> All animal-produced carbon came from the air.
All carbon comes from star fusion, what relevance does that have?
> It's irrelevant in the long term view.
It's irrelevant over geological term view, over "human" long-term view it's very relevant.
All carbon comes from star fusion, what relevance does that have?
> It's irrelevant in the long term view.
It's irrelevant over geological term view, over "human" long-term view it's very relevant.
I don't have enough data to know if I agree with his point (especially since the GHG changes form), but his "long-term" refers to the life cycle of a single cow.
There's two issues with that:
1. cows really release the carbon stored in the food they eat, that carbon could otherwise stay locked (as it was before we cleared the field from which we grow feed).
2. cows also convert part of the carbon their release from their feed into comparatively worse greenhouse gases than just CO2