> _One final warning about hardware RAID controllers: It's difficult to predict whether a hardware RAID array created under one controller will import successfully to a different model of controller later._
> _We find that with hardware RAID, it's frequently difficult to tell whether you're nuking your array or importing it safely. So in the event of a controller failure and replacement, you may end up sweating bullets, YOLOing, and hoping._
This was the main reason I decided to switch to Linux software RAID from a 3ware card years ago.
A thunderstorm caused a power trip and after powering the system back on, the 3ware controller lost its EEPROM contents that held the PCI vid/pid. Fortunately, it was just a RAID 1 mirror. We used dd to cut past the metadata header and managed to mount the ext2 filesystem.
Using software RAID, I’m confident that we can take the drives to another machine in a pinch and still be able to mount it without much hassle.