The point was that trusting all your backups to a one-man operation is not particularly wise, though cperciva provided more information. HA and using multiple services was not part of the conversation.
If my offsite backups vanished (the building they're in burnt down, for example) I'd a) know about it promptly, and b) arrange additional copies and security for my current set of on-site backups. Just the same if as if Colin gets hit by that bus and his service goes down without anyone knowing how to, or caring about, bringing it back up.
If Tarsnap is a single point of failure for you, you're doing it wrong.
The end.