Let's be clear on the differencen between reproducible and replication. Reproducible is when an experiment's data and methods are published and other researchers can reproduce the same statistical results. An experiment that has been replicated is a new experiment that applies the same methods to a new set of subjects and arrives at statistically equivalent results.
The distinction is important. Reproducible research is a lot easier but there are still famous examples of attempts to reproduce published results that revealed serious flaws. Cases where the data are kept secret to thwart reproducibility are thoroughly suspect. Replication is a harder problem, both in being able to perform a potentially costly and difficult experiment, and in the statistical analysis to show equivalent results.