Checking some of my own pages:

http://www.aetherltd.com 5726 bytes.

But if try the tool at "http://analyze.websiteoptimization.com/wso", I get 1276134 bytes, including all referenced files. The big items are fonts. The fonts are offered in three formats (.ttf, .woff, and .eot.), and the tool counts all of them, even though most browsers will only load one format.

That's what firebug told me. Using the built in inspector I get 1,356K.

Your tools are probably not loading images if they show such a small number.

Including images. Chrome reports loading 1017 kB for me.

HTML is 23KB gzipped (served that way).

Uncompressed, it's 67KB. This does not account for the remainder of the resources.