For free customers using our Universal SSL solution, only modern browsers are supported so it has only used SHA2 certificates since it launched over a year ago.
The danger is that after December 31, 2015 we may no longer be able to get SHA1 certificates for new customers because CAs have been told by browser vendors to no longer issue them. While that won't cause a problem for modern browsers, for legacy browsers that can't be upgraded it will mean they will not be able to access the encrypted web. Unfortunately, that disproportionately affects regions of the world where censorship risk is high. In Iran, China, and parts of Africa with more restrictive governments, legacy browser traffic is as high as 30%.
If providers like CloudFlare who can safely support SHA1 certificates only for legacy browsers, while supporting SHA2 for modern browsers, cannot continue to get SHA1 certificates then we risk cutting off a substantial portion of the most vulnerable Internet users from the encrypted web. That is a bad outcome.
We will be talking more about this on our blog in the coming weeks and plan to open source the TLS handshake fingerprinting logic we're using to identify what browsers only support SHA1. I'm hopeful that the browser vendors and CAs will do the appropriate thing by requiring modern browsers to only support modern hashing algorithms but allow providers like us to continue to support the best available cryptography for those users who cannot upgrade to the latest browser tech.