You do get idiots saloming around in somewhat heavy traffic, but that doesn't actually slow others down much while they're putting everyone at risk.
That's a common idea based on not-very-careful observation and just isn't factual. There's plenty of data showing that aggressive driving has minimal effect on travel times. In fact, you actually get a bigger speed-up by strategically avoiding left turns: companies with delivery fleets plan their routes with this in mind.
[1] Not-super-technical explanation: http://lifehacker.com/does-speeding-really-get-you-there-any...
I routinely drive at 90km/h on the main 100km/h stretch of my 28km commute. 23km at 90km/h, and I pull up next to or immediately behind the person that passed me a few minutes ago: the difference in arrival time between a car doing 120 and another doing 90 on that stretch is 4 minutes, assuming they hit 120km/h as soon as they leave the lights at one end of the road. If they have to overtake slower traffic like busses, cranes and me, they get less of a head start.
Eleven minutes versus fifteen on the only stretch where aggression makes a difference. There is no way in the world that this counts as "double" the time. The rest of the trip is the same average speed of about 25km/h, with the more aggressive driver getting to use their brakes more than me.
Red lights are the great equaliser.
Aggressive driving buys you one or two cycles of the traffic lights, along with a much higher fuel and maintenance bill.
Furthermore, the total time might be less on a good day, with aggressive driving, but the more aggressive drivers there are, the higher the likelihood of an accident, which takes substantially longer than slow drivers.
t1 = aggro drive time t2 = slow drive time t3 = accident drive time
small cities, say less that 500k, it's probably not worth it, because p(accident) is pretty low, freeway backups relatively rare, say in the neighborhood of .1
bigger cities though, traffic gets messed up all the time. t2 wins.
t2 < p(accident) * t3 + p(1-accident) * t1
http://www.npr.org/2013/11/29/247825768/phantom-traffic-jams...
[1] So there I was[2] driving through Iraq when an Iraqi army convoy approached rapidly from behind us. While swerving past my trucks, that had pulled over for them to pass, one of the vehicles left the road and rolled over multiple times. 2 people died in that accident, I applied tourniquets to 2 additional people who lost limbs, and no, they didn't get the gunshot victim to the hospital any quicker that way.
[2] Fun fact. Do you know the difference between a fairy-tale and a war story? War stories start with "So there I was".
Police often have additional driver's training. I happen to think that police often drive faster than they should, but this is less the case for emergency vehicles. I rarely see an ambulance or fire truck moving at high speed. They are pretty aware of their job to get somewhere safely, and I am typically only passed by an ambulance if I am stuck in traffic myself.
So read a book or work on something on your laptop or go on Amazon and buy a present for your partner with the health insurance money you'll eventually save by registering your commute as autonomous.
There are a large number of reasons you'd notice that won't work the very first time you take a car out for a drive (you give a great one: "it's going to take twice as long for it to make it through rush hour traffic"). With no eye contact or hand gestures available it's a harder problem, but aggression and counter-aggression is going to have to be a part of any self-driving model. Even if all cars were self driven you'd still have pedestrians willing to cross the street at any sign of hesitation.
But then I thought, that couldn't happen, because it's too clear that any such lobbying puts police unions squarely at odds with citizen safety. Now, shoot-first cops, civil forfeiture, and highly militarized police forces already point at this, but there's plausible deniability. Opposing self-driving cars could be too direct of a swipe at public safety from public safety officers.
I don't know...
Self-driving cars will completely remove this avenue of investigation because there will be much fewer infractions.
I think that this is a good thing and a bad thing. On the one hand, you won't get police harassing random innocent people on the off-chance that they're criminals. On the other hand, the police will start doing other things because they don't have to pull people over anymore, and those things might be much more invasive.