At least in the US, the problem is that if you total the car during your lease, you owe the remaining value of the car. That makes leasing an absolutely horrible decision in the US--all the downside of buying a car with none of the upside.
How is the UK dealing with that?
Gap insurance has been a requirement for every lease contract I've ever signed. Which means that the difference is paid by insurance.
And no, leasing is sometimes an excellent decision, let's not be silly.
I have no ownership, it is an expense just like gas and insurance. I am buying the ability to get around freely and not indebting myself as I would with a purchase. At the end of 3 years I can simply walk away.
You can get a lease for a silly small amount of money if you play your cards right. Check out leasehackr.com . Right now I could walk into a Ford dealer and walk out with a Ford Fusion for $147/month. Or if I don't want to deal with gas I could get a Fiat 500e for $99/month. I spend more on coffee than that!
Leasing can be seen as a fixed payment that always gets you reliable, newish transportation with less hassle. Sure it costs more than buying a car and keeping it for ten years, but after taking my ten-year-old car to the shop and putting thousands into it, and after seeing that it lacked newer features like the car seat "LATCH" points, I see that driving a ten-year-old car is no panacea either and might not be worth the cost savings.
Modern cars are wildly more reliable than even 20 years ago, IMO. The 10-year old piece of crap I drove 15 years ago is not the same as the same as the 11-year old car my wife drives everyday.
The Fiat 500e lease example above is a great example because I'm only in for $3600 for 36 months. Name a car that you can purchase outright for $3600 that will never need unplanned service, replacement tires, etc.
I put 50-100,000 miles on cars that start with about 100,000 that I buy for $3000-$5000. I haven't needed much unplanned service, largely due to luck and buying well-maintained cars. When I am done with the car, I sell it for about $1000-$1500 less than I paid for it. And the insurance on these cars is MUCH cheaper than for a new car.
So by not "getting to" walk away at the end, my total cost is not $3600, but $1500. You could buy a car for $10000 and sell it at $6400 if you wanted a newer model.
But the big difference is that if I get laid off or have to file for disability or something, I have an asset that I can keep using instead of upgrading if I want, or sell if I need the money. A lease is a liability!
There's nothing wrong with leasing, particularly if you prefer (and have the means to readily afford) to always drive a car 0-3 years old. If you have that preference, leasing is often the best choice.
The real problem is that preference is a very expensive preference and is being opted into by many people who probably should be being more frugal.