Agreed with everything you wrote here, I should have been more precise.
That said your advice on using Symfony2 or something else over Drupal is extremely valid and I can say that as I used Drupal for a couple of years and ran into all the usual issues (worked fine for non-logged in, fell over with a few hundred logged in users), as a nice way to generate largely static content for end users it's just about acceptable but people seem determined to not use it for that, whether you can blame Drupal for that or the end users is an interesting question I guess.
I now don't use Drupal anymore, although I might occasionally whip it out for a site that only requires a few admins to log in...