This is not a duplicate. The post is about a new lawsuit filed due to the change in rules, the suit has not been previously on the front page.
We started moderating HN this way after the Snowden deluge of 2013 in which the front page was dominated by follow-up posts for a long time. Many users complained about this, and they were right, yet the underlying stories were obviously on-topic. We came up with the current policy as a way to balance the concerns.