Agreed. The H1B push seems to be solving a short term problem while leaving our domestic educational problems unaddressed.
From looking at international rankings it looks like the domestic educational problems are more in the middle and high-school level. The Universities are doing great.
If it's the professors all hope is lost, since future professors will be taught by the people who are currently dropping the ball.
We may have quality teaching, but we are not educating ourselves.
It's also possible that the reason the top Universities are at the top is that the top foreign students want to go there. That means giving Americans more preferential treatment may "break the spell" so to speak.