And yet the most desirable neighborhoods in the country are planned in just that fashion.
The iPhone and the iPad are gated communities with a HOA. Your neighbor can't park a clunker across the street from your house for six months... but neither can a friend of yours stay in an RV in your driveway for a week.
"Most desirable" is a relative term.
I want to have freedom, even at the cost of a more difficult life. I'm house hunting right now, and I'm actively avoiding the kinds of places you describe.