I'm not a vegetarian or an animal rights activist, but my urge to add this disclaimer might have something to do with why that's so.
I'm not a vegetarian or an animal rights activist, but my urge to add this disclaimer might have something to do with why that's so.
Trees are far more difficult to herd than either cattle or cats, and orchards have lifespans in the decades, with some historic California orange groves up to 300 years old. Most nut and stone-fruit trees have a 30-50 year ife. Moreover, there's a period of 4-7 years depending on tree crop during which an orchard is nonbearing, so if you remove an orchard, there's a significant hit.
https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/32b6yl/drought...
http://www.treasury.gov/resource-center/tax-policy/Documents...
The upshot is that it's much more difficult to rapidly adjust tree-crop water use than cattle, whether dairy or beef. Though on a gallons per unit protein basis, almonds do rate as more efficient as I understand.
On herds: not clear, though I believe they're somewhat reduced. Though alfalfa, not almonds, in support of cattle, are the largest single use (ag or otherwise) of water within California.
As with herds, alfalfa cultivation can be switched on or off rapidly.
My understanding is that the actual amount of supplemental water for cattle varies greatly throughout the state. For northern coastal California, irrigation (or "virtual water" in the form of supplied alfalfa) is less necessary.
UHT milk is transported all over the world, across great distances. I thought the difficulty of transporting milk was that it would rot.
1 gallon of milk weighs about 8.3 lb. For that you get 1632 calories, 38.4g fat, 195.2 g carbohydrate, and 131.2 g protein. It's about 16 standard servings, and half to 80% of a day's total calories. If not UHT-treated (not practiced much in America), it keeps for about a week. Cross-country truck transit would be 4-5 days. Rail about 2 weeks.
The same weight of beef is far more concentrated: it would deliver nearly 7,000 calories, 235g fat, a staggering 1142 g of protein, and is 40 servings of food.
The beef doesn't require pasteurisation (heating is expensive), can be frozen, doesn't slosh (though hanging sides can be hazardous truck cargo), and frozen it will keep for months.
Shipping routes into California generally require crossing high mountain ranges, which further increases shipping costs. It's something on the order of a 1 mile elevation gain being equivalent to 400 miles of level travel, if I'm recalling earlier research properly. Outside California, your available dairy land would be Oregon and Washington (both affected by drought), or points east of the Mississippi. That's a long way to haul a heavy, awkward, perishable, liquid cargo.
Wisconsin has few deepwater ports within 7 days shipping time to the West Coast.
Your alternatives:
● Powdered milk. Stores indefinitely, much more portable (no water weight), but taste and consistency issues. Much surplus milk has traditionally been powdered.
● Condensed milk. A compromise, but expensive as I recall.
● UHT. Though as noted, it's proven unpopular to date in the US. It's possible that might change, but it would be a significant change.
Making cheese requires lots of cow's milk, removes much of its moisture (hence its weight) and also has preservative effects.
I'd like to look at cheese cost per unit nutrition (calories, protein, fat). I think it tends to remove much of the carbohydrate content.
But yes, fermentation == early food preservation.
Because beef is a red herring. Beef uses next to no water.
Alfalfa used to feed that beef, on the other hand, is a huge water consumer and completely silly given that it could be grown elsewhere quite easily. California exports something like a billion dollars worth of alfalfa to China. It's nuts.