Not a logical error at all, much less a major one. The obfuscated "taxation" of American households led to higher bids for airing games which led to salaries for players and higher valuations for teams. The cost to ESPN of the entertainment (Mike & Mike, Bill Simmons, etc) is a laughable fraction of the cost of broadcast rights.
So I believe the author is possibly correct in his assertion that cutting off the money from non-fans (since fans will presumably pay in some way) will materially affect the valuation of these leagues.