I just see a lot of... well... the post's title was honest and accurate. I see a lot of "scene" navel gazing the strikes me as just bizarre and defocusing. If I were in the Valley I'd worry that the "scene" would be overwhelming and distracting to the point that I'd run the risk of spending a lot of time pursuing vanity metrics and things that only matter within that scene.
The long term risk here is startups building around the startup scene and therefore becoming dependent upon the startup ecosystem itself. This kind of circularity and economic incest made the dot.com crash a lot worse than it might have been and it could happen again.