But what do you do about an inmate who terrorizes his cellmates, his peers on the yard, his peers in the cafeteria, etc. You've tried solitary for a day, for a week, etc.
If you leave this inmate in with general, he's taking away their rights to learn and rehabilitate. If you put him in with a bunkmate... well, that seems like punishment to the bunkmate. You end up creating a new ad-seg unit that looks just like the old one, but with a new name.
I'm not meaning to say that solitary is used correctly in the US right now. Not at all. But it may be an inevitable result for a very small group of prisoners who would otherwise take away the others' right to rehabilitate.
(Edit: replaced stray ? with .)