> I think many place too much faith that while someone isn't working, they will be doing good things with their time and not having negative effects on the society or economy or the human race
I think you need to look into the assumption that humans require so much work; it's not historically true, hunter gatherers spent much less time working and much more time in leisure, even tribes today.
> Everyone earning their keep is not an antiquated concept.
Earning your keep doesn't require 40 hours work a week in a world full of automation, what is antiquated is the notion that there's enough work to keep everyone working all time; look around, that's changing.
> It humbles people. Fills their time with purpose. Improves their intelligence and resiliency.
So do other things, like art and culture; there's more to life than work. Seems you've been brainwashed into thinking only work fulfills people.
> Supporting someone because they exists is a horrible idea!
No, it's called being human and it's what has to come whether you like it or not; there simply isn't going to be enough work to go around to rely on a labor based means of distribution anymore and automation is going to further distribute what's left into the hands of a very few. Those trends can't end well without a radical change in how society is organized.