HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

zzzcpan

4,245 karma · joined December 27, 2011

submissionscomments
zzzcpan··on Multilingual People Have Healthier, More Engaged Brains? (2016)
No consensus on "existence of bilingual advantage", which is inherently subjective and unscientific claim. There doesn't need to be any consensus on it whatsoever, it's not science.
zzzcpan··on Multilingual People Have Healthier, More Engaged Brains? (2016)
> "bilinguals have been argued to develop superior executive functioning compared with monolinguals"

This is the one I find very problematic. They made up an entire unscientific claim to disprove.

zzzcpan··on Multilingual People Have Healthier, More Engaged Brains? (2016)
That point is actually about emotions. I think what it means is that children are only developing brain circuity related to emotions and so develop emotional associations with the words in a second language, while adults already did and can understand, control and ignore emotions better and do not develop emotional associations with the words in a second language, or at least not as much.
zzzcpan··on NextDNS Joins Firefox’s Trusted Recursive Resolver
> Obviously, you're better off not giving that information to your ISP if you don't have to, and with DOH, you don't have to:

This is incorrect. DoH doesn't take away that information, DoH only takes away one source of that information, other sources are still available to your ISP. So adding DoH to the mix simply forces you trust more parties with the same amount of information. There is just no way around it. DoH is simply not for privacy.

zzzcpan··on NextDNS Joins Firefox’s Trusted Recursive Resolver
Whether netflow is heavily sampled or not depends on where and how it is generated and for what purposes. It's just a format.

> You started out saying that running your own local recurser is privacy-enhancing (it's the opposite) and that ISPs can see your DNS queries when you run DoH (they can't) and retreated to a position of "other things leak".

Never said any of that, but your remarks are still wrong. What I said is basically that at ISP level there is much more information about what you are doing than DNS queries, including information that allows to identify the websites you are visited. Again, just IP addresses alone identify more than 90% of websites (can't remember the exact number from the research, it's like 95% from alexa top 1 million).

Now with regards to privacy. First it's important to understand what privacy is actually about. Within your traffic there is a lot of meta and side channel-like information, some of the sources of that information overlap a lot or are even identical, a lot of redundant information. Like we can look at a packet with a DNS query and see domain name identifying a website. Or we can look at IP address of a packet initiating new connection, it won't identify every website uniquely, but it will most of them, to get to 95% we would need to also look at IP addresses of new connections following that connection, i.e. sub resources, making sort of an IP set fingerprint, either way single IP addresses or a fingerprint can be mapped to unique domains or a set of potential domains. To complete this example there is also SNI in plain text in packets and domain names in Host: headers, which also uniquely identify websites. So there is at least 3 sources of the same or almost the same information. What kind of privacy level is that? Well, we have a single party with access to the same relatively easily extractable information from multiple redundant sources, it's a lot to trust with. Would it change anything if remove any of the sources? Not really, it would have very insignificant effect on privacy since other sources are still available. And if we have to send that information to another party, now that would make things much worse, because now we would have to trust two parties with the same information, rather than one. Ok, so, how can we actually improve it? We can try to remove all three sources of information and send all of them through another party. This changes the party we have to trust, but we still have to trust it with just as much. What if we can't trust any party that much? Then the next choice is to shard (partition) that information to as many parties as we can. Trusting even just with half of that information to one party and half to another is already much better and is where we finally start scratching the surface of privacy. I hope it's clear that DoH is not helping with privacy, it just steals one of the sources of this information.

As for running local recursive DNS server instead of the one provided by an ISP, it isn't leaking significantly more information to anyone. Packets likely go through the same route and there is a bit more of them for queries that didn't hit the cache for few popular domains. IP address is also exposed in such DNS packets, but ISP's DNS server would be coming from an IP address that belongs to the same AS and this leaks almost the same amount of identifying information.

zzzcpan··on NextDNS Joins Firefox’s Trusted Recursive Resolver
Luckily, I do believe that DNS query data has value, that's the reason I'm arguing against anti-privacy crap like DoH and have been since the beginning. If my arguments don't make sense to you, it's either because you lack understanding or have an agenda to push DoH.

> I'm not sure what you think NetFlow records contain.

I don't need to think what they contain, I implemented a netflow collector or two in the past.

zzzcpan··on NextDNS Joins Firefox’s Trusted Recursive Resolver
> The threat model of DoH is your local ISP.

There is no threat model for DoH, only ad hoc attempts to justify it. Here's the thing, your ISP sees all of your packets with all the IP addresses and ports and payload size and the exact time they were sent and received. This identifies every website you visited with very high accuracy, I mean just IP addresses alone identify more than 90% of the websites you visited.

> DoH is essentially a DNS-only VPN. It has exactly the security model of a VPN with respect to the DNS protocol.

That "security model" is just integrity in communications with resolver, but it actually sacrifices privacy for that.

> The attack DoH breaks immediately is your US mainstream ISP recording all your DNS queries

This is absolutely useless "attack" to break. Most ISPs in the world record netflow-like data and store it for a long time, which provides more detailed profile on you, than DNS queries. If they store DNS queries, those are just for commercialization, not for snooping.

zzzcpan··on NextDNS Joins Firefox’s Trusted Recursive Resolver
> The whole point of DoH is that you don't run the DoH recursive cache on the network you don't trust.

Nope. There is no point to DoH and you can't actually run "DoH recursive cache" within trusted network, because it communicates with authoritative servers over public internet.

zzzcpan··on Runtime Support for Multicore Haskell: A Retrospective
It's only one part of the story (scheduler) and not even good enough idea considering non-locality overhead.
zzzcpan··on Runtime Support for Multicore Haskell: A Retrospective
No, work stealing is pretty high overhead.
zzzcpan··on Still Why No HTTPS?
Dealing with certificates is more critical than "general server maintenance", things people often neglect doing suddenly become required. It might take from a few months to even a couple of years to get from neglected infrastructure to infrastructure ready for reliable automated issuance of certificates.

I actually evaluated a bunch of acme clients, wasn't satisfied with the code of any of them and wrote my own. But even from those I looked at certbot was always the worst choice, it's ridiculous letsencrypt is promoting it, better choices were POSIX shell clients or statically linked clients, like those written in Go and other compiled languages.

zzzcpan··on Runtime Support for Multicore Haskell: A Retrospective
> so relatively fine granularity of your algo stepping is the key here

Fine granularity requires pretty much zero overhead synchronization, which green threads or any shared memory multithreading implementations can't do, they need to spend like a few thousands of nanoseconds of useful work before synchronization costs become even just bearable.

zzzcpan··on Still Why No HTTPS?
And he's not even right. There is no hassle only if you take plenty of risk and rely on a random crappy acme client to do it well, its dependencies to always work, disks, OSes, servers not failing, acme protocol not changing and not deprecating anything.

Otherwise you need some infrastructure: logging, monitoring, some way to manage upgrades, backups, testing recovery, oh and those private keys are better not be leaked anywhere, so you need encryption for backups, which brings key management and so on.

zzzcpan··on WebAssembly becomes a W3C Recommendation
I have read the article, when it came out actually, it's merely about type mapping rules to an intermediate common representation. And it absolutely doesn't imply that interface types give you everything for high level interfaces in any language. Not that it's even possible, as high level <-> wasm <-> another high level transformation cannot realistically be automated for an arbitrary high level language, what can be is just high level <-> wasm <-> wasm level looking code in another high level language. It's like decompiling, you can't produce high level code automatically, only low level looking code in high level languages.
zzzcpan··on WebAssembly becomes a W3C Recommendation
What you are describing is more like __asm__("") in C, not an interface for application developers. Those are still required for every single target language because of the mismatch between the levels of abstractions between those languages, webassembly and actual logic exported.
zzzcpan··on WebAssembly becomes a W3C Recommendation
> embedding a WebAssembly runtime gives you all of that plus the ability for people to easily write plugins in any language

No, you would still have to provide an application programming interface for every target language you want to support.

zzzcpan··on Ask HN: What programming language is business folks friendly?
Not really programming languages, but Turing complete: HTML and CSS. Useful for business students and allow to ease in into more traditional programming eventually, even if it's Javascript.
zzzcpan··on So Where’s My Low Voltage DC Wall Socket?
Well, there is less drop with more copper, so it's more about costs. Cost of cables, DC-DC converters, power supplies and their efficiency determine optimal configuration. Probably going as high as cheap mass market DC-DC converters and PSUs allow is good rule of thumb for low voltage, so like 20-24 V. Beyond that better to go with high voltage.
zzzcpan··on WASM as a Platform for Abstraction
I'm not talking about potential applications of things that may or may not embed wasm and provide high level interfaces, libraries, compilers, tools. It's irrelevant whether high level stuff uses wasm underneath, application developers won't be touching it directly. I'm talking about actually doing all that work to enable application development. These are the people wasm targets and there are very few of such people on earth. It's very niche tech.

I was considering wasm for myself too, read the spec, articles, played with their ocaml implementation, parsed a bit of bytecode, but concluded that it's not a good tech, too browser specific to use elsewhere and waste time on it.

zzzcpan··on WASM as a Platform for Abstraction
There are maybe a few hundred people on earth who are in a position to embed wasm into something, how is that not niche?
zzzcpan··on WASM as a Platform for Abstraction
WASM is not a startup, it's a very niche tech and pushing it to other niches as a "platform" needs a lot of investment and buy in from professionals and management working in those niches. Not that the idea itself of an intermediate representation is bad, it's just WASM is not necessarily good and the odds are definitely against it.

HN top comment on dropbox wasn't really wrong either. Triviality proved to be a valid point. Plenty of companies made similar software once they saw there was a need for it. I mean who still uses dropbox today?

zzzcpan··on Russia blocks Premier League broadcasts by Amazon's Twitch over lawsuit
Russian government more than once voiced concerns over gamers doing things online without government involvement and control. Sberbank is not just greedy business, it's greedy only when it serves Kremlin.
zzzcpan··on Distributed Algorithm for Constructing Minimal Spanning Trees in Networks (1976) [pdf]
What exactly did you find interesting in the paper? It's a pretty bad paper. The kind of paper you would expect from pre Lamport "distributed algorithms".
zzzcpan··on Russia blocks Premier League broadcasts by Amazon's Twitch over lawsuit
> This is not about 'authoritarian control' whatever that might mean, it's "just" about copyright enforcement

It is in Russia, it's more like an excuse to block Twitch. Sberbank, the parent company of Rambler, is also a Kremlin's right hand and has been doing this kind of stuff since forever. For example, this was the company to which Yandex was forced to sell the controlling "golden share".

zzzcpan··on Unbearable news
> The problem is that revenue from paying subscribers is not enough.

Nope, it's enough. News is just not what you think, it's far from simple business. The biggest value news outlets provide to people who own them is the value of influence and controlling the narrative. So they are deliberately chasing after the eyeballs to spread their influence and no business model that narrows the audience much is even considered.

zzzcpan··on Database Internals
It depends on your goal.

Database internals books are not worth reading if you want to work on implementing real world database engines. You are better off checking out internals and documentation of various implementations and also research papers in that field. And you would be doing your own research anyway.

But if you are just starting out in programming, it's probably as good book as any to learn something new and practical about algorithms and data structures.

zzzcpan··on Having Kids
> Testosterone levels drop in men who even cohabitate with young children.

I call bullshit. There is at best a correlation of cohabitating with young children and periods of sexual inactivity, but probably correlation of periods of sexual inactivity and participating in the study you pulled that data from, i.e. it's a bullshit study.

Wikipedia has good enough explanation about when testosterone levels change in men: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Testosterone#Males

zzzcpan··on Having Kids
Oh god, let's get at least a little bit sciency about having kids. There are no serious chemical changes in men, only in women to a) deal with and forget the pain of child birth and b) form a bond with the child. Men are dreadful of having kids because they fear of having to support them, they are sort of tricked by women and pressured by peers, society, government to do it. Some men can find enjoyment and fulfillment in raising children of course, but it's much harder if they have to worry about providing for them.
zzzcpan··on Systemd Opened Security Hole in Linux, VPNs Could Be Compromised
It does deal with some untrusted input, often not directly in shell though, but through other tools.
zzzcpan··on Systemd Opened Security Hole in Linux, VPNs Could Be Compromised
> If you look at the old scripts-and-daemons hairball that systemd replaces, it has a lot of security warts too.

Not even close. Scripts were always memory safe and limitations of shell didn't allow to go crazy with things and introduce security issues left and right.

← PreviousPage 9 of 34Next →