The main problem with starting an app like this is that it basically doesn't work without having a substantial number of users. Even with a dozen people onboard, it will still feel very empty. We need a way to gain a larger following quickly to get the ball rolling, and for the user interaction with it to even make sense.
As for the selfies on the website, we had the idea of using real photos that you might find on the app, instead of some obviously professionally made photos, but, yes, that might be the wrong approach.
And yes, I really feel that the "No ads" is the way to gain a real following, and if the app is good, it will spread organically.