Of course, but this is people's lives and careers. If you've spent 60 hours a week for the last 40 years on something you aren't about to hand it over to some randomer on a wiki.
What you're talking about are things like pride and profit, stubbornness and renown. My point was that the current science culture is currently as much about fame and pride as it is about understanding. In order to have any sort of anonymized, wiki-based science, we would need to ask people who have become famous and respected by doing things one way to start over in a new way.