HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zwieback

9,242 karma · joined May 8, 2009

Engineer at HP
submissionscomments
zwieback··on Servo vs. steppers: Speed, Torque and Accuracy [video]
Yeah, we have one application like that, a big gantry that would be a pain to home. Interestingly, the high res absolute encoder is also used to commutate the servo (it's sine) but the teaching of the commutation is a little nerve wracking. Maybe I'm getting old but the whole setup stresses me out
zwieback··on Servo vs. steppers: Speed, Torque and Accuracy [video]
Our nomenclature for servos in machine controls is a little different, for example a traditional 3phase servo with a 3phase hall sensor is still called "servo" even if it doesn't have an optical encoder. With this setup you can commutate the motor and get smooth motion and variable speed control but not precise position control. We then add on a optical shaft encoder or a optical linear encoder for position control.

In the video he has what looks like a magnetic absolute encoder, I have honestly never seen that in industrial applications although I have seen "absolute" optical encoders that have a backup battery to store the home point, kind of weird imo.

I was surprised when I first encountered servos with just magnetic hall effect sensors but there are actually lots of applications where you want speed control but not accurate position control.

zwieback··on Servo vs. steppers: Speed, Torque and Accuracy [video]
In my mind the main difference is steppers always taking full current, that's why we tend to switch to traditional servos past a certain size or use hybrid steppers like the MDrive
zwieback··on C: Simple Defer, Ready to Use
I agree about missing RAII when switching away from C++ but it seems like defer cleans up after enclosing function exits while RAII cleans up when object goes out of scope, which is more fine-grained. Maybe I'm misunderstanding exactly when defer would clean up but it seems more like a safety feature. As people pile more stuff into the function the cleanup would be deferred more and more while RAII encapsulates the management right where you need it, e.g. exiting a loop or something.
zwieback··on Routine dental X-rays are not backed by evidence
I had the same thing with my dentist about one of my remaining wisdom teeth, we went back and forth for five years but it finally got bad enough to do something. I opted for a crown though and it's been good and not too bad out of pocket.
zwieback··on Ask HN: What's the "best" book you've ever read?
Middlemarch by George Eliot
zwieback··on Map with public fruit trees
which mapping style do they use? Reminds me of the German maps of my childhood. We have nice forest service maps but the styling isn't as pretty
zwieback··on Map with public fruit trees
Oregon is plastered with fruit trees just growing anywhere in public spaces. Most of the time wild trees aren't cared for enough to be useful but there are some exceptions, especially plums.
zwieback··on Map of how hard each state works
My state of Oregon is apparently lazy and, I saw on another map this morning, also one of the loneliest.
zwieback··on Can't believe there's a market for this
Endless styling options!
zwieback··on Endurance exercise without weight loss may reduce body fat
I took a 100mi ride last week and even for that one event my body fat percentage seems to have shifted. I actually gained a little weight at the same fat percentage. Some of it is retained water but it's been a week so I think some of it is actual muscle mass.
zwieback··on What, Me Worry? The Art and Humor of Mad Magazine
I grew up in Germany but my parents wanted us to learn English so we had subscriptions to many US magazines like Time, National Geographic, New Yorker and, most beloved of all, Mad Magazine. Us kids would fight over the issue when it showed up, good memories!
zwieback··on A photographer captures life in America's last remaining old-growth forests
This time of the year I'm inclined to agree but come February I'm ready to head south...
zwieback··on Remembering the LAN (2020)
I must be the same age, remember Netware and also LANtastic and others. I worked on a product that let Macs running AppleTalk connect to PC LANs.
zwieback··on Medieval game pieces emerge from the ruins of a German castle
Cities were bombed to smithereens but a lot of smaller towns in the countryside were spared. My Dad grew up in Berlin during WWII but my mom just a bit north in Mecklenburg, big difference between their wartime experience.
zwieback··on Medieval game pieces emerge from the ruins of a German castle
I grew up not far from this site but have been living in Oregon for 30 years. One of the things that still strikes me when I go back to visit is just how much old stuff was around me in my childhood. Over there it's like "oh, let's put a nail salon in this 400 year old building". Here it's like: "oh, there's a 100 year old barn, we must turn it into a heritage site."
zwieback··on Show HN: The Global Literary Canon
Good list, would have preferred to see Charlotte instead of Emily though.
zwieback··on [dead]
Ahh, sneaky! I read the article and couldn't figure out what the point was.
zwieback··on The USDA's gardening zones shifted, this map shows you what's changed
No change in my hometown of Corvallis OR but plenty of change in the areas surrounding the Willamette Valley.
zwieback··on [dead]
I don't agree what what he's writing but I think his style is great, academic writing style but still very readable.

I've been asking my kids (students) and my wife (employee) and they don't see this climate at our state university. I think it's worse in non-technical fields and at private universities.

zwieback··on [dead]
Very very well written but seems like mostly author has an axe to grind with spoiled elites, not that that isn't an axe worth grinding.
zwieback··on Manta Ray UUV prototype completes in-water testing
Same, and now I'm fantasizing about the Netflix movie about manta rays unscrewing submarines
zwieback··on Fifty years of the personal computer operating system
Yes, stuff was ridiculously expensive back then. I was lucky that my dad bought an Apple ][ for home use but none of my friends could afford anything like that. All our software was pirated or we wrote it ourselves. I have fond memories of my youth in the 8 bit era but this is the golden age of home computing, right now, and it keeps getting better.
zwieback··on The Wi-Fi only works when it's raining
Thanks, was wondering about the mechanics. Boughs with leaves would droop but needle trees not so much and would be more transmissive in the first place.
zwieback··on The Wi-Fi only works when it's raining
What kind of a tree is it?
zwieback··on Garbage collection for systems programmers (2023)
So true, moving from C++ to mostly C# I'm liking memory management by GC but hating tracking file handles, sockets, etc. RAII is something I really appreciated
zwieback··on Nobody Wants to Buy the Future: Why Science Fiction Literature Is Vanishing
Not sure, maybe I didn't distill out the author's position correctly but it seems intuitive to me.

Are books about war popular in war times or do they become popular afterwards? I think there may be something unique about speculative fiction vs. depressing stuff about the present time, which I find myself drawn to.

zwieback··on Nobody Wants to Buy the Future: Why Science Fiction Literature Is Vanishing
Tech is unbelievably fantastic: GPS, wireless, lithium batteries, high end displays, etc. have given us extremely useful tools for everyday life. Tech itself is not depressing at all.

What is depressing is the current effect it has on society and a large percentage of sci-fi describes new ways humans make each other miserable. I can believe (but have no numbers) that that kind of sci-fi has become less popular.

zwieback··on Nobody Wants to Buy the Future: Why Science Fiction Literature Is Vanishing
I was wondering about that too. To answer that question we'd need normalized numbers, e.g. sci-fi as a percentage of total sales. It does seem likely that people who read sci-fi 20 or 50 years ago are now gaming, tinkering or cosplaying.
zwieback··on Nobody Wants to Buy the Future: Why Science Fiction Literature Is Vanishing
Author says that sci-fi readers are voracious readers and have moved to fantasy, romantasy and non-fiction.
← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →