This reminds me of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Brain_Project as there is also lot of skepticism if it's doable. But maybe we just underestimate human ingenuity.
This reminds me of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Brain_Project as there is also lot of skepticism if it's doable. But maybe we just underestimate human ingenuity.
Fifth generation computing - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_generation_computer
Strategic Defense Initiative - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Defense_Initiative
Expeditionary Combat Support System - http://spectrum.ieee.org/riskfactor/aerospace/military/us-ai...
The Field Data Collection Automation for the US census - http://calleam.com/wp-content/uploads/US_Census_FDCA_Case_St... (the failure added $3 billion to the cost of the census).
How do you score the Space Shuttle? It didn't come close to meeting its design goals, but throw enough money at something (as we did with SDI) does result in something.
Anyway, my bet is that we don't actually need a very big supercomputer to emulate what brain does. We just don't yet know why it is so efficient, we don't know the trick(s). And I think, there is a possibility, as Human Brain Project will evolve, we will get better at figuring out what really needs to be simulated and what is just a fluff. And this will make possible to scale it up even on current hardware. Anyway, at least that's why I think it should be supported.
Again I ask, "Do you have a tally of the ones that failed?"
Would it include the Superconducting Super Collider? ($2 billion for a hole in the ground).
Actually, it's a trickier question than that. What does failure in an ambitious science project mean to you? Do you classify the two failed Orbiting Astronomical Observatory (of four) as an engineering failure, or a scientific one, or both?
For that matter, what is on your list of ambitious scientific projects, and how many of them have a success which is not primarily due to being a well-run engineering project? That is, the success of the Large Hadron Collider surely is due mostly to being a successful engineering project.
My experience is that the high-end science projects like what you are talking about (eg, the so-called 'Grand Challenge' projects), are constructed so they cannot fail. They lack a solid, measurable goal, and any advancement is counted as a success. This failsafe means they are more likely to get political backing.
So what I mean, I think, is not ambition in terms of resources, but rather ingenuity.