What is the major problem you have that the iPad solves? That's precisely what the "naysayers" are asking, and aren't hearing any convincing replies.
* I want a simple, small, light tablet. Naysayers: You can't do Photoshop on it, so no one will want it.
* I want to give it to my mom so she can just browse, with no tech support. Naysayers: No moms are going to buy it, how many people will buy it for their moms?
Rinse. Repeat.