The second paper you've linked, the systematic review, is actually mostly in favor of a vegan diet. How does that raise questions about consuming animal fat and CHD?
The second paper you've linked, the systematic review, is actually mostly in favor of a vegan diet. How does that raise questions about consuming animal fat and CHD?
The second paper draws distinctions between several forms of fat hilighting the weak evidentiary link between most fats and CHD. Trans fats are an obvious exception. I posted it in response to the claim that low-fat diets are almost certainly healthier. At the very least, that paper reveals that eating meat isn't incompatible with longevity and good health, contrary to claims you've been making all over this comments section.
But since you asked, here's what 5s on sci-hub revealed, clicking literally on the first two links without looking:
- http://goo.gl/tWB3LA // Maternal vegan diet causing a serious infantile neurological disorder due to vitamin B12 deficiency
- http://search.proquest.com.sci-hub.io/docview/197420736?pq-o... // yeah, ok, it's raw-vegan, but the B12 issue applies to all vegans (as noted in the refs of paper 1), especially since many can't seem to distinguish between B12 contents and bioavailable B12 ...
To be clear, my claim isn't that vegan diets are unhealthy. Rather, it's that we don't really know much due to the poor state of nutritional epidemiology, and that there's at least some evidence showing that veganism is really hard to get right.
Also, the B12 boogeyman? Just take a weekly supplement and be fine.
The point wasn't to do a systematic review of the literature, but rather to counter your argument whereby those skeptical of the lipid hypothesis are equivalent to climate change deniers.
If you're actually interested in this stuff, I invite you to cultivate a genuine interest in the matter and use this nifty little link to get to all the paywalled papers your heart desires: http://sci-hub.io/
Further, I'd be happy to share what I think good guidelines are for separating wheat from chaff in nutritional epidemiology studies.
>Also, the B12 boogeyman? Just take a weekly supplement and be fine.
I mean no disrespect, but I find this answer to be as comical as it is widespread. In one fell swoop, you've (A) implied that vegan diets are not balanced (B) ignored the body of literature surrounding the (possible) toxicity of artificial vitamins (C) undermined your sustainability argument. Moreover, B12 is but one example; I again invite you to make liberal use of sci-hub, pubmed and google scholar.
Or just eat a couple spoonfuls of nutritional yeast every day.
And no one ever died or had their brains explode from being on the South Beach Diet.
B12 deficiency manifests itself as acute and irreversible nervous system damage. It's a fair question - do you notice when you don't get enough B12?
You can say the same thing for magnesium deficiency - it causes permanent damage over time. Furthermore, 75% of the population is deficient in it, and it's nearly impossible to detect and diagnose a deficiency. Your body doesn't tell you "hey, time to eat some magnesium" the way it tells you to eat food. Chances are you (yes, you) are deficient in magnesium, unless you take a supplement.
Yes, B12 deficiency is serious, but there are other equally important vitamins and minerals that even non-vegetarians are deficient in, whose symptoms are difficult to detect, and require supplementation to fix.
Vegetarian diets don't have the monopoly on required supplementation.