them that vociferously love america, maybe it's just country music that gives that impression, or the type of uneducated poor who enter the army with blind faith in our institutions, etc.

zug_zug··on On social reality in China
I don't have any personal experience with this, but what's interesting to me is how similar a lot of this sounds to America. I'm not saying it IS the same as America, just that if there is a substantive difference I didn't get a sense of it

- Nationalism stemming from insecurity (I tend to notice the poorest, most desperate tend to be the proudest)

- "social death" - Is that not so different that being canceled or fear of being canceled? To me it seems very apparent that people who get ostracized on the national stage take a huge personal toll and have their personality changed for years.

- Also for the Dark World example he uses a Peter Thiel quote. I think optimism/trust/community is lower here now that a few decades ago. But I do agree that in tech jobs I've anecdotally seen more cutthroat approaches (e.g. refusing to share knowledge with a coworker) from other cultures more often.

zug_zug··on DeepSeek Harness Desktop for macOS and Windows
So for me, literally I was trying to solve a problem with an AI agent and it threw the term at me. It is a real and useful concept, but my hypothesis is that a certain AI release started using and a bunch of people said "Oh this makes me sound smart/trendy" and started using it every chance they got.

We like to think we aren't token predictors, but the amount of sheer regurgitation I see from us humans makes me wonder (also "commoditize your complement", and so many others)

zug_zug··on Thought-Terminating Cliché
I mean interesting article, but I think I would consider them more "conversation -terminating" than "thought-terminating."

Like if somebody says "It is what it is" I take that to mean mean "I'm done hearing you complain about this."

zug_zug··on The last time my family was replaced by technology
And my great great grandpa thought horses would lose all their jobs to cars. And they all did and it was never the same again.

There’s no quick answers, but intuitively I think we all get that the % of jobs not doable by AI and robotics approaches 0 over time.

zug_zug··on DraftKings is using AI to behaviorally target chronic gamblers
Somebody said (I think it was FrostPrime) roughly: Gambling is genuinely the scariest drug, I actually think it's worse than cocaine and it's just right there on your phone.

I think that really framed the issue well to me. Imagine having an addiction problem and having to carry the problem substance around with you 24/7.

zug_zug··on 500k facial scans at UK stations yield no arrests, 1 false positive
Yeah following on this, when you look at places that actually are low-crime it's almost always cultural. But if all you have is a hammer everything looks like a nail I guess.
zug_zug··on 500k facial scans at UK stations yield no arrests, 1 false positive
Shouldn't the burden of proof be the other direction, that it's both cost-effective way to prevent crime? And that the cost should include not only pricing but all of the other negative externalities of removing privacy (such as deliberate abuse by bad actors inside or outside the government).
zug_zug··on A Privacy Analysis of Web and Mobile Conversational AI Agents [pdf]
time for somebody to make a quick script to poison your chat history by starting 1000 fake conversations with contradictory identifying details "I worry as a lesbian woman, my tween daughter doesn't blah blah Shabbat blah blah move home to Australia"
zug_zug··on Tank Body Problem
The shot timeout is the biggest issue for me. There's nothing worse than lining up the most crazy indirect shot and have it just disappear as it comes in.

The math on whether a shot is in escape velocity should be trivial for an AI to add. The only other degenerate cases would be some sort of orbit. My recommendation would be if the shot hasn't landed in 5 seconds, see if it's making progress, and if unclear, accelerate time until it is clearly making porgress (by 10x) and timeout at 60s world time.

zug_zug··on California farmers are struggling to sell grapes as demand for wine drops
I think gummies are a superior (more pleasant, healthier, safer) social lubricant than alcohol and I’m sure I’m not alone
zug_zug··on What reversing, modernising old games tells us about the economic impact of AI
Maybe I missed this but to me the economic implications are obvious: net loss for game companies, neutral for ai companies, win for gamers probably
zug_zug··on Has Violence Against Teachers Become Accepted by Society?
Yeah given that I don't see any statistics in this article, I'm not convinced of a systemic problem.
zug_zug··on Has Violence Against Teachers Become Accepted by Society?
So what?

Let's take aside the charged component of this and just suppose hypothetically that 100% of the assaulting students belonged to some subgroup. So what?

They may be 100% black, or 100% male, or something, but it's not like you can reasonably just say "So no males at our school." Regardless of whether you can find a subgroup who this belongs to with a very low specificity, you still need policies that tackle the behavior itself rather than trying to find some really weak predictor.

zug_zug··on Japan moves to tighten rules for foreigners
"Labour shortage" is just the business's perspective on "plenty of jobs!"

If there truly is a shortage of outstanding jobs, then they can compete and raise salaries and the least significant roles ultimately won't get filled, which is optimal.

zug_zug··on Japan moves to tighten rules for foreigners
That's their problem to solve however they want, if they want. The population shrinking by some large percentage doesn't seem to be inherently bad to me, and probably is good.

It's so laughable to me when people say "BUT THE SHAREHOLDER VALUE!" when we talk about things like the important life trends of millions of people.

zug_zug··on Plunging test scores are a slow-moving catastrophe
I agree it's worth looking into, potentially very emphatically. But that means doing some hard science.

That means don't just look at test scores by county, it means looking at DELTAs in test scores across time by numerous dimensions (income, poverty, did the kids get breakfast, school, etc) and an open mind to every possibility. Perhaps comparing against the parents' test scores might help elucidate.

Given the rise of so many unexplained mental health phenomena, I personally suspect there are environmental factors, but again, we need hard science and a lot of it.

zug_zug··on Plunging test scores are a slow-moving catastrophe
The challenge here is that you're assuming performance by race should be constant over time. Maybe that's true, maybe it's not, I think a richer analysis with wealth, parental education, english as a first language cofounders might be helpful.

Also if you want to entertain the theory that it is racial/genetic, it'd be important to do that analysis on a continuum since a lot of people who are "minority X" may be more than 50% white or there may be trends in that over time.

zug_zug··on Grok 4.7
> If you haven't used it, how do you know if it's winning?

I'm judging on benchmarks, and whether anybody or any company I know has ever suggested using it (not yet).

zug_zug··on Grok 4.7
Well I "tried it out" I asked it one question, and it gave no answer and said "Sign up to use more!" I don't think I'll be doing that, no.

I can't think of a single dimension grok is winning on (capability, cost, voice), but want to stay open-minded -- anybody want to vouch for its capabilities in any domain?

zug_zug··on If AI coding is lowering your code quality, you're not managing quality right
I think this is a bit of a simplistic mental approach. I've certainly seen a lot of "The engineer owns the outcome, AI is just a tool, don't release anything you don't vouch for."

However, I just don't think that's realistic. It's asking an author to suddenly become an editor. It's asking somebody who writes code to now read and debug others code.

It can actually be harder to find the the bug in a tricky piece of code than it can be to write your own correct code from scratch. I see AI introduce all sorts of bugs all the time in my personal projects that I would never introduce, and would never think to test for, especially around anything graphical.

zug_zug··on Autism is genetic – and why this information matters now
I feel like this is a willfully confusing article. So autism may involve disrupted genetics, but you may not have inherited those genes from your parents, they may be what are called "de novo mutations" which are mutations to the sperm or egg cells in the parent. This is evidenced by autism being more prevalent when the parents are older and those mutations are more common.

Also it clearly must be to some degree mutations if you believe the rates are going up, which even the government is no longer disputing (though that may not be conclusive proof, to me it seems evidence leans to more likely than not currently).

De novo mutations can also be caused by environmental factors, this is very well established and called "genotoxicity"[1] and certainly some people have been exposed to known genotoxic chemicals to varying degrees over time (formaldehyde) and who knows what undiscovered ones there are, newer standards of pesticide testing are starting to look for reproductive health effects but many chemicals that have been in use for a long time haven't been held to the highest standard.

Another reason you might think it would be "de novo" mutations is that this could be any sorts of random errors in the genome. If autism is an umbrella label for various genome errors (which it very well may be, since it correlates with other conditions very often), that may explain why it's so hard to pin down a few genes and why symptom expression varies so drastically.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genotoxicity

zug_zug··on Why I'm still bearish on LLMs after Navier-Stokes
Did you read your link? It says that 33% of people adopt AI, not that AI makes all workers 33% more effective, that would be absolutely insane. For that to be true we'd expect to see either companies who use it have revenues all suddenly jumping 33% (which we have not seen) or laying off 33% of their staff (which we have not seen and would also be catastrophic in the short term at least).

I'm not really going to belabor this point more, because it really sounds to me like you haven't even done the most cursory exploration into this and the people who have give an estimate of 7-10%[1] (and only a small fraction of that value would be captured by the AI provider). All the best.

[1] https://www.goldmansachs.com/insights/articles/generative-ai...

zug_zug··on Devastated father says his 9-year-old son spent $118,000 on YouTube ads
Okay but like... so what? Like does that even really pass the common-sense test that that is enough?

Like my bank would give me a phone call before I wired $20k oversees. Google should by default send you a sms confirmation on your first $10k+ purchase. This is the type of common-sense stuff that isn't an issue in-person, but somehow online we get the most barebones protections for consumers because "technically the EULA said so and so."

Basically if we make the corporations liable for it, we give them an incentive to prevent fraud, identity mistakes, etc. Whereas if they are not, we give them every incentive to avoid unintended purchases.

zug_zug··on Why I'm still bearish on LLMs after Navier-Stokes
You said 10s of trillions of dollars of revenue, which when the sum of all salaries is 65T, is minimum 15.3% of all salaries best case. It really feels like you're just pulling numbers out of nowhere here.
zug_zug··on Why I'm still bearish on LLMs after Navier-Stokes
That's what the 30x instead of 20x multiple is, for a "growth" tech company.

There's no strong evidence that openAI or anthropic will have non-linear revenue growth, so I'm not sure what point you're trying to make. Unless you think they'll fire all their engineers and replace them with agents or something crazy?

zug_zug··on Why I'm still bearish on LLMs after Navier-Stokes
Well if we make AI that learns at the rates humans do, it'll fundamentally undermine and destroy the relevance of all existing AI. It sounds to me like you're saying "we basically are there it's just a matter of degree" and I'm saying "No it's orders of magnitude off and probably won't be using LLMs at all and maybe a very fundamentally different type of neural net technology that hasn't been invented yet."
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →