There's a comment from one of the paper's co-authors that will probably need repeating here (https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/3imphg/scientists_...): "To those wanting to dismiss psychological science as "cult science" based on these findings, note how ironic your response is. You're discrediting the very people whose data you are using to back up your claim. This massive, groundbreaking project was conducted on psychological science by psychological scientists. In my view, psychological scientists are among the most dedicated and rigorous scientists there are. No other field has had the courage to instantiate a project like this. And I am sure that many of you would be shocked to find out how low the reproducibility rates are in other fields. Problems of non-reproducibility, publication bias, data faking, lack of transparency, and the like plague every scientific field. The people you are labeling as "cult" scientists are leading the movement to improve science of all types in a much needed way."
Also, the current top comment quotes the following from the paper: "Any temptation to interpret these results as a defeat for psychology, or science more generally, must contend with the fact that this project demonstrates science behaving as it should. Hypotheses abound that the present culture in science may be negatively affecting the reproducibility of findings. An ideological response would discount the arguments, discredit the sources, and proceed merrily along. The scientific process is not ideological. Science does not always provide comfort for what we wish to be; it confronts us with what is"
And another co-author chimed in (https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/3imphg/scientists_...): "The real interesting part is seeing how other disciplines hold up in terms of reproducibility. A new project has been started: Reproducibility Project: Cancer Biology, they will try to replicate 50 studies. I am very curious how this will turn out, I highly encourage other disciplines to also start a reproducibility project to test how consistent their findings actually will be. I don't see these results as discouraging, instead, I see it as a big step in developing scientific methods. Now we know which methods and standards might be wrong, we can try to fix it (for example by developing guidlines)."