Of course, it's a different argument when your house starts making food for you, but but I think I'll still lean towards maintaining my current system.
Of course, it's a different argument when your house starts making food for you, but but I think I'll still lean towards maintaining my current system.
For example, my cable box comes with a remote that has a 'turn everything on' macro button. Except there's no integration, it just blasts the power toggle IR for the TV. Does it work? Yeah. Does it work well? No.
Buying a single brand and carefully selecting devices can help with that sort of thing, but it's BS you have to be careful to get any integration, it should just work.
I'd agree that a lot of the time it still doesn't work 'well' though.
The sad thing is that it is so easy to imagine so much more. If the cable box provided the available programming as data, I could use whatever interface I wanted to access it. Instead, I'm stuck with their customer hostile crap (no way to hide channels, etc.).
Try installing new lights and switches in your house sometimes and come back and ask that again.
Not to mention, why do we want 120/240VAC to the controls rather than low voltage DC (less shock risk, less fire hazard, etc.)?
This is even more desirable in office buildings.
I've installed plenty of lights and light switches... I still don't see the problem. Either you have the requisite knowledge to do these things, or you hire an electrician who does. Furthermore, no fancy IoT device is going to remove the basic requirement for running wires to the light socket and (semi-optionally) from the socket to a switch. This is fine because it only has to be done once when a space is built.
I would much rather have simple and reliable wiring done once when my house is built than have to buy new light switches every two years because my old light switch is obsolete.
>Not to mention, why do we want 120/240VAC to the controls rather than low voltage DC (less shock risk, less fire hazard, etc.)?
Oh come on. the shock/fire risk of a properly installed light switch is indistinguishable from zero.
Not to mention that the whole project has cost just a few hundred dollars, and the results will last decades. Why would I ever want my house to jump on the high tech upgrade treadmill?*
*Call me back when you can sell me robotic chicken legs for my house. That would be awesome.
Because its simpler, and therefore both cheaper and less failure-prone, to run the actual power to the device through the switch.
We've had alternatives with a complexity cost for a long time; they are rarely preferred because the complexity cost is rarely justified.
IoT provides more alternatives with complexity costs, but doesn't really change the basic reality for most light switches.