The last three months I've been living semi-rural in the midwest; all the households are on two acres (minimum, due to to well and septic density.) I've had more direct contact with my neighbors in these 12 weeks than the previous 21 years put together. Maintaining larger properties that are much more distant from the urban core invites collaboration. Household attendance at the HOA meeting last month was almost 50%; waaay more than I saw back in the Front Range burbs.
Your view of the world doesn't match my experience at all. Exactly the opposite.
In my experience, this translates as, "governments who think non-car transportation modes should be treated as seriously as cars."
> However, actual contact with neighbors was very sparse; a service for every need, everything on auto-pilot. The last three months I've been living semi-rural in the midwest; all the households are on two acres (minimum, due to to well and septic density.) I've had more direct contact with my neighbors in these 12 weeks than the previous 21 years put together. Maintaining larger properties that are much more distant from the urban core invites collaboration. Household attendance at the HOA meeting last month was almost 50%; waaay more than I saw back in the Front Range burbs.
Honestly, this just sounds like your personality is more attuned to a rural area; you're fitting in better, and therefore socializing more. There are certainly people like yourself for whom this is the case, and that's absolutely fine. The problem with the regulations I mentioned isn't that they allow for low-density development, it's that they enforce low-density development.
Also, what you're describing still matches the article more or less: you don't really have spontaneous interaction in the community, but you do have intentional/planned interaction.
I agree with you but in the sense that non-car transports should be treated much more seriously than cars, which I suspect is not what you meant to transmit.
People are more friendly in the midwest, and they are more open to talk about family matters. Family matters are in essence intimate, and the topics draw the people in the conversation together. In the big cities, these topics are regarded as "more" private (they are indeed private). It is a social norm to not share them unless to good friends. The less people share, the less opportunities to make friends.
I also find it is easier for adults, especially men, to make friends in Asia, like in China and Japan.
For example, we think of people in rural areas as being those who love the outdoors, they get out a lot into nature, exercise a lot, more than city slickers, right? Except no, they're actually less healthy than urban residents. Sure, there are some there who really are going out into nature constantly and are in fantastic shape, but what you don't see are the people who just sit at home all the time watching TV and smoking, because there just ain't that much to do - http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240527023047935045764344...
The 'urban planners' and their cheerleaders have it wrong. They've decided that downsizing everyone and making them live in each others laps will end with Kumbaya. In fact it ends with everyone on edge, peering at each other silently as they sweat the value of their tiny piece of it.
> Remove that and replace it with a degree of liberty
Do you know what liberty is? It's letting the market have a say in how dense developments can be, so that people's individual choices dictate what's available, rather than the law. It's supporting all modes of transportation so that people have an actual choice in how they get around, instead of being required to drive to do anything or go anywhere. Forcing everyone into what topspin thinks is best isn't liberty, it's coercion.
It's a lot easier to have "high social cohesion" when you have a uniform culture that's been around for centuries, and are not living in a nation of immigrants from all over. I have nothing against that, by the way, but I'm simply pointing out that many countries like Japan are fairly xenophobic at best, racist at worst. I believe there was an article on HN recently about how difficult it is to found a start up in Japan as a foreigner.
Plus, I'm not sure this kind of tight-knit culture is something I'd want to be a part of: http://www.kalzumeus.com/2014/11/07/doing-business-in-japan/
> The company is your public life. Have an issue with your landlord? The company will handle it, in those cases where the company is not your landlord.[...] Need to file paperwork with City Hall? Someone from HR can do it for you.
> The company is your private life. All friends you’ve made since your school days almost by definition work for your company, because you spend substantially every waking hour officially at work or at quote leisure unquote with people from work.
That sounds to me like modern-day feudalism.
----
> Do you know what liberty is? It's letting the market have a say in how dense developments can be
What's wrong with the people in each area voting for the laws that govern their area? If the people in an area don't want to vote for an increase in density, then so be it. Let them live their lives how they want to.
> What's wrong with the people in each area voting for the laws that govern their area?
There's nothing necessarily wrong with localities having their own laws, of course. I'm not advocating for overthrowing democracy, I'm just arguing that overly restrictive anti-density regulations have had a number of bad impacts:
- In desirable metros, skyrocketing property values caused by restrictions on new housing supply act as a large wealth transfer from the young to the old.
- Needing to use a car hurts the poor, hurts college students, hurts childrens' independence, and hurts residents' healthiness.
- Lower density developments are more energy- and thus carbon-intensive.
- Wasted time on long commutes because the only affordable housing is far away is a huge economic sink.
- The economy overall is weaker because many people avoid moving to high-productivity areas like Silicon Valley or NYC, and instead go to lower-productivity cities, because of high housing costs caused by a lack of supply: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonkblog/wp/2014/07/25/h...
Once a friend and I started counting languages as we walked around Times Square. In 20 mins, we counted a dozen then gave up (we couldn't identify the others we heard). With such diversity, it is not easy to agree on anything without lots of effort, discussions and compromises.
City living (this is all just my experience) is about chasing opportunity and throwing yourself intensely into the pursuit of success. Out in the country, I see people who have earned enough to buy a house with some land, and are ready to drop into a lower gear. They're willing to forego the opportunity and experience in order to achieve some stability and a slower pace of life.
So it's no wonder that, when you deliberately remove major sources of tension from people's lives, they are more easy going.
[citation needed]
On the flipside, if you have friends who aren't right next door (or perhaps who once were and you don't want to write them off because they moved), it helps to have the ability to drive to their place. I'm not arguing for "car first", but I don't think "pedestrian first" makes sense either. Most of my friends are scattered around a 20-minute radius.
(And quite frankly, you can choose your friends but you can't really choose your neighbors.)
> anti-density zoning laws
I'd have less problem with dense housing (especially since I don't actually care about the stereotypical "yard and a white picket fence") if said housing started including -90dB or better soundproofing.
A good transportation policy takes all major modes seriously. If you look at a biketopia like the Netherlands, they still drive as much as they bike. Nobody wants to completely get rid of cars, transportation nerds like myself just want the different modes to be on an even playing field, rather than cars being always hyper-dominant like they usually have been in the US. I expect to continue to own a car for a long time.
Also note that, assuming everything transformed overnight into an urbanist's paradise, that 20 minute radius would shrink considerably, and many of your friends would be reachable by bike. I'm paraphrasing a quote I heard before: "Car-first planning creates distance that only cars can solve."
> I'd have less problem with dense housing (especially since I don't actually care about the stereotypical "yard and a white picket fence") if said housing started including -90dB or better soundproofing.
Agreed. This is one regulation that I am all for.
I've seen far too many people argue viciously for exactly that.
> transportation nerds like myself just want the different modes to be on an even playing field, rather than cars being always hyper-dominant like they usually have been in the US.
Agreed.
Even on an aggressively pro-bike blog like BikePortland, this kind of opinion is an extreme minority. There are urbanists who really despise cars, or at least despise cars in urban areas, but they're just a vocal fringe. Most want more equalized resources and care for walking, biking, and transit, and they want each mode prioritized for an area in a way that makes sense based on each mode's attributes (e.g. cars should be prioritized for freeways between cities, denser modes prioritized in expensive urban cores).
Yep. Instead of having a thousand of single-family houses, I would rather have a beautiful 30+ stories castle surrounded by a park of ~1 km radius. Cars are expected to live underground and reach the surface outside of the park.
Saying that as I have lived a few years in a very similar setting, while being at a university: http://cdn.absolutevisit.com/blog/photo-of-the-day/100075/Mo...
The problem with this is that you're basically getting the worst of both worlds. You lose many of the real benefits of dense development because there's no space for jobs and shopping, and you lose the benefits of privately kept land like customized yards and broken-up sightlines and so on.
The "giant building separated from everything else by a giant moat of grass" style also has a long, ugly history in public housing developments, with it meant as idealistic but ultimately turning to crap.
As for being disconnected, it's usually quite opposite, if your friends live in the same building: you're 5-10 minutes away from them.
Again, speaking from the personal experience, not dreams. Map: https://goo.gl/maps/g7bEBsoqwkL2
Also, living in the same building actually helps to find new friends, especially if there's enough shared space indoors/outdoors, such as cafes, gyms, hacker spaces, etc.
For various reasons, including the fact that it's much easier to be on good terms with your neighbour when he lives way over the other side of the hill and nothing he does really affects you or vice versa.
Also because of necessity -- if there's only two people in a ten-mile radius who can help you if you have a problem, it's nice to be on good terms with them.
And finally just the fact that the fewer people you come into contact with, the easier it is to become friends with them. If you keep running into the same fifty people over and over again you'll get to know them, but most of the people I see in the city are people I'll never see again.
Ostensibly friendlier, but how often do they actually interact on a day-to-day basis? (I agree with the rest of your post)