Maybe it's because the decentralized system is less efficient in combat with a more centralized one, which ends in arms race to total centralization?
For example, the First International was formed as a response to the more organized bourgeoisie, which often utilized the state repression apparatus against unions. And unions themselves formed as a reaction against organized wage labour.
But I think many leftists today are coming in favour of universal basic income. In the sense it is democratic, and democracy can be considered both centralized (we all agree on something) and decentralized (we all have the same amount of power). So I think the left is becoming more and more pro-democratic, which can be the solution to your conundrum.