a) is fine (which is what this "Gitmail" service provides), but shouldn't b) be preventable if you tied email addresses to the public keys uploaded by the user? So if I tried to push commits to Github with an email address that belongs to Linus Torvalds, Github should be able to reject the push based on the fact that I authenticated with a key pair that is not in Torvalds' keys.
(Perhaps I don't understand the way in which git pushes work well enough?)