If I'm understanding correctly, the new test is based on a single data point from each group, rather than an aggregate statistic (like mean). I'm no statistician, but it seems like this data would have far too much variance and noise for this to be a useful test.
The minimum performer could be someone who had a sudden personal crisis. Or who had 10 competitors suddenly pop up. Or any number of other circumstances outside their control. The minimum performer is, almost by definition, an outlier. It doesn't seem rational to suppose that an outlier is representative of the group.
I can understand that statistically this test may be more rigorous. In practice I would expect it to be less rigorous. Because the assumption it makes (that a single outlier is representative of the group) seems even more dubious than the assumptions required for Paul's original idea.