For example, you post about political "ponerology (study of evil in politics)" ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10548272 ), and bring up economics often. You also have a non-trivial knowledge of US political history, as with this comment at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10404379 :
> That's false, because the Democratic party today encapsulates both the old Republican and the old Democratic party. Hillary Clinton is essentially an Eisenhower Republican (if you place her into any European country she's in their conservative party), and Warren/Sanders are the left wing group.
> The republican party of today is essentially a business lobby masquerading as a party. Place it into any European country, and it will be a far right extremist group.
Did you learn American political history from going to school at Dartmouth? I think it's odd you didn't learn about any of the pollution laws during that time.
You also have pretty firm ideas on the topic already, based on your comments at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10142290:
> The US is a dystopia, no surprises there. What a shame that all humans are anymore are an outpost of corporate greed.
and at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10440304 :
> The more I think about it, the more I believe that the United States is the worst place to live if you are poor.
> There are places that are poorer, hell I'm from a third world country. But I've never seen anyone in the third world show utter contempt for the poor. No one keeps reminding the poor that it's their fault. We call them "unfortunate", Americans call them "losers".
(I'll note that two people, one with experience from India - where you are from - and Bangladesh, and the other with experience from Islamabad, disagree.)
I see you are familiar with being downvoted, such as like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10411502 where you propose "We should engage in a culling of humans." Then again, perhaps I am simply part of the "political-myopia of tech culture" that you bemoaned about at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10516056 .
I start with the observation that your question here expresses an outsider naïveté which does not match your historical comments. I give evidence. I demonstrate that you have close knowledge of American culture - enough to have made firm statements on the topic. Indeed, you have made statements which already answer the question you've asked. I also commented that others have disagreed with your views, including through downvotes and personal experience.
I also gave details so that others might be able to answer your question while taking your views in mind.
I claimed I have no knowledge about it, and asked if someone else did. What is your problem with that? You aren't even contributing to the conversation. Do you honestly have nothing better to do than to attack random people on the internet? Please get a life.
Your comment history shows that you think the US is a distopia, and "the worst place to live if you are poor." If you really believe that, then why are you asking the question when you know the answer? The WaPo article title even includes "Poor communities across the country live with ‘extreme’ polluters", which is in line with your understanding of the US.
I do not see how I can contribute to the conversation when there appears to be a strong dichotomy between your question and your background understanding. But another way to contribute is to help other commenters understand where you're coming from. And of course, some conversations are not worth pursing.
Why would I think you are attacking random people? I never said that, nor is it something I believe. Though telling me to "Please get a life" does come close to being an attack, no?
FWIW, nearly every HN commenter, or at least those who post as often as you or I, has an inordinate amount of spare time.
Also, I see you've used "I'm out" before. As I mentioned earlier, you derided the 'political-myopia of tech culture' here on HN. Later in that thread, maxerickson at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10519360 wrote:
> I was pointing out that what you said about value was not an argument against economics (because economics doesn't care about what form value takes).
> You keep looking for a word other than value to describe this thing that you think should happen because then I can't point out that you can analyze it economically, but this is not a way to argue that education should not be analyzed economically, it is a misunderstanding of economics (it was really clear when stated as "Value" is not only monetary, but "we should do it just because" is still an imputation of value...).
You decided, incorrectly IMO, to describe it as "a last-word-mine argument", and ended the thread with "I'm out".
My interpretation of both exchanges is that you don't like it when people point out apparent inconsistencies in what you wrote.
(BTW, for those in the future who, like I, sometimes review someone's back history before commenting - hi!)
Then people learn heavy metals and other chemicals which leached into the soil are unhealthy. Some times people know about it and a superfund gets declared, other times it was forgotten and people find out many years later.
New developments in Mountain View[1], for example, sit on top of superfund sites. Some of which cannot be alleviated but rather "managed".
Hunter's point in Sf is another example. That was a navy shipyard with lots of lead heavy metals and other things from WWII war effort --but people eventually built out housing there.
[1]http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/mar/19/google-...
http://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/11/1/015...
They apparently analyzed population density near their outliers, but they don't discuss it. My general sense is that polluting industry will be located in areas with very low population density (these areas tend to be poorer than high density areas). To be clear, that's just speculation.
They also don't discuss the actual expected impact of the toxic outliers. The data they used to determine the outliers is government data about environmental release of toxic chemicals; there is at least the possibility that the releases are within sensible regulatory limits and don't pose a great deal of risk to the people nearby.
Note all the people commenting in this story that pollution of the Flint river is not a significant contributor to the problem in Flint, it's the pipes and the failure to adjust the PH of the water (here's the VTech professor that did a lot of the advocacy blaming the lack of corrosion control: http://flintwaterstudy.org/2015/09/commentary-mdeq-mistakes-... ).
DuPont knew for half a century that their chemical, PFOA, was poisonous to people and to drinking water, yet kept exposing their own workers and dumping it in places where it killed livestock, leeched into the soil and contaminated water supplies.
DuPont is still fighting regulations, and fighting thousands of personal injury lawsuits in court, one by one. It settled with the EPA for $16.5m — essentially nothing. The EPA's role is to regulate, but it is basically powerless to do so.
Meanwhile, PFOA and related fluorochemicals are now apparently present in the bloodstream of almost all animals and people on Earth — including everyone on HN — as well as much of our drinking water.
[1] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/10/magazine/the-lawyer-who-be...
[1]http://www.alternet.org/books/how-corporations-dump-their-to...