> it's just a one-time cost to replace all the meters
Much easier said than done.
> At that point all you actually need is a standard IP-based protocol to announce real-time rates. The power company doesn't even need to communicate bidirectionally with individual devices whatsoever -- all they need to do is broadcast the current rate and let the devices make choices
Several problems there (before I get into 'kids these days' mode):
- Meter connected 24/7 just to get prices is not feasible (also remember you need per meter pricing for the issues
listed by the parent)
- For it to make decisions to "use less power" you need a controller for every device (heating/AC/etc) you want to be controllable - or something more complex if you want fine-grained control
Too complex for home usage, basically, where you want to turn your devices on and not worry about spot pricing