http://public.econ.duke.edu/~erw/197/forget-cea%20(2).pdf
We'd like to pretend everyone is a self-motivated software engineer who will create value for the world for personal fulfillment. The data shows this belief is false.
http://public.econ.duke.edu/~erw/197/forget-cea%20(2).pdf
We'd like to pretend everyone is a self-motivated software engineer who will create value for the world for personal fulfillment. The data shows this belief is false.
There is a growing fear amongst some that automation will finally overtake job creation, and that the resulting unemployment will be sufficient to throw masses of people back into poverty.
If that actually happens, then a 13% reduction in work effort might very well be less than desirable if one wishes to prevent social unrest.
There are two key benefits of basic income in that respect: Firstly, to ensure that if people are unable to find a job, they can still live a decent life. Secondly, to reduce the amount of people forced into unemployment by making more people choose to not work or work less, whether because they choose education or choose to stay home with their young children, or choose to retire earlier, or simply choose to make do with less.
Of course, the pre-requisite for that to be viable is that society can make do with 13% less work effort (or whatever it ends up being, whether more or less).
That's not a case against it, that's one of the benefits of it. The notion that everyone must work is antiquated in this continually automating world and will soon no longer be possible. The people who are losing jobs don't have the skills to be in demand and demand for human workers will only continually decrease as time passes. When you automate people, the rules change; it's not going to be like the past where people just did different jobs. There won't be enough jobs that require human skills enough to keep more than a small part of humanity working.
I think you need to look into the assumption that humans require so much work; it's not historically true, hunter gatherers spent much less time working and much more time in leisure, even tribes today.
> Everyone earning their keep is not an antiquated concept.
Earning your keep doesn't require 40 hours work a week in a world full of automation, what is antiquated is the notion that there's enough work to keep everyone working all time; look around, that's changing.
> It humbles people. Fills their time with purpose. Improves their intelligence and resiliency.
So do other things, like art and culture; there's more to life than work. Seems you've been brainwashed into thinking only work fulfills people.
> Supporting someone because they exists is a horrible idea!
No, it's called being human and it's what has to come whether you like it or not; there simply isn't going to be enough work to go around to rely on a labor based means of distribution anymore and automation is going to further distribute what's left into the hands of a very few. Those trends can't end well without a radical change in how society is organized.
So far in human history the only people that were able not to work, but instead have an effortless lives devoted to "art and culture" were members of aristocracy. This happened few times, since the ancient civilizations till 19th century and always resulted in that "noble" class degenerating into bunch of perverts. Basic income would result in pretty much the same, just on larger scale.
We are not yet in the era when humans are useless. We still need Uber drivers, house cleaners, and day care workers. Once we reach the era where robots have made everyone obsolete, BI will be so cheap to provide that no one will bother to oppose it.
As best I can tell reducing work effort is good, but neither the banking crises nor a BI hold much of ceteris anything like paribus. The banking crisis saw work effort fall, but also saw productivity fall and saw incomes fall for a great many individuals. It's not hard to imagine that that nets out negative.
I didn't say we were, I said it's coming, and we need to adapt before then or it'll be terribly hard on society.
Considered strictly (literally "everyone", specifically "software engineer"), it may actually be the case that literally no one believes that.
Let's consider a weaker interpretation, more precisely phrased "enough people are sufficiently self-motivated to create value for the world that the perceived decrease in productivity due to workers opting out of traditional employment will be substantially made up for by the other things these people choose to be productive at."
And contrary to your claims, the data you provided not only fails to show that this is false, but lends some support to the notion. From the same paragraph whence you draw the 13% figure:
"Because the primary earner typically worked many more hours than the secondary and tertiary earners, this implied a relatively small reduction in work effort by primary earners."*
"The general result that secondary earners tend to take some part of the increased family income in the form of more time for household production, particularly staying home with newborns, was found in all the experiments"
To a large extent, "Mincome reduced work effort" in the same sense that a man marrying his housekeeper reduces GDP. It does not mean people are being correspondingly less productive!
It is also not clear to me how volunteering would have been counted towards work effort, and non-commercial art almost certainly would not.
Regarding "software engineer" in particular, the study took place in the 1970s. For many well-paid jobs, the initial capital requirements look qualitatively different.