Considering the inmates in solitary are the ones suing because it is cruel I think that answer is quite apparent. Yes, people would rather be with people even if those people aren't perfect.
If I was in prison and could make a case for anything you can bet I'd be the biggest pain in the ass (wrt legal wrangling) I possibly could. I mean, my life is pretty much trashed already, right? No harm in seeing if you can get a reduced time or even a settlement out of it.
That said, I can only imagine that enforced solitude would be pretty awful in its own right.
I am talking about the well being of OTHER inmates.
>Yes, people would rather be with people even if those people aren't perfect.
So, yes or no, you would want to be in a cell with a "not perfect" person who has killed has last two cellmates?