We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10929274 and marked it off-topic.
Meanwhile, the author can't even afford a house where s/he lives which calls into my question my characterization of that salary as even qualifying as a middle class salary.
We are being increasingly divided into the poor and the rich so much so that those lucky few that are barely hanging on to middle class earnings are now also being characterized as rich, despite some signs pointing to those earnings not even really qualifying as middle class.
I suspect a single mother making minimum wage would most definitely recognize that she's poor.
> and would balk at characterizing the author as only middle class.
This is probably true. Middle class is so inconsistently defined, though, that it's hard to have a meaningful conversation about what constitutes middle class.
> Meanwhile, the author can't even afford a house where s/he lives which calls into my question my characterization of that salary as even qualifying as a middle class salary.
Home ownership is a terrible way to categorize middle class, mostly because as salaries rise, so do expectations of what constitutes an acceptable home. Someone making six figures in the bay area absolutely can own a home. They just can't buy the one they "feel" they should be able to afford. I see a number of homes and condos on sale in Mountain View for <500K, and a whole bunch in Sunnyvale and San Jose in that range. I'm sure if I looked across the bay I'd find a ton.
When your salary is double the median household income, you're at least middle class and realistically probably upper middle class. The fact that your salary won't buy you a 1.5 million dollar home in the heart of Palo Alto is kind of irrelevant. Moving from Palo Alto to Fremont does not change your social class, even if it does make you hate the commute.
edit: Median family income in San Francisco in 2010 was $71,745. Six figure individual salary is most definitely middle or upper middle class, even in the bay.
http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Bay-Area-income-beats-...
From what I've observed, it seems to be based on what feels normative to their social groups. If most of the people you know make minimum wage or close to it, it feels normal, and therefore you're strongly motivated to believe that's what middle class is.
As for $71k median income in SF, I would not personally define that as middle class. To me, middle class is the capability to own at least a modest home and have significant ability to save for retirement. You can't do that on $71k in SF. As such, I would characterize the majority of SF residents as being less than middle class.
And ability to save for retirement is merely a signal too - it has never been used as any kind of barometer for what is middle class.
If we're talking about middle class as it relates to income - which is what people mean the vast majority of the time they use the phrase - then $71k is middle class, full stop. If you exclude the bottom 20% and the top 20% of incomes (the widest generally accepted income range for middle class) you get $47-140k. And this is household income, not personal income.
San Francisco is the outlier in terms of salary, and if you try to project that onto the US as a whole, you end up with statements like "As for $71k I would not personally define that as middle class."
1. The actual statistical average or median whatever that number happens to be is the middle class, full stop.
2. The middle class is the ideal standard of living one should expect for people who are neither rich nor poor.
I happen to subscribe to the latter philosophy. The middle class is whatever range of incomes it takes in a given city adjusted for cost of living to own a modest home and save significantly for retirement. SF's median income can't do that.
That used to be how we defined the middle class a generation or two ago, back when home ownership and solid retirement plans were more common.
Nowadays it's less common to make enough income to support that lifestyle in many cities and people who can afford it are being increasingly referred to as rich.
I'm in software. My brother went into medicine. I don't talk about my job at home anymore, because both of us know what shitty perspectives he has in front of him for the next decade or so. I do what I can to support him (and the rest of my family), to make sure there are no stupid blockers hindering his growth opportunities. But I still can't really cope with the income potential difference. It's a topic we avoid talking about.
Medicine is one of the few fields besides software that seems to be doing very, very well, judging by how much of the U.S. GDP gets plowed into this sector every year.
So how is going into medicine a poor economic choice? I seem to be missing some information about the topic.
"What if people find out my husband only made 85 million last year." Note: That conversation actually happened and the person was worried about how they were going to cut back their lifestyle. With the clear implication that 85 million was just not enough.
>Primitive commodity money, like the magical words of non-literate society, can be a storehouse of power, and has often become the occasion of feverish economic activity. The natives of the South Seas, when they are so engaged, seek no economic advantage. Furious application to production may be followed by deliberate destruction of the products in order to achieve moral prestige...Potlatch is very widespread, especially where there is ease of food-gathering or food-production. For example, among the Northwest coast fishermen, or rice-planters of Borneo, huge surpluses are produced that have to be destroyed or class differences would arise that would destroy the traditional social order. In Borneo the traveler may see tons of rice exposed to rains in rituals, and great art constructions, involving tremendous efforts, smashed. At the same time, in these primitive societies, while money may release frantic energies in order to charge a bit of copper with magical prestige, it can buy very little. Rich and poor necessarily live in much the same manner. Today, in the electronic age, the richest man is reduced to having much the same entertainment, and even the same food and vehicles as the ordinary man.[1]
[1]Understanding Media, Ch. 14 Money: The Poor Man's Credit Card, Marshall McLuhan
Therein lies the problem it may be: we have become lost in abstraction and confuse money with real wealth. It's like we can never get enough because we are starving ourselves eating the menus instead of the dinner while at the same time not realizing that there is only so much dinner one can eat before becoming sick.
The more we rely upon abstraction, the more disconnected we become from the reality which that abstraction is supposed to represent.